Which Wich

I have never eaten a bad sandwich here. You can have them add the most random combination of veggies and sauces and it always tastes amazing. I don’t know how they manage it. But i’m awfully happy they do. I always have either the black bean patty or crab salad sandwich. They taste sooooo good. Everyone must try this place out. The service is pretty quick. The only negative is their point system. But I guess that’s not the biggest deal when you look at a food place.

I came here for the first time tonight, and it exceeded expectations. I got the muffuletta because I love olives. They have a large selections of meats, cheeses and toppings and the toppings are more original than your typical subway items. The bread was tasty, and you have options for wraps or lettuce rolls as well. I will come back

So I was a bit hesitant to try this place because most places are limited to vegetarian options, thanks to the previous Unilocaler who posted a photo of the black bean sandwich. I love this place! They’ve bags for each type of sandwich, and then you pick your toppings, I got the black bean one, and it was absolutely amazing! I will be coming back here soon.

The cash register manboy was very helpful in explaining the process. His patience never faltered even after the third hour of me trying to pick the perfect combination of toppings to create a sandwich so great that it could wipe out ISIS with a single bite. I failed at this, obvs, but I will keep trying. You’re doing good things, Which Wich. Keep it up!

This place is very «Meh.» I tried it after seeing a Youtuber review them and I wasn’t very impressed at all. I ordered a Turkey Club on white bread and I added caramelized onions. The sandwich was very dry even with mayo added. The chips weren’t anything special. However I ordered my son a toasted PB&J and it was freakin excellent, you can’t go wrong with melted peanut butter. If I ever go back I will ask for a man-​sized PB&J…lol

While I usually am an «order off the menu, let the kitchen do their thing» kind of person, if we’re talking sandwiches, I can get a little particular – Did they hear me say extra pickle? Because I definitely said extra pickle.
For this reason, Which Wich is a dream for me. I get to do all of my hem-​ing and haw-​ing with my trusty sharpie and brown bag, while all of the decisive people who have their act together can fill theirs out and hop in line. Their turkey is surprisingly good, and their bread has the structural integrity I always look for in a good sub. Line has always been quick when I’ve been through, and the toppings are fresh and numerous.
Revolutionary? Probably not. But a good place to stop if you’re in Hilliard and need a quick sandwich.

I didn’t have a good experience at all. They got my order wrong, which I thought was impossible as I filled out the bag exactly the way I wanted my sandwich. The employee gave me attitude when I pointed out that they had put mayo on my order and no where did I check the box for mayo so they had to remake my food and it took them over 10 minutes to do so. The sandwich was very skimpy on the meat. For the price they charge, no thanks. I’ll be at jersey Mikes.

Wow! That was actually pretty good. I would recommend this place very highly. I got the Beef with jalapeños, garlic, oregano with the French dip. I will be back to try something different, but that beef with the dip was so delicious I may get that again. Friendly service too.

Probably one of the BEST Rueben’s I have ever had and I’ve ate a lot of them! Must try! Corn beef was perfect and the marbled rye was amazing!

A great sandwich shop the middle of a strip mall. At first, it is a little confusing on how to order, but eventually you figure it out. They have a wide array of sandwich possibilities with an even greater selection of toppings. What’s really neat, is you pick the bag of the sandwich you want and then just go crazy checking additional items you want on your sub (olives, lettuce, mayo etc). It is a fun experience and the food is delicious. When you are venturing over to the Westpointe Shopping plaza, and you’re done shopping at Gander Mountain and Wal Mart and want a unique sandwich experience, you should check out Which Wich.

I have always been hesitant to come to Which Which. I now know that it had been a huge mistake. I can’t speak for all the locations as this is my first time to a Which Which. But the staff mostly the cashier guy, was extremely friendly and helpful. This location is clean and tidy. As for the food I indulged in a shrimp bánh mi. I’ve had some before and in a 10 scale I would give it a 8. That’s high because personally I don’t give a lot of chain food restaurants anything higher than a 7 because of the quality of ingredients. Which which however surprised me one of the freshest sandwiches I’ve had in a while. I will be sure to recommend this location to my friends. I will take a pic next time as I was too busy not being able to put my Which down !

