Flyer’s Pizza & Subs

Fairly consistent, fresh and good. Dine in and get the free home made chips when they’re fresh. (If they’re not fresh don’t bother) small dining area but not usually that busy.

I ordered two pizzas for carryout. When I got there to pick them up one was wrong. Mistakes happen and I waited 15 minutes while they made a new one. There was no apology for the mistake. Replacement pizza comes out and it is still wrong. Again no apology and the manager on duty overheard there was a problem and quickly went in the back to avoid dealing with it. They offered to make a third pizza but I told them to just forget it and credit my card back for the pizza they got wrong. They told me they couldn’t issue a credit to my card but could give me store credit for a future order. I told them the credit needed to be issued to the card because I wasn’t paying for a pizza I didn’t get and after this horrible excuse for customer service I wouldn’t be back. They finally said they thought they issued the credit but had no way to give me a receipt to verify it. The one pizza they did manage to get right was now cold after sitting that long. Pizza was just average at best and service was the worst I have experienced in a long time at any dining establishment. Will not be back.

I got a gift certificate for $ 10.00 off anything I wanted from here and who can pass that up. We went inside to order take out there was a girl on the phone and another who was organizing the orders in the window. We were not greeted nor did either girl acknowledge us which I think they should get them to work on. We stood there for a couple and once the girl got off the phone she greeted us and we placed our order and she did suggest a side of mushrooms which I declined, but she did a good job. We ordered a large pepperoni with sausage which would have been $ 17, but was only $ 7 for us so great deal. We got through pizza quick and it was piping hot. I really enjoyed the crust and sweet sauce and plenty of cheese too, but there sausage was too spicy (not hot spicy) for my tummy. He liked the crust and pepperoni, but wanted more sauce and bigger chunks of sausage.
All in all I don’t trust the sides, but the pizza is much better and I will order again.

I had a great experience at this location. They were very patient with me as I tried to find my coupon unsuccessfully. However paying the regular price wasn’t an issue with the employees friendliness. One girl (sorry I can’t remember your name!) spoke with me the whole time I was there about different things and mostly horror films since tis the season and because she is a film major. I found it a very pleasant experience as most places will just take your order bring your food and go about their way. As I was by myself, I really appreciated the friendliness. And the food was, of course, delicious!

Ordered Flyer’s pizza for the first time today and I didn’t know what to expect. After trying some of the other pizza locations in my general area I was not too pleased. But I am glad Flyer’s changed that.
I ordered a large sausage and black olive, a mini BLT, and an order of chocolate chip cookies. On both pizzas I asked for the original crust.
Everything was cooked perfectly, not undercooked, not over-​cooked. The lettuce and tomatoes on the BLT was fresh and crisp. The mayo was on the dough in place of a sauce and was not overbearing. The original crust is a medium thickness that was crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, and golden on the bottom (no cornmeal). The cookies were warm, and thick with big chunks of chocolate. I do not think they were homemade though.
Next time I will try their thin crust and wings. The BLT was good enough I will order it again.

Never actually went inside the location or personally ordered from them, but on occasion we would order a few pizzas from here for lunch and the taste was phenomenal, even more so after the slices went cold (who doesn’t love cold pizza)?

I wanted to love Flyers, but the crust is kind of chewy as if it weren’t completely cooked… and the sauce is a tad sweet for my taste.
I also despise greasy pizza. So much that I generally only order cheese only pizza. In my opinion, their pizza is nearly as greasy as a pan pizza from Pizza Hut.
I DID actually crave their Southwest Chicken pizza, but the last time we picked up a pie, the cashier told us they were going to drop the axe on the SW Chicken. What?! Well apparently it was «annoying to make». Omg…
Which brings me the final reason why I don’t love Flyers… the price. I feel like it’s a bit expensive for a pile of grease.
15 inch SW Chicken (Chicken, Green Peppers, Onions & Salsa) …$ 18
15 inch Cheese Pizza … $ 13.50
They also don’t ACTUALLY have a just a «cheese» pizza, the menu starts at a «one topping» pizza… (Cheese isn’t actually considered a topping, it usually just comes «standard»).

You have GOT to love Flyer’s Pizza. It’s a West Side Columbus/​Grove City thing. You either love Flyer’s on Hoover or PJ’s Pizza at Hall/​Norton.
Me, I’m a flyer’s man. A good, tasty pizza, not soggy with grease, not cracker-​thin, and it’s not one of those pizzas where you eat a slice and be grateful you got a few pepperoni with the whole loaf of Wonder Bread you just ate. The sauce is nice and sweet… great hot, great cold, and always spectacular with beer. Delivery is always on-​time or early… can’t beat Flyer’s.
I am, however, dinging them one star for their other menu items. The subs are passable (Gimme a King Don at that point), and everything else is bar food fare.
They should team up with Tammy’s. Get rid of all their sides, Tammy’s sell Flyer’s pizza, and Flyer’s sell Tammy’s sides. THAT would rule.