Casey’s Public House

Nice big casual pub type restaurant with plenty of booths. Service was just fine and the food was really tasty. They have specials and a Sunday brunch as well. The parking lot is right in front In a strip shopping center right on W Chester Pike

Great place, a staple of Newtown Square great atmosphere for the whole family, the menu has good variety, and the food is great, beer is cold what more could you ask for. The first Friday night if every month there is live entertainment, Rob is a very talented one man band, he packs the house with his following so you may want to call ahead for reservations on the first Friday of the month. Over all a great experience the owner is always on location and making sure everyone is satisfied, would recommend to everyone.

I’ve probably eaten at Casey’s twenty times over the years and generally have been pleased with the consistent quality of the food and service but what I got last night was not good on several levels.
The tone was set early when I ordered my drink (Diet Coke with lemon), it arrived with no lemon and something floating in the soda, not sure what it was but it looked like a piece of plastic…
Before my dinner arrived I got up to use the restroom and while in there, I witnessed the busboy that was working my section of the restaurant exit the bathroom’s only stall and quickly exit the bathroom without washing his hands (there is a sign above the sink instructing all employees to wash their hands). Luckily this gentleman didn’t deliver any food to my table because if he had I would have sent it back! That’s nasty!!! He did however bus our table when we were done eating. Hopefully he wasn’t handling any food back in the kitchen…
For dinner I ordered the black & blue salad, it’s a tossed salad with balsamic dressing, blue cheese, and topped with sliced blackened sirloin, I was asked how I wanted my steak cooked, I ordered medium rare. What I got instead was well done steak which was dry and cool to the touch which leads me to believe that it had been sitting for a while. I’ve ordered that salad a bunch of times, this is the first time I didn’t enjoy it.
We ordered off the kids menu for my children, it’s a nice selection of entrees and very reasonably priced but the selections we made were just brutal. We ordered the cheese flatbread and the macaroni and cheese. The macaroni and cheese is straight out of the box (not homemade), I’m thinking Kraft macaroni and cheese. The cheese flat bread was just ridiculous and tasted horrible. What we were expecting was a flat bread pizza, but what we got was this floppy rectangular shaped, flour tortilla looking thing that had a dab of bad marinara sauce smeared on it and a bunch of mozzarella cheese melted on top. It might have been microwaved because it was completely soft and floppy, not crisp, and when I checked the underside, it didn’t look like it was baked or toasted. My kids wanted no part of it and they’ll usually eat anything that slightly resembles pizza.
The other two folks in my group didn’t have any issues, they ordered a steak special and a crab cake sandwich and they were both very pleased.
I’m hoping what I experienced tonight was an aberration or just a bad night for Casey’s because I’ve always enjoyed going there.

Nice ale house type restaurant interior. The snapper soup lacked actual snapper! The French onion soup on the other hand was was an improvement. I had the roast pork with provolone and long fried hots. They lied… they weren’t hot. My wife had the Blackened Chicken which was a little dry and spicier than the hot pepper on my pork sandwich. The total bill for the two of us 1 cup snapper 1 french onion 1 pork sandwich 1 blackened chicken sandwich 1 draft beer 1 glass of wine was 43 dollars. I tad ffor the quality. Also the the bartender double as our waitress which became a little annoying.

This place., where the heck do I start… First off, if you’re contemplating trying this place please drive in the opposite direction. I came for «brunch» today and I swear I haven’t had heartburn like this in years. Our clueless waiter 100% was never trained in his job. We had to ask for everything, including ice in our drinks. When filing out tip/​signing he literally waited till we signed and immediately took it. Now everyone knows you drop the check off and wait till the guests leave to pick it up. The food was terrible, it’s pitch black inside. I would be scared to look back in that kitchen. Drive far far away, you’ll thank me later!

I didn’t expect the best meal of my life, but I really did expect better. My fiancé ordered wings and I the boneless nuggets. The wing sauce had so much butter that I couldn’t taste anything else. My nuggets were so hard and difficult to chew. I barely made it through half of them and couldn’t eat any more because I felt sick — and I hadn’t even eaten that much! My fiancé brought his wings home to put Franks on them because there was barely any hot sauce flavor. I don’t think we’ll be going back.

Was here a few times. Think the food is great. Had and pretty good bartender one time and a really horrible bartender the 2^nd time. But overall I give this place a thumbs up. More for the older crowd. Seemed clean and comfortable.

Excellent service. Our Bartender was 25 yrs new. Staff gets along with each other and makes even a first time visitor feel like Norm from Cheers.

I stopped in here for a fast bite between two work events and had a turkey club with fries on wheat. It was an ok sandwich, nothing to write home about and the fries were of the frozen ilk. Like other Casey’s the place was decorated in dark woods and has that bar/​saloon feel. Service is ok though not particularly friendly. It’s located In a West Chester Pike strip mall so parking can be a challenge here during business hours.

I LOVE this place. Friendly, clean and DELICIOUS. I love there salads. So fresh and delicious. Im needing one right now.

I’m just confused this this restaurant.
Some days it great other days it is terrible:(
I think finding a few reliable chefs would make all the difference.
The one night I ordered a a grilled cheese (that I waited a year for) and they literally melted the cheese on the bread in the microwave! It wasn’t even melted together.
Ugh.
I hope they get a new chef so they can get back to the delicious and reliable food tegu always had.