I’ve always found sub shops to be hit-​or-​miss (with chains like Subway getting more and more «miss» all the time), and though the price may be a little high at Which Wich, it’s kinda worth it for a fully customizable sandwich with such a HUGE array of options. Plus, I can only eat half a 7″ at a time, so it’s essentially two meals for me.
I got a chicken sub with tomato, avocado, delicious deli mustard, and a bunch of other stuff piled on. It tasted fantastic, was heated evenly, the bread wasn’t too toasted at one end and chewy at the other, and overall it was just a darn good sandwich.

This review is for the «Lettucewich» which I have attempted two times. It is terrible, sorry. They literally take a head of lettuce, or romaine, or whatever green it is, and tuck your ingredients inside the leaves. There is no wrapping involved, it is a badly made salad. It is impossible to eat, since it is so wide and not wrapped, so I had to individually pull off each leaf, put some ingredients on, and wrap it myself. It was a giant mess. I will give them two stars, because they have this option, and it TASTES good. But the way they make it is just terrible, and my friend who got a lettucewich as well agreed. If I ever go again, I will try to bowl option since that is essentially what I got, without a bowl to help me.
I highly recommend Jimmy John’s lettuce wraps. They are cheaper, tastier, and easy to eat.

Small bite for the price
Tried out Which Wich for lunch to see how it was. When I came in I had no idea how to order and the workers were no help. I eventually figured things out and placed my cheesesteak order to go. It did not take long and the sandwich was hot and fresh. It was however quite small and for $ 7.50 I would expect more. It tasted ok, nothing special or worth coming back for.

Before coming into this which wich, i was debating between this and taco bell.
Walking in, i assumed that offering a sandwich wouldn’t be that difficult. I was wrong. They have definitely over complicated the sandwich ordering game. You grab a brown bag with whatever meat you want then mark off what you want on it.
I decided on the Philly cheese steak because i love philly’s. I added provolone, banana peppers, onions, crushed red, and mayo. I was disappointed because this sandwich was 0% spicy when that’s what i really wanted.
The sandwich was pretty alright at best. Lacked flavor and the bread was very crumbley. Comparable size to a 6in sub from subway. But for $ 9 for a sandwich and drink is dumb!
The place was clean and the people were friendly but i still can’t get over that their motto is superior sandwiches and this sandwich was alright at best.
Step up your sandwich game which wich.

Which Which is the Mecca of grinder shops. It has a dizzying array of choices to build your own custom grinder. There are more choices for toppings, breads, meats, and condiments than any place I’ve seen, and since you can mix them up anyway you want, there’s an unlimited number of ways to make a grinder here.
For you Midwesterners, a grinder is a sub or a hoagie. Same thing. There’s a chain of restaurants here called W.G. Grinders and yet every time I order a damn grinder I have to tell you what it is. What’s up with that? Where I grew up we called them grinders but I still always knew what a sub and a hoagie is. Why don’t you know what a grinder or a hoagie is?
Anyway, the quality of the food at Which Which is top notch too. I’ve been here many times and every time the quality has been consistent no matter who’s working. It’s always put together neatly and perfectly and always delicious. Sometimes I feel like they don’t put enough on of some things but I’m sure I could ask for extra next time.
There are other places where the food compares to Which Which in quality but nobody compares for the number of choices and customizability.

Not too shabby!
Huge fan of the idea of writing your order down on the sack and then just waiting for a few minutes until they call your name.
I also like how many options there were for the wichs.
It seemed to me that it was locally owned by a Hilliard resident since their were kids working (assuming they were the owners) and the kids knew a bunch of other kids wearing Darby and Bradly gear. I like that they are investing in the community which they live in.
The only issue was, My wife and I ordered 2 large subs and 2 milk shakes, 35 bucks! Luckily the subs were large enough we were able to eat the other half for dinner the next day. But if we were really hungry…35 for 2 subs and shakes is a bit pricey, then again its much better than subway.

