Eagle Pizza

Eagles was super accommodating for our large group business lunch. The place is quite small and fills up quickly! We did make sure to call ahead and the turnaround was very quick on our pizzas which were very good! The pepperoni was just okay in my book but the «all the way» or whatever they call it here was FANTASTIC. The cut ham, small ground sausage… so good. The little dining room has a great feel for dining in and the self serve fountain drinks are great.

One of my favorite places for pizza in the area. The pizza is delicious, and prices are very reasonable. I’ve only eaten in the restaurant once, and didn’t care for all the kids and noise. But for carry-​out, it can’t be beat!

I would have given them more stars but the amount of 5 stars is misleading. The food is average and their customer service is horrible. They always have an attitude when you call in because they have a bunch of teens working who obviously don’t care. If they don’t give you the right food the managers aren’t even genuine about their apology. Flat out rude and I won’t waste my time coming back when there are a million other places with similar menus to give my money to.

A friend of mine has been telling me to try Eagles for a few months now. We both have an affinity for all things pizza. Last night I finally decided that it was time to quit letting the 15 minute drive dissuade me from going. So while out running a few errands, I ordered one pizza with sausage and pepperoni (recommended by my friend) and another with extra cheese and mushrooms. This may sound like a lot of pizza for one person and it is. Believe me. But I have a «roommate» and we like leftovers. This is a judgement-​free zone, ok?
At any rate, I paid for and collected the goods from a very nice woman at the register and was on my merry way. I drove home trying to ignore the pizza aromas filling my car until I was finally home and ready to dig in.
The crust is thin and ever so crispy. Not thin and crackery. Yeah, I just made that word up. They do not skimp on the toppings and the edge of the pizza had that almost-​burnt (crisp) cheese, which is my favorite part. Allow me to call out the sausage on that specific pizza. I was expecting an the sausage to be nothing but fennel seeds which just so happens to be one of my least favorite flavors. I was pleasantly surprised to discover this not the case! Just a good old fashioned, well-​seasoned sausage. And the price? No complaints here. I think it’s reasonable and worth every penny.
They work some magic in that kitchen and I was not disappointed. In fact, in my humble opinion, I can confidently say that this place is THE best pizza joint I’ve been to. I will definitely be back; probably ordering enough pizza to feed 2 families. I am not ashamed! This place is legit.

Eagles pizza is one of my favorite spots and they now accept credit cards! Went this past Saturday around 530 pm. I ordered a half cheese/​half pepperoni however apparently it was too loud because the server thought I said just pepperoni. .was kinda bummed about that.
Ordered a pint salad with Italian dressing and I was so disappointed! Only came with shredded lettuce, a pile of cheese and 1 pepperoni, 1 olive and 1 banana pepper. I thought it was a joke… nope, definitely wasn’t. This was the most horrific salad I have ever received from a pizza place! When I went up to the counter and asked for additional pepperoni, olives and banana peppers the server obviously wasn’t supposed to get it for me as she asked me to keep it shhhh and came back with a bowl of banana peppers. …The look on my face, priceless.
Eagle pizza– your italian salad is horrible and should be taken off the menu. So disappointed!
Pizza was okay today. Could have been cooked a few more minutes and really would have liked to have my half cheese. Disappointed and won’t be back for a while.
Step up your salad game, please!
Lord have mercy!

I have heard about this place for a number of years and never stopped by. My son and I ended up here because 62 BBQ sold out of food by 6:30. So, we decided to try Eagles legendary pizza. Boy am I glad we did. The pepperoni and onion was as good as any i have had.

Eagles Pizza is a New Albany classic. No frills just good pizza and quick service. Every time I order a pizza over the phone no matter how busy they are they say my order will be ready in 15 minutes. I head over and it’s always ready on time as promised.

After going gluten free with our family in January 2015, we’ve been looking for a good gluten free pizza. From what we’ve found the offerings are fare to mediocre… with the occasional good pizza here or there. Just tried Eagles gluten free pizza and it’s FANTASTIC!
Highly recommended whether you’re gluten free or not!

I used to think this place was good pizza… that was almost 20 years ago, now I find it to be overly greasy and pretty bland. It’s got a great location and the building is cool but there are far better pizza places around or heck even good old frozen Red Baron tops this option.

This pizza is by far the best in the area! make sure to get the thick crust/​deep dish, it’s amazing! The large salad is huge so if there is only 2 people dining you could definitely get away with a small. We get the «everything» toppings, it is literally like it says e v e r y t h i n g ! Staff is very friendly and dining room is very cute and clean!

I have been here several times for lunch. I always get the pizza which is great. The crust is thin but not cracker thin. The sauce has a bold flavor and they have never been lite on the toppings. The service is always friendly.
Don’t expect anything fancy. They use paper plates to give you an idea of the atmosphere. They are now taking credit cards which makes it nice to see. I always get a couple of cookies on the way out. I think this is just a nice family owned restaurant that is prefect for a low key pizza joint that the whole family can enjoy.

Food was great. We got the kickin’ chicken. Pretty reasonably priced. The eating area was cool.

I love the taco pizza, sausage and peperroni, and BBQ chicken. Now that they take credit card I no longer can complain about having to take cash. This place is awesome.

Since Christmas, they have begun to accept credit cards. You no longer have to use the ATM, or paper checks.

Love Eagles — get the thick crust. Pep and mushroom is killer. Great family place.
CASH ONLY!

Old-​school small-​town pizza joint. Cash only, order at the counter, historic building, local history on the walls. Very friendly, pleasant service. Taco pizza wasn’t the best I’ve ever had and far from unique, but was quite good. For local charm in a family-​friendly environment, this place is hard to beat.

Great pizza. The sausage is my favorite. The only thing keeping them from a five is the seating is pretty cramped also not taking credit or debt in 2014 is pretty ridiculous.

LOVE this place! Their pizzas are a killer deal! We usually have to order 2 pizzas to feed our family. When we order 2 from Eagles, we always get stuffed and still have some left over! Love their crispy thin crust, and they always pile on the toppings. It’s ‘no frills’ which keeps the prices low. No delivery, cash/​check only… I’m happy to drive over and pay cash for my yummy pizza in the plain white box!
And unlike a lot of NA locations, they have plenty of parking! Skip the delivery charge of other places, it’s worth it!

Best pizza in town… try the pep & saus pizza. Crust and ingredients seem homemade & always fresh.
Sure, no delivery & no plastic, but I know a few places back home still like that. Its a shock for first-​timers, but it’s worth the inconvenience.
UPDATE: They take credit cards now. And still have great pizza & wings!

Great pizza of 40 years experience so yummy
:-)