Jarets Stuffed Cupcakes

Their cupcakes are just okay. I’ve had better cupcakes than this.

I moved to Nutley from Las Vegas 3 months ago.
I love all the little cafes and mom and pop restaurants.
Today me and my son came in and had a «moms favorite» and I ordered «the Nutley»
A little disappointed there was a more empowered chocolate taste than the Nutella.
I didn’t taste it at all actually.
I wouldn’t have gone back, but the young brunette girl at the counter was really sweet and friendly.
For the most part I give it a 5 star
Could use a little music, but finding parking was fine.
And my son was happy for the after school treat!
I later learned that thier cupcake truck was seen outside ShopRite and heard the driver purchased boxed cake mix

These cupcakes are what dreams are made of. I finally got the opportunity to try out a few cupcakes after hearing so many rave reviews from people in the area. I started with the nutley and after the first bite, I knew right away that I had uncovered a new addiction. The moist cupcakes make magnolia’s look like child’s play. I plan to return later this week for more.

I’d never say no to cupcakes, yet this may be the only place that I’d consider it. Why? The price simply does not translate to the quality of the cupcakes. Hopefully more reviewers try the chocolate frosting here. It literally is a duncan hines duplicate. I would not even be surprised if it actually is just duncan hines chocolate frosting whipped and looking pretty. The cake I must say on the cupcakes are moist, and this does tend to happen if they are filled. The filling is scarce for sure, and they make the cupcakes look much bigger than they actually are.
For a whopping $ 4 a cupcake, head to Sweet Avenue in Rutherford where you can easily taste the quality difference. To be honest, I’m not sure if these are even completely home made, and when I question this at $ 4 a pop, it is concerning. I am always underwhelmed by this place, and have given it a multitude of chances. When I spend $ 20 for 5 cupcakes, they better be damn good, and unfortunately they just aren’t. The only aspect keeping it from a 1-​star review for me is its very nice and passionate workers.

I hadn’t been in a while and craved cupcakes. I usually order mom’s favorite but they were out so I ordered the black and white, which was equally as tasty, and a red velvet for my dad. The cupcakes are still delicious but small. I remember a larger portioned cupcake for $ 3.50

So delicious.
When I’m overwhelmed with good flavor options I gamble and randomly pick one (unless it’s really terrible sounding, then I pick again.) I ended up with the Tres Leches which is «Vanilla Cupcake, Stuffed With Tres Leches Custard, Topped With Whipped Cream and a Cherry.»
I guess with the stuffing it becomes so moist it’s hard to take sensible bites. The whipped cream topping was so good too. Whenever I’ve gotten cupcakes from say a grocery store, I find the cupcake part to be dry and the frosting way too sweet I end up scraping most of it off. Every part of this was so tasty I ate it quicker than I was planning to.
It was empty when I went but it was difficult to find parking. I can’t fault them for that as it’s probably a prime location because it’s busy, but I almost gave up going until I found a spot on side street. It’s near Nutley High School so I imagine all the cool kids come by after school. If it’s not a problem for you to get parking and you come by, a definite must try.

Family owned Buisness, the best way to go… They make you feel like family. Plenty of cupcakes to chose from, and just the smell of the sugar makes you want all of them. This is the best dessert place in town. They also have Gluten Free cupcakes as well as lolicakes.

Best.cupcakes.ever.
Don’t miss out on this place — it lives up to the hype.
Just a suggestion — was there this morning for some Halloween cupcakes and there were not many to choose from. Hope you have a larger array around the winter holiday season.

This review is for their newest location — Hoboken. The space is small but it’s nicely located.
Impressive cupcake selection — I got 6 stuffed cupcakes for close to $ 20. The cakes were good but crumbled after the first bite. This made it a bit tricky to eat. I wasn’t a fan of the icing on any of the cupcakes. It tasted like the normal store bought frosting.
This will be a first and last for me. Ive been to many cupcake bakeries in the area and NYC and I’ve experienced better quality.

The BEST cupcakes you’ll find anywhere. Such an incredible selection you’re sure to please your crowd. I wouldn’t think of having a party or holiday without them. You can’t go wrong with the red velvet!

Great selection of flavors you are bound to find something to enjoy. I visited for the 1^st time and came with backup. The cannoli made a fantastic impression but not so much with the jazzy raz. I also tried the boston cream for good measure. The cupcakes were moist and balanced in flavor. Service with a big smile. We weren’t rushed to order and patrons were helpful in sharing there experience and suggested favorites.

Best cupcakes ever!!! My favorite was the pistachio cupcake! Very moist and a wide variety of cupcakes to choose from. They tasted fresh each and every time I purchased cupcakes.

Cupcakes are one of the most amazing things on earth, and they also happen to be something that I just can NOT live without.
I’m from NYC, but I frequently visit the booski in Bloomfield, as he’s relatively new to that area. So in other words, I’m not very privy to the «IT» spots in NJ.
One day I had a crazy sweet tooth, and I said to myself, I wonder where can I find a quality cupcake to fulfill my craving? I did some digging on Unilocal,and I stumbled upon Jarets. I told the boo all about it, and upon arriving to Jersey, we took a quick ride there.
Upon entry, we were greeted by a smiling young lady, and a large array of cupcakes in the refrigerated display case. I chose the peanut butter delight, he chose the boston cream. Amazing!!!
Fast forward to today, 6 months later. Jarets is apart of our weekly itinerary. «Jazzy Razz» lemon cupcake w/​raspberry filling, and vanilla icing for me, and the banana cream for him. Moist cake, delicious fillings, and creamy icing.
Never fails, and never disappoints. I love this place, bottom line.

