Jonny D’s Pizza

My family and I just walked in, and we got ignored for a total of 5 minutes, no one attended to us, we were looked at wrong. terrible customer service, no one even spoke to us, we were standing in front of the counter like a bunch of statues… we are Latinos and as soon as we pulled up to the parking we were looked at wrongfully … I wish I can give this place zero stars. in conclusion we walked out after all that time standing and waiting for someone to take our order…

Very slow pick up service. The food taste good. But wish it was quick service to heat up a few slices. Maybe I’ll try one more time.

We gotten pizza at my job from here. I liked it.

Never disappointed. Love their eggplant parm rolls & calamari. Location is perfect. Great price.

Had 2 slices and some garlic knots and they were very good! Will eat here again soon.

Jonny d’s has amazing pizza. So much better than Jimmys. The buffalo slice Is so good. And the Greek salad slice is yummy. There garlic knots are ok, same as any other pizza place. The servers are pretty nice and there grandma slice is good

First time, great mushroom slice but. the counter girl came out with a big bottle of Windex and started spraying up the table directly next to me while I was eating. When I told the pizza guy about it, she started to laugh loudly. I doubt she would be laughing if she was trying to eat in a cloud of Windex!

A lot of people raved about Jonny D’s so I was eager to give it a try. Meh.
I got a large pie and a tossed salad. The pizza was ok, nothing great. A good N.Y. slice of pizza is eaten folded in half. I folded this and the front half of the pizza flopped over. It was slightly underdone.
The tossed salad… I have been getting salad from pizza joints my whole life. NEVER had it come with the dressing already on the salad. It’s ALWAYS on the side. This was swimming in dressing. It was already soggy by the time I got it home and no way will the leftovers survive until tomorrow.
So beware-​if you go to Jonny D’s order your pizza well done and your salad with the dressing in the side… and maybe your experience will be better than mine.

Decent pizza. Never tried the other food. No complaints. I like their mushroom slice. Give it a try, the mushrooms are fresh and not from a can like little v’s

food– delicious… grilled chicken is the best! Service is not good… don’t really care or pay attention
. I have been overcharged twice… by a lot and never said anything bc I was home by the time I realized… hire more responsible people that will run your business the way you would if you were there.

your usual italian pizzeria. good pizza, never ordered their food as most pizzerias dont have fresh food other than pizza. would definetly go back

For years this building was an automotive repair shop. Now it’s one of the better pizzerias in the Huntington Station area. In a weird spot next to the O’Connell funeral home, and not in what I would consider the greatest area ever, Jonny D’s makes a really good, consistently solid slice of pizza.
I’m probably starting to sound like a broken record, but the crust is perfect. The right thickness, perfectly cooked all the way through, and the cheese and sauce are just the right mix. The sauce is flavorful without being overbearing.
The service behind the counter is attentive and friendly. Everybody seems to enjoy what they’re doing which makes me enjoy coming in for my usual slices. Absolutely recommended.

After a couple of months searching for a pizza place we are really happy with the food at Johnnys. Calamari was a little to done for me but still good. Greek salad was absolutely delicious so many ingredients. Pizza crust was good. Sauce was good. Cooked just right. Staff was a little loud and childish but they are young. Place was clean so we will be back

Pizza is greasy. Workers unprofessional. Guy dropped the spatula on the ground and then used it to take out pizza slice! Yuck!!!

great pizza love the crust .best shrimp parm hero. every thing is fresh and seasoned just right

This place has the best pizza in the Huntington area! The ingredients are always fresh and the sauce is original. The other entrees are excellent as well, chicken Parmesan is worth trying.

This place is great. The pizza, for me, is exactly how it should be. Prices are reasonable. We always get our cheese slices and sausage/​pepper/​onion pies here. Our next meal will actually include some non-​pizza meals, but I don’t think we’re going to be disappointed. Highly recommend.

Couldn’t believe I have never heard of this place before when I was told about it. I have been so deprived! Love everything I’ve tried and staff is very friendly! Thought I posted this awhile ago, but it was stuck in draft form. We have gone several times since, though not tonight.

Quite a bit better than the overrated Little Vincent’s Pizza down the road. The large pie is indeed large, the sauce is just fine, they don’t skimp on the toppings and the pizza has a good, hearty crust. My wife and I split a tossed salad on our second order, which was surprisingly abundant with veggies. Can’t say much more as I’ve only ordered from here twice, but I think it says enough that I’ll be ordering from here again.

Since moving to huntington station i’ve been searching for a good pizza place. I didnt think it would be this hard! I finally found it at Jonny D’s though! They have a full menu and didn’t look at me funny when I ordered a pie with half no cheese.
My husband liked his half but said the sauce was a little on the bland side… I didn’t notice this.
I was bummed that they were closed on christmas eve… my family has a tradition of eating pizza on this day and I ended up having to go down to little vincents. I think Jonny D’s will be our local spot though.