Cake Creations

It was awesome! I went to cake creations a few days before the birthday party and they worked so well with me. The cake came out better than what I expected, all for a fair price.

I called Cake Creations at the last minute to place a cake order and I am so happy I did. They were so helpful, they accommodated my last-​minute request, and they made it really special and wonderful. On top of that, the cake was DELICIOUS. I immediately ordered my next cake needed for the following week and will be ordering from this bakery for every need from this point on. :)

The cupcakes are very well decorated but do not taste as good as they look. Its a small store with much organization but when I buy cupcakes, I want them to taste good more than just look good

I got their sugar cookies from Hilliardfest and they were adorable. That was all they had going for them. They were dry and had no flavor. My two kids, who eat anything with sugar, took one bite each and proclaimed them yucky. Very disappointed.

Cupcakes were awful. They taste exactly like a cake mix and the icing is bland and greasy like Crisco. They are pretty but taste terrible.

Needed a birthday cake and was unsure of what to get. They were very helpful in suggesting one and did an excellent job in creating the perfect cake for me. It was the hit of the party and made me a star. Thanks so much!

Beautiful and tasty cupcakes! I got 6 different kinds from buckeye, fruit filled, vanilla, chocolate, oreo, cinnamon and they were all yummy works of art! The staff is very friendly and I would reccomend Cake Creations to anyone wanting a sweet treat or cake made for a special occasion!

2.5 not quite a 3. We saw them at the farmers market and decided to give them a go. They had 3 packs with pre-​chosen cupcakes and honestly, I would’ve preferred to pick my own because between the 2 different kinds of 3 packs there were some in one I wanted and same with the other. We settled on the filled ones which had a red velvet (hubby’s favorite), a strawberry (ugh…would not have chosen that one) and a «buckeye.» This 3 pack are their most popular sellers. The ladies were very nice and told us we’d never have to go to another cupcake place again. That’s a tall order given all of the places we’ve tried and have fallen short but I admire the confidence in the product.
The prices are decent. $ 2 for non filled and $ 2.50 for filled. We paid $ 7 for the 3 pack. We got it home and thawed them since they were in a cooler. We split all 3 in half and got to tasting. We both did not like the strawberry one. Hubby ate the rest of his but I couldn’t. One bite and I was done. We tried the red velvet and it was okay but the hubby said that was not the cream cheese icing they said it was (thankfully! I hate cream cheese frosting) and the inside was filled with whipped cream. Meh. The buckeye, while good, really had no business being called a buckeye cupcake. A small drizzle of peanut butter glaze or whatever that was couldn’t be tasted over the rich, but good chocolate frosting. «But it’s filled!», you say. Yes it was… with whipped vanilla cream. (???) Their pamphlet says they have have peanut butter cream so why wouldn’t you fill your buckeye cupcake with the thing that makes a chocolate anything a buckeye?
We had high hopes but as with many places in C-​bus, they fell short for us. I wouldn’t steer people away from here, I just know for us, the search continues.

This place has the best cupcakes.
Be careful. It can be very addicting. I had to sneak out and replace cupcakes that I ate in secret!
Anyway…they have all kinds of flavors. Flavors for cake. Flavors for icing. And flavors for fillings. They are very pretty, too.
Twice, I have pre-​ordered from Cake Creations.
One was a cake for my mother-in-law’s birthday. They let us design the cake, so we had it made to look like a quilt (M-​i-​l is a quilter). They did a great job. I wasn’t delighted with the colors… then I found out that they did it in the colors that my husband had requested. And he liked it. And it WAS his mom’s cake.
The other time was for a party and I wanted a variety of cupcakes. They gave us at least two of every kind they packed, and made sure there were many many different kinds.
The hardest part here is that all their cupcakes are good, so it is hard to choose.
I think I like the red velvet ones best. Or the chocolate. Which chocolate? Don’t know… too many…