Sully’s Pizza & Calzones

We were visiting Seattle and went to the Boeing production facility tour in Everett, WA. After our tour, we checked Unilocal for a nearby restaurant and saw that Sully’s had good ratings so we drove over there. It’s only about a 10 minute drive from Boeing. All three of us thought the combination pizza was outstanding. The crust was just right and they don’t skimp on the toppings. The woman working that day was Alise and she was very friendly and helpful. All three of us would highly recommend Sully’s for a pizza. Thanks, Rob

Had myself a calzone here today! It was soooooo good! I’ll definitely be back for more!

Spicey calzone bread 5 stars. Don’t let the name scare you the bread is not spicy, the sauce is mild. The mozzarella inside is very tasty.
Spicy wings are baked 3 stars. Well cooked and a little spicy. Not knocking a point off because PNW doesn’t have good wings.
The Sully pizza 5 stars. Pepperoni has great flavor, sausage is incredible. Perfect crust, crispy yet soft in the middle.
Hawaiian pizza 5 stars. The Canadian bacon is awesome.
Nice job. 2 beers, 2 apps, a large Hawaiian, a 12″ Sully. $ 67.67 before tip.

This place is awesome. Really tiny hole in the wall place, had a cute, homey vibe to it. The food is good, but the people are what really make it great.
We’re from Seattle but were exploring on our way home from the Tulip festival, and this place is right off the ferry. We had the back patio all to ourselves at one point, which was nice. The waiter was super friendly and genuinely interested in our day. He was sad for us when we told him we had already had pie that day and weren’t gonna get their signature peanut butter pie for dessert, but we assured him we’d try to make it back for the pie some time.
As we were leaving, he caught us out the door with a small box and said «I couldn’t let you guys leave without trying it, enjoy!»
Gestures like that will always convert a place from good to great for me. We were already planning on coming back to the town, and now we will absolutely be sure to go back to Sully’s when we are in town!

First time at Sully’s. Cute little restaraunt with great service. I always like finding places that have yummy gluten free options. I had the Mediterranean pizza on a GF crust. Awesome thin crust with loads of toppings. Definitely a place I will visit again.

Very good pizza here! We have eaten here three times so far, no disappointments. Still searching for the best ordering combination for our family to satisfy everyone’s dietary needs (one gluten free, and two fussy kids). Short of ordering 4 different pizzas ($$$$), doesn’t look there are many other options?

We had the best meal, and amazing server. Thanks for making these LA girls feel welcome! It was wonderful!!!

Decent place, family friendly. Pizza was good, nothing exceptional. Had the Mediterranean pizza and was Good, definitely better than the chains. Stopped there after a visit to the Boeing factory. Recommended!

First time here and not my last. Caesar, chop and Greek salads were fresh. The appeteaser of spicy thin calzone w salsa (odd mix but totally worked) wetted our appetite for our meal. My daughter had the Hawaiian calzone and I went for Sicilian. Talk about dreamy! The pie crust married w fresh ingredients melted in my mouth. After our meal and despite the amount consumed, I don’t feel weighed down. We will be back again and again…

Poor low quality food! Very disappointing! Kids food came last…
House salad served on plate not mixed– spinach with stems, not ripe tomato and grated cheese (House salad at Sullly’s)
one child pizza came last because burned the first time.
friendly server. She gets 5 stars!

The Darby calzone with jalapeños is the best with the Lucille ipa :0) this is my all time favorite pizza and calzone spot!!! Cozy atmosphere and great friendly staff! If you haven’t tried it, you’re missing out!

Fantastic pizza — try the Sully’s.
Remember to save room for the peanut butter pie.
Vey family friendly with a fun vibe.

We headed to Sully’s on the way home from the ferry with our dog. It popped up on a search of outdoor dining. Fantastic service. Delicious calzone and fresh key lime pie. The waitress brought water for our dog too. We will be back.