I like this place and I will be back.
I walked in and was greeted immediately and asked if this was my first time here which it was. One of the workers came over and showed me how their ordering system works. There are several types of sandwiches on the board that you can choose from, you pick which one (wich) you want and grab a bag for that particular one which has listed all the different topping choices, you check off what you want with a marker. I like this procedure because I am indecisive and could take as much time as I needed without holding someone up or feeling rushed.
I chose a monte cristo (turkey ham and grape jelly). I love a monte cristo, however, I would not order this sandwich from here again unless I could get the jelly on the side. I love a sweet and savory sandwich, however, I like the savory much better. I am used to adding my own jelly and because someone else does that for you, it was just too sweet for me.
I thought the meat was good, way better than subway becuase it tasted like meat instead of cardboard. And the portions were good. I ordered a 10″ sub which was $ 8.25 and had half for supper and half the next day for lunch which to me was a pretty good deal for the quality. I also like that they have a real oven the sandwich goes through if you choose it to be hot rather than a microwave!
I look forward to trying it again.

I heard good things, and it’s close to home, so I checked out their website and signed up/​got a coupon for a free sandwich with purchase of chips & drink. We went last night for dinner and were immediately greeted by a young lady who explained the procedure. They have paper sub sacks are sorted by sandwich type (chicken, seafood, vegetarian, etc.) with all the choices on them and you take a red sharpie and check off what you would like. They have separate order forms for shakes. Then you take your sack/​form to the counter and pay. When your order is ready you go to the counter to receive.
I like that they have 4 choices for a vegetarian sub; I chose the Caprese, on wheat, hot. It had mozza, tomatoes, and pesto. With a bag of chips and a yummy pineapple milkshake, it was a pretty good meal.
I would recommend checking this place out because it’s different, and they have lots of options on the menu. It is a little on the pricey side (the small sub is $ 5.50, and the medium milkshake is $ 4.00). The large sub is $ 11, but I did not see the actual size.
I’ll go back, because it’s kind of fun, and I don’t know anyplace else that serves pineapple milkshakes!

Watch out Sub joints because a new chain is in town. I really like the premise and entire set-​up of this place. This is chain from Dallas so some people are used to this but I was a first timer. Most people seemed to be first timers on a Sunday lunch.
Ordering: At least 10 different bags to choose from. I chose seafood, the wife wicked. The seafood had 5 different options for meat (Artichoke & Crab) then you choose your style: white, wheat, bowl, and lettuce (South Beach/​Atkins friendly). Do you want it hot or cold? Then choose toppings, sauces, and cheese. Pepperjack, tomato, hummus, spicy mayo, jalapeño, and cucumber. You fill all of this out on a bag just inside the restaurant. I love this for first timers as you have plenty of time to think without feeling pressured to order. i also can add as many toppings as I want without having the associate looking at me like I am a pig or annoying.
Prices and Food: $ 5.50 for a 7 inch and they actually put toppings to the edges without an inch of just crust. I hope they keep this up as I know they are just new so quality is priority. The 7 inch with half a medium milkshake was enough for lunch. The artichokes were nice large pieces and they don’t skimp on them like Piada tries to do to me. They have an option to put the house chips (kettle potato chips) on the sandwich as well. My wifer was very glad about this option. We both really enjoyed our meals. The wicked is about a dollar more for the 7 inch but it has a generous supply of meat. They serve warm choc chips cookies (fill out the survey on the receipt and bring back for a free one).
Staff: Very friendly and helpful staff. One of the franchise owners was at the door helping set everyone up. He said that they will keep someone by the door for the first month and whenever they get busy to help the first timers. They plan to open a few more in the Columbus area. Great concept, good food, friendly atmosphere will make this place work. I understand why it is one of the fastest growing chains.