Isabella’s Millis

Wow, this place is a hidden gem! I live right around the corner and was finally able to get there while they were open. I got a large Italian grinder and a couple of LARGE pieces of pizza (they even let me pick!). The food was excellent, although the bread to meat ratio could have been a little less, I didn’t care because the bread was so damn good. The pizza was exceptional as well. The only thing holding me back from giving a full 5 stars is that their hours make it so tough for me to get there to enjoy it! Super friendly people serving great food. I’d recommend this place to anybody in the area!

Outstanding customer service. Immaculately clean interior. Friendly and relaxing atmosphere and fantastic sandwiches. Variety and large portions make this place an ace in Millis.

Their subs are amazing especially their Italian subs. That’s all I really get there because its soo good! The sicilian style pizza is really good also. The people who work there are always friendly. Overall a great place to eat!

Great sandwiches, friendly staff. Wish their hours were extended later at night. We love their pizza and have to pick it up by 7pm.

Have to say love little hidden gems like this when driving along the road. Glad we stopped here and will be back again when driving though Millis again.
Service was absolutely phenomenal fast, attentive, clean, right on top of things.
Food was amazing for sandwiches only use boar meats which is good but over priced. But in this place for the amount of stuff they put on there sandwiches it’s not bad at all.
It’s time inside but cozy with limited bistro type seating outside as well.
Everything is freshly made and bread is as well. So soft and don’t just right.
Prices are fair and reasonable I think and one of the better prices I have seen in awhile.

Isabella’s is a great sub shop. I try to visit Isabella’s every week or so for lunch as it is right down the street from my Office.
The Pizza, subs and Calzones will also make anyones day better. They use perka and punch cards for free subs and pizza and I think coffee.
The pulled pork subs with onion rings are amazing and I recommend them to anyone.

Used to go there a lot more when it was in Medfield. Then they sold the place –_​_​_​–
They had the best sandwiches anywhere and I was so sad to see their shop become an abomination afterwards.
Though I’m happy they’re back. Except now it’s 20 minutes out of my way to go visit them. Worth the trip, but can’t realistically go as often as I want.
I usually get the Mayflower or Ruben. Both super yummy. Racking up the Perks points! The shop is small and cozy. A few tables and always people inside. Definitely should try it out if you’re in the area.

I’ve tried several of their sandwiches, and they have all been great. The buffalo chicken pizza is really good too.

Went today fire lunch and got the mayflower sandwich. (Turkey, stuffing, cranberry sauce, and mayo) the best was excellent and the cranberry sauce seemed fresh and not canned. The price is average and they have a lot of extras like deserts, sheet pizza salads, etc.
This is my second time here, both times have been good.

Great place, one of my favorites, definitely the best sandwich shop in town and then some. Great owner and family oriented business had a chain and then centralized to my hometown boy were we lucky.

Subs are stuffed while still being well-​crafted. I love the giant chalkboard with all the types of subs although I don’t really need it because I always get their version of the Mayflower. You could get a different sub every day of the month from here!
They also have calzones and salads, and delicious Italian desserts. The pricing is pretty good for the portions and I’ve never had a customer service issue. It’s a tiny little place with not much atmosphere, so we only pick up from there.
My boyfriend loves the meatball sub, it always comes super warm and with just the right amount of cheese. Steer clear of the steak and cheese though, as it’s poor quality and has almost no steak.

With over 60+ sandwich choices-​this place is a sandwich lover’s heaven. The bread really makes these sandwiches fantastic — think soft, fluffy, and melt in your mouth. All sandwiches come in 3 different sizes, depending on how hungry you are, however don’t worry, none will break the bank. There are small tables to eat inside but this place has no ambience so it’s definitely the pick-​up and go type of place. This place is awesome. 5 stars hands-​down!

The lines can be long, but it is worth the wait if you want some pizza that make Papa Gino’s look like frozen food special. I have never had anything here besides the pizza. I will drive out of my way just for their pizza. This maybe some of the best sheet pizza East of the Mississippi River!!! Worth the drive from anywhere. Skip all the houses of pizza you will see on your drive to Isabella’s

Simi Pesto Chicken is tasty. Great Rolls.
I love this food.

I love Isabellas, best sandwiches around. I don’t really care if they microwave some sandwiches, I hope they never close EVER. Pizza is also delicious and they always let me pick out which piece I want.

They microwaved my Reuben. Never going back there again.

We looooove Isabella’s. They have great sandwiches. Actually who am I kidding, I’ve only tried one, the Simi’s Pesto Chicken and I like it so much I get it EVERY single time I go even though I tell myself I’m going to try something new. However the BF has tried several of the sandwiches and has always been happy with them. Bonus — they have a sandwich punch card where you can get a free sandwich after buying 9. And yes I’m on my second card… stop judging me.
Where this place sets themselves apart is in their to-​go meals. I always stop here whenever a friend has a baby (which is pretty much weekly) and pick up the chicken parm, eggplant parm, and a baked ziti. It’s always a big hit and they won’t have to cook for days (it’s just as good heated up the next day). I would definitely recommend calling ahead if you are looking for something specific. Usually if they don’t have they will make it for you.
They also have pizzagaina during the Easter season that rivals my in-​laws homemade pies (and it sure beats hand chopping all that meat…)
Definitely check this place out, the food is good and you’re supporting a locally owned family business.

AMAZING sandwiches and prepared food! Love their marinara sauce and meat balls. I’ve been eating Isabella’s since 2005. This family knows what it’s all about! First stop for catering needs. Their rolls are the BEST in the area. No joke. Great new location. Keep it up! :0)

Excellent sandwiches and pizza. Quality ingredients.

Great local spot. Very fresh ingredients and interesting sandwich. Even the basics (Italian sub etc) are way better then the offering at the other local pizza joints. Great soups The also sell Boars Head coldcuts at competitive prices.