Jimmy John’s

Don’t believe the commercials when it comes to this place. Waited over 90 minutes for my sandwich today. I called after an hour and the guy on the phone was a real punk a$$. If you can’t get a sandwich delivered two miles in an hour and a half, at least don’t be a jerk when I call to find out what’s up.

So much for freaky fast. We ordered 43 minutes ago and are still waiting… I just called and was told «the driver should be on his way». Finally showed up 46 minutes later, as we are about to walk out the door to leave.

Waited 45 minutes for my sandwich. Called the store and the worker was polite, but there’s no excuse for taking 45 minutes to deliver a sandwich. If you’re running that far behind on orders, hire more people.

Jimmy John’s is probably my favorite place for quick subs in Madison/​Middleton. They are unbelievably quick, and their sandwiches are good as well. The prices are decent, too.
Of course you’re not going to be given a gourmet sandwich, but from what you expect, the product is great.

Sandwiches were delicious but service was lacking. I bought 5 subs with chips and cookies. The cashier handed me a bag and I was expected to bag all my stuff on my own. I realize that this sounds extremely petty but it just portrayed rude and lazy service in my opinion. I would expect a little more friendly assistance at a sub shop.

Jimmy John’s just opened in Middleton. I can’t say that Middleton was lacking in sub places, but they’re a welcome addition regardless.
As you would expect from a chain, this location does not differ at all from the other locations. They have a reasonably-​sized menu and you don’t get many options in terms of customizing your sandwich. So, if you’re lucky enough to arrive when there are no other customers, your sandwich will be ready in about a minute.
Their subs are tasty but not out-​of-​this-​world. They never have any kind of special, limited-​time subs, and the menu is very unadventurous (no «Buffalo Chicken Bacon Chipotle Club Supreme!!!»), so if you went there every day you would be bored after two weeks. If you’re hungry, I recommend the Italian Night Club (probably the best chain Italian sub anywhere) or the Hunter’s Club (not great-​quality roast beef, but a lot of it). If you’re not very hungry (or, as my Mom says, you have a bird-​like appetite), go for the JJBLT.
JJ’s uses only Hellman’s mayo, which, as far as I’m concerned, is the only mayo which is fit for human ingestion. They also only use provolone cheese, which is actually saltier and less cheeselike than Subway’s provolone. So those two cancel each other out.
Normally I would give only three stars, but as this location seems friendlier and faster than other Jimmy Johnses, I awarded them an extra star. I am normally do not appropriate stars in such a generous manner, but the situation warrants it. Now I have to deal with the fact that when I went to Middleton High School, the only restaurants within walking distance were China Wok and Taco Johns (RIP in peace), while the spoiled brats these days get a JJ’s and an entire organic grocery store. Grrr.