Tara Leigh Cakes

Was so disappointed with our purchase from this bakery! Read the reviews and got a personal recommendation to order from here and the product we received in no way reflected such high praise. The cake was unfinished and messy and was missing three different design aspects we asked for. Upon emailing the owner she gave us a refund and offered us a store credit so we could give her a try again, and then never sent the certificate for the credit. She admitted she had too many orders the weekend we needed our initial cake and did not get to design the way she wanted, even though i had ordered a month in advance. Will pass on ordering from here again.
We tried the new location in middleton. I saw a that a new bakery was opening near my house and told my fiancé to stop in on his way home. I was unaware it was the same place. I have to tell you that even the baked goods in the bakery on the grand opening day STILL WEREN’T GOOD! He picked the churro cake slice and a double chocolate cookie sandwich with salted caramel buttercream. The cake was dry as a bone! The cookies were tasteless. Pass, pass, pass.

Happy to see a new bakery in my travels. What a disappointment! Stopped in to get something to go with my coffee and there was virtually nothing to choose from. Macarons, cannolis, and a couple of other items. Sorry, but empty cases are never a pretty site in a bakery…
Anyway, I did end up getting a few large cookies (choc chip and peanut butter), tasted them, but then ended up tossing them all. Not worth the calories…

Ordered 3 dz cupcakes for a baby shower I was hosting. They were fantastic! Everyone at the event (including the harder to please elders) LOVED the cupcakes! So many flavors of cake and icing from which to choose. I wanted a variety and chose six flavors and when I placed the order it was great to hear them say «sure, we can do that!» The cupcakes were nicely wrapped and tasted delicious! Super nice staff, great product and presentation!

Amazing !!! Grabbed a few pastries here on my way home from work. Delicious ! The bakery is so nice, decorated in French theme, and the woman was so nice, definitely visiting this bakery more often !!

Stopped in looking for macarons and even though there was almost nothing left at all there were still macarons! I had a raspberry one which was tasty and a maple one. Wow! The maple macaron was AWESOME! Also shared an Oreo trifle with my wife.
Wish we lived closer! :)

If your looking for the highest standard in pastries you need to look no further than Tara Leigh’s. Unique, home made, exquisitely tasting pastries! Every visit to Tara’s has been «OMG I’ve got to have it» Best French macarons I’ve ever had, crispy, chewy, flavorful and always a fresh variety of amazing flavors. Love the Eclairs too! The creative éclair flavors makes her reinvention of the éclair my new staple regardless of the flavor of the day! Their all amazing! The Opera cake is my sons favorite, rich, smooth, flavorful chocolate goodness-​party in your mouth. We also recently had Tara’s «Smores Cake»,
The only disappointment was that we didn’t order up a larger size, everyone wanted seconds, it was a big hit. The little torched marshmellows pressed into the layer of chocolate and encrusted graham crumbs was just perfection. Guess what I’m ordering up for my Birthday in an extra large! Ok, gotta say the Cannoli’s were top notch too! I’m Italian and know the Cannoli well. Looking forward to my next visit, if you do go to Tara’s you will not be disappointed!

This bakery just opened a couple of weeks ago and I have already been in twice! I picked up a cake (one that was in the case– I did not pre-​order… But she definitely takes orders) to bring to my family’s for Easter and they couldn’t stop raving over how delicious it was — completely devoured. As mentioned by another, it is tricky to find as her signage isn’t all up yet but it’s literally right next to Teresa’s. Great selection!