Can’t say I’m a fan. I was introduced to this place by my a co-​worker. To her defense, I was looking for something different on an indecisive lunch outing. The waiter might have hated his job. There was absolutely no enthusiasm for someone that I will assume might have wanted a great tip. Sucks because he could have had a lot of potential. The food was not great but it wasn’t horrible. I won’t be returning but if you have to eat, maybe your experience will be better than mine. Cheers

As regulars, we know the food here is not so great and the service can be a little unfriendly. However, it has been a consistent quick go to for our family for years.
Last night was the worst. Wiatress Penny could have cared less and was flippant and rude. Shrimp Cesar Salad had been waiting under the heat lamp long enough to be limp and dried out. Baked potato and mashed potatoes were stone cold. Raw oysters were warm and sandy! We will find another «go to» place! So sad.

Average at best. Cheap food but still overpriced. Soup tastes like Campbell’s from a can. Not fresh. Probably microwaved. Meh. Go somewhere else.

Fri ²⁄₇ & sun ²⁄₉ 1^st visit on long time and last forever. 2 P’s and bad ones
Let’s start with 1^st P that would be Pete. Just downright rude. We are at bar watching Villanova game. No power for 2 days decide to get out. Didn’t eat because food isn’t that great. 15 min into game the bartender turns on pebble peach pro am. Me and three other couples ask to out game back on. I ask Pete the owner his response was its on the tv behind you. That’s strike one. We left.
The 2^nd P is for Penny the Sunday bartender. If your not a regular your screwed with her. Got my first beer because she saw me walk in. By time I was done second beer she paid no attention because the regs all came in. 13min went by before she saw empty bottle and noticed my gf sitting. I was thinking about tapping bottle on bar. 1.00 top was all she got and not Penny more. I will sit in the dark before I got back.

Casey’s is a good, family friendly restaurant, and a nice place to go to if you would like to be a bar regular. They have a pretty big menu, but fish seems to be the best choice when going there. I always had food that tastes fresh, and never had bad time. My favorite thing on the menu is their French Onion Soup. It has been consistent for me for at least 10 years, and is one of my more favorite versions of the soup. Their prices are a little high, but they do have sandwich and salad choices. Plenty of appetizers to choose from, and never had an impolite server. If you want to just enjoy an easy, casual dining experience this is a good choice to go to.

My husband and I decided to try this place again even though we really didn’t like it the last time we went a few years ago. The menu is varied and looks great. For starters we took the waitress’ suggestion and ordered the muscles in red sauce. They were simply awful, undercooked and fishy tasting. When asked how we liked them we were honest with the waitress who returned them to the kitchen. Good news is they were removed from the bill.
For the main course my husband had the penne puttanesca, which he often orders out. I’m not sure how they managed it, but the pasta was truly tasteless! One good thing is that the pasta itself was not overcooked. I had blackened salmon, which I ordered medium rare. It was like shoe leather.
For dessert my husband had bread pudding, or should I say day old bread with a thin sauce poured on top. At this point we weren’t surprised. From what I’ve been told, if you go there stick to the sandwich and burger menus. As for us, we’d rather eat at home.

oh no… Caseys is not open during week days for breakfast anymore. :(
Weekends its crowded but the brunch includes those same great omlettets, Now you will find me at the Coffee Corner in Media for weekday breakfasts or maybe even the Country Kitchen in Edgemont

This is stepped up bar food, done pretty well. But every time I think about going there, I remember that they have those awful coated fries (like at burger king) and then I go somewhere else. PLEASE CHANGE the FRIES! Steak fries would be the perfect fit for this place but any other kind of fries (except for curly) would do. I don’t know if those coated fries are cheaper or last longer in the freezer or what but they’re terrible and I never frequent (nor recommend to friends) any restaurant that serves them.
Other than that, the place is cozy, comfortable, and kid friendly with a friendly and attentive staff. Its the kind of place I’d go for reasonable prime rib (with steak fries) or butterfly shrimp, or maybe a burger for lunch. But I won’t go back until they change the fries. Thank you for your attention.

Casey’s is an institution in this part of the western burbs. Of course that doesn’t mean it’s a great restaurant but is an OK restaurant. The atmosphere is dark with lots of booths. There is a medium sized horseshoe bar that also has three booths in the bar area. There are TVs around the bar but they are nothing special. This is not the best place to watch a game.
Speaking of the bar; it can get busy. It draws a mixed crowd that is older than most. They do free appetizers on slow weekdays to hopefully entice you to stay awhile. The beers are a selection of mostly domestics. The drinks are well made and priced normally for the area. I’ve used this bar to meet business associates in the area several times and it’s worked well.

The wife and I have eaten dinner here several times over several years. We have never had a bad meal, usually had an OK meal, and occasionally had a great meal. I have had amazing blackened prime rib and the wife has enjoyed excellent broiled scallops. The vegetable sides are usually pedestrian at best. The wait staff has been OK but certainly nothing special.
Casey’s has recently begun to open for breakfast seven days a week. I haven’t has a chance to try it yet but the menu on their website looks good.