Sahara Pizza

The staff was friendly and the pizza was delivered quickly! We were in a pinch for a community event and they were rockstars!

Tried a couple of times, not the type of pie I like I guess.

Stick with the cheese bread and you are solid. For 7 bucks you get everything you need. Been ordering it for 5+ years. Their pizza is greasy, but that’s pizza on an island… Sauce is better.

After a terrible first time we attempted one more time. The staff were friendly and made sure to take the time to make the pizza right and fresh. Not bad the 2^nd time around.

Sahara Pizza generously donated to a community event. Their cheese and pepperoni pizzas were ready on time and delicious. The 5 stars are for their community involvement and support. Anthony was a pleasure to work with and they have earned my repeat business.

We gave Sahara another try last night after talking with manager. He assured us the long delay last time wouldn’t happen again. He was good to his word. We received our pizza this time in under 30 minutes! It was hot and cheesy and delicious! Thanks again Anthony.

Solid pizza choice, absolutely friendly and efficient employees. They keep on earning my repeat business!

Sahara Pizza is pretty good pizza. I love the Landmark & chicken fettuccine alfredo pasta! So good. They do delivery & carry out.

Literally the worst pizza I’ve had in years. I had two different ones — pepperoni and pineapple, and veggie. Cardboard-​like crust. Flavorless.
It’s hard to make a bad pizza, but Sahara does it.

I absolutely love Sahara pizza and Anthony he is so good to work with me I have allergies and he makes sure I get the right pizza and everything. The pizzas are fabulous thank you Sahara pizza thank you Anthony

Ordered a Jungle Vegetable, large size 16″ for a late supper. It was nasty! I ordered online, and made a mistake, ordered this pie instead of a Pumba. White sauce, blah, undercooked onions, yuk, and even though it was stuffed with veggies, the tomatoes were on the MIA side, and overall it was completely tasteless (unless one had a marinated artichoke in the veg mix.) For a total of $ 35 (tax, tip, delivery fee of $ 1.75) I could have done better elsewhere. I think the only pizza I’ve ever had at Sahara which I’ve actually enjoyed is their plain cheese pizza. Lesson learned again.

The customer service you will get is OK, the delivery time is OK, but honestly the pizza doesn’t taste all that good for the price that you have to pay for it.

To be honest, I don’t know why the ratings here are so bad. I never had a bad experience from them ever and I’ve been coming for years. The pizzas we get have plenty of toppings, the bread is soft, the veggies are fresh and the workers are fast with delivery. The food ALWAYS come in hot for me and they can adjust things to your convenience. IF they DO make a mistake, they will increase the size of your pizza from medium to large or give you a complementary wings, bread, etc. i think they have pretty good customer service. Sure, they made a few mistakes before but they always added extra food for us, like another pizza or something. I still think this place is better than Mo’s or any other pizza place on Mercer Island.

Sooooo fucking bad. Tastes bad, price is bad, service is bad… Allow me to share my horror story…
I’ve lived on Mercer Island for 4 years now and I’ve always made an effort to go off island to get Domino’s due to the high volume of negative feedback I hear about Sahara’s. This weekend, I decided that I wasn’t feeling like driving to Domino’s and called up Sahara’s for a medium pizza and 10 chicken wings delivered to my house. The order came out costing a surprisingly cheap $ 31 for a greasy pizza and some overly sauced wings (sarcasm).
But still, at this point I was like whatever, really not feeling like going out today so I’ll just shell out 31 bucks and wait for the delivery. NOPE. «sir, delivery will take about ONE HOUR and 45 minutes». Anyone who’s been to Mercer Island knows that it ain’t the damn New York City. I can drive around this island 3 – 4 times in ONE HOUR and 45 minutes. They then tell me that «pick up will be way faster, about 10 – 15 minutes»…LIES. Foolishly I believed them and started driving towards Sahara’s — the one thing that I was trying to avoid that day.
When I arrived at this sorry establishment it was already filled with a room of unhappy customers. Half an hour later my food still isn’t ready, so at this point a total of 45 minutes has passed since I initially called in. I overhear a complaining customer who had called in over TWO HOURS before and still hasn’t received his order…
About 50 minutes later I get my medium pizza and 10 chicken wings, which all tasted like shit. The chickens were just any plain regular chicken DRENCHED in WAY TOO MUCH sauce. The pizza fucking fell apart, the onion was completely raw… ugh
Will never go back there. I mean I don’t want to sound stingy but $ 28 (they took off $ 3 for the long wait) for shitty food, shitty service and an overall shitty experience is just not worth it. I hope no one else goes through what I went through.

I have been regular customer Couple years now.
I guarantee u they have best pizza in Seattle
They have some unique items as well like tiki tiki.
During the lunch time, they sell personal pizza too. I recommend chicken bacon ranch which is you should try. It’s amazing!!! their wings also great quality as well.

Absolutely horrible. I could not understand a thing what the guy who picked up the phone was saying when I called to order. Pizza looked and tasted bad. It tasted like a piece of cardboard with stale tomato sauce on it. You could do better with a frozen pizza from QFC, definitely with one from the Whole Foods. Hello Pizza Hut!
Sahara pizza was pretty decent even one year ago. Something happened and everything went south. I am not ordering another pizza from this joint.

Barely one star: Tasteless, under-​topped, really expensive, made the mistake of adding a bitter Caesar salad. One of the basics of good pizza is a tasty crust. Tonight we ordered two pies and both had chewy, doughy crust, making it really difficult to eat as the cheese and toppings literally slid off onto my lap. In total the bill came to $ 47 plus a healthy tip. My tip to you, fellow Unilocalers, if you want pizza on Mercer Island, look elsewhere.

Not good. Sauce is too sweet, barely any toppings, crust was too dry. Save $ 5.00 on a large pizza and order from Roberto’s, which is better.

Eat here at least once a week for lunch. Solid pizza with a good crust and plenty of quality toppings. Service has always been fast and friendly. Fair price point for the quality. Would be cool to see some kind of frequent diner program.

I wasn’t expecting anything special at this strip mall pizza joint. I brought in an older autistic child i work with who tends to be flighty and prone to snatching things. Not only did Sahara’s staff provide excellent customer service, but they were understanding of my companion, got our pizza to us promptly, and tossed dough to one another to keep us entertained while we waited. The pizza was delicious. We had half pepperoni olive and half Hawaiian, everything about it was perfect.
I will definitely seek out Ssahara Pizza in the future.