Came here at 7:30pm on Thursday. Had Mediterranean Calzone. First time since under the new ownership and renovation… We used to eat and have beer here a lot when it was Reilly’s.
New interior is warm, clean, like the new tables, and friendly. Now, the Calzone… I think, it’s better than before. Service ia good. Good to see it operating again.

Really light and bright décor. The brushed steel and warm woods really lent toward an upscale feel, while being warm and welcoming.
Good selection of beer on tap and nice wine selection.
Chop salad with chicken was delicious– chicken was tender grilled and well-​seasoned. Husband had the spicy Thai calzone — awesome chef touch was his name drawn in sauce on the top of the calzone — and the balance of spicy, savory and sweet was perfect.
Will come again — glad to see a place in the old DK spot with an interesting menu and I must try the dessert next time!
They are open til 10 on Friday and Saturday, 9pm on weekdays.

We went there on a Friday night and they were slammed from providing about 50 pizzas for a wedding across the street. Despite this the service was great! The pizza was awesome and my girlfriend got the Greek Salad and said it was one of the best ever.
Cons:
out of wings
I personally wasn’t a fan of most of the beers they had on tap
Definitely coming back and would recommend to others. I have been looking for a «small town pizza joint» in this area for awhile and I am glad I finally found this one!

Ordered an Italian Focaccia to go. Large portion, good focaccia. Tasty sandwich. Friendly staff.

I think the calzone is the reason to go here! The restaurant is new and still has some service issues to iron out, but I think the food helps make up for the kinks! I’ve also had the pizza and the not so chopped salad, but I prefer the calzone! I was visiting family and ate here 3 times during my week long stay. I do wish they had a few snappy lunch items just for convenience sake. The wine was tasty and they’ll let you taste test their local beers on tap. I love that they are a local business, supports local breweries… And some breweries by local people! I really hope they stick around! I’d love to go back and eat another calzone!

Awesome pizza and great service. Calzone was delicious too! We went on a Sunday evening and sat out on the patio.

We just moved nearby and heard about this new restaurant, and were excited to give it a try for the first time on Mother’s Day. The food was great, but service was a bit slow and rocky. It wasn’t a big deal and we wouldn’t have minded at all, except that we have pretty little kids and appreciate when we can keep them from waiting too long and getting antsy. The server was a really nice high school senior and said it was only his third day at his first job, so we definitely understood.
That night, we had the Sully’s House salad and the Greek salad, and both were really delicious. We ordered a few different calzones and they were all great (the Sicilian was my favorite!) For dessert, we all shared both options. The vanilla crème brûlée cheesecake was good and had an untraditional crust (walnuts? cookie dough? I couldn’t figure it out). Next time, I will ask for no chocolate drizzle on the plate, since it overpowered the vanilla flavor. But if you want a little extra chocolate, it was perfect! The peanut butter pie was so, soooo good. The chocolate drizzle was just right on that one! Normally peanut butter pie has chocolate all over, but I loved that this one was just peanut butter. It was the perfect way to end the meal and we’ve been looking for excuses to go back just so we could have some more.
Luckily, we had visitors in town and we went to a concert at the Rosehill Community Center yesterday, so we took them to Sully’s afterward. A lot of other people had the same idea so it was busy and service was again a bit rocky and slow. But the company was good, the restaurant is very comfortable, the staff is friendly, and the food is great, so it’s worth it. If the service was snappier, I’d definitely give it 5 stars.
We all loved our salads and calzones again. Husband built his own with pepperoni, Italian sausage, ricotta, and sundried tomato and said it was amazing. He was so happy. This time, we ordered a whole peanut butter pie and took the rest home for late-​night snacks and breakfast! =) So good.
The restaurant has a lovely patio overlooking the beautiful rhododendron garden. You can just barely see the sound between the branches. If the bushes were trimmed just a little, it would be perfect. Both times we’ve gone, we sat inside next to the windows and it was really sunny and bright and got a bit hot. If there were some window treatments that cut the sun but not the view, it would really be perfect.
I’d definitely recommend this spot. Great for families, friends, for a date, for a light salad or meal, for dessert, or for few drinks and a pizza. Take your friends and keep it open!