Got the red velvet, the Nutely and the canolli and they were all amazing! They were fluffy and moist, and didn’t taste too sugary. I’ll definitely get cupcakes from here again!

Cup cakes are okay, the carrot cupcake is really good. .Friendly staff. A little bit pricey for a cup cakes. Nice and clean, very relaxing place. I ordered a cake once for a birthday and before I did I asked the lady if I can go order it 5 hours before they close to pick it up the next day Sunday, she told me with an attitude it needs to be now but I couldn’t because I was at work till 4. Another girl then gets on the phone real nice girl and I told her I would call back in 5 min to order the cake. I had to send my boyfriend to get it unbelievable
bad experience!

I decided to try Jarets’ cupcakes because a coworker raved about them. I finally tried them because I was in the neighborhood. For some reason, I expected the cupcakes to be dense since they are stuffed… but I was pleasantly surprised at how moist and soft they were! Loved the red velvet and instant carma. Will return soon!

Yum. Classic Vanilla w/​chocolate is my favorite. Love bringing these to parties, as everyone raves about how yummy they are!

I’m from New York but I found Jaret’s on good old Unilocal when we were visiting family in North Arlington. I wanted to bring over some cupcakes and decided to stop by and see what they were all about.
I have a major sweet tooth and have had cupcakes from virtually everywhere. I can honestly say that Jarett’s were one of the absolute best that I’ve ever had. They had a great variety of different flavors, the frosting was the most creamy and smooth frosting ever, and the cake part of the cupcakes was just perfect.
Priscilla who was behind the counter was so helpful and patient. (We came in a few minutes before they were closing). She gave us recommendations and was just very sweet as i was being indecisive and couldn’t figure out which cupcakes to get.
Everyone loved the cupcakes and they were a major hit! My cousins are so excited to have discovered this Bakery since they live ten minutes away. And now whenever we decide to visit Jersey, we will definitely have to stop by and pick up some yummy cupcakes from here. I am regretting that I didn’t buy some to bring back home!

The location was cute, the selection was extensive, and the staff member (possibly the owner) was friendly and patient. The cupcake itself was good, but not great. They were a manageable, small size (like homemade size, or a bit smaller,) but they were a tad dry. My friend and I suspected that they hadn’t been baked the same day. The two flavors we sampled were Michelle Ma Belle (toffee) and Oreo something-​or-​other. I’d go again for a group outing, but just for the novelty of the menu

I love cupcakes! My hubby brought these home on yesterday. I’d never heard of the bakery and am not always a big fan of stuffed cupcakes but these cupcakes were great. The cake was very very moist. The filling wasn’t to sweet or overwhelming. The icing was a bit much but still tasty. I tried the lemon and pistachio. Both were very good. I would definitely go back to stuffed cupcakes. They were a little pricey at $ 20 for 6 but I guess that is also BC they are stuffed? Nonetheless, give it a try!

I was not impressed. What a let down.
The cupcakes were NOT terrible, but they were NOT amazing like other people say. Maybe its because i came around 7:30 PM and they weren’t super duper fresh but i was just not impressed.
The word STUFFED is used lightly here, they were not stuffed at all. it was a weak attempt at being stuffed with something. I had the «Elvis» and «Sexy Sadie» or something like that. They were cold and the frosting was hard. My friend got the Red velvet, i looooove red velvet but its so easy to make so i didn’t get it. however, the cream cheese frosting was pretty good ill give them that.

$ 3.50 for a cupcake, what?! Yes, they’re pricy but they’re absolutely perfect. One of the best cupcake shops I’ve ever been to. I wouldn’t pay for them if I felt I could make them better by myself but I can’t. Jarets you win.
Someone wrote that some of the cupcakes are «hit or miss» but that’s not necessarily true. You can’t hate on the «weird» cupcakes just because YOU don’t find it appealing. Someone out there in the world is gonna like it. Yes, some seem kind of odd but whatever; the point is they have something for everyone. There are so many cake, stuffing, frosting and toppings combinations that there’s no way someone could walk in here and not find something they like.
When you buy cupcakes, they label the containers for you so you don’t forget which one is which. This is really helpful especially when you buy a bunch. They also have coffee, lattes and other baked goods but I’ve never had them. I love this place, I will go out of my way again to come here like I have in the past.

These cupcakes are the best I have ever experienced! Moist and delicious and defiantly plenty to choose from with over 65 varieties. There is a cupcake for everyone here even the pickiest of eaters.
My personal favorite is the Banana Blast which is a banana cupcake filled with banana moose topped with chocolate icing and a banana chip. Also the Nutley is awesome chocolate cupcake stuffed with chocolate nutella moose topped with chocolate icing and a hazelnut. (can’t go wrong when nutella is involved) Many people say they are a little over priced but I’m a strong believer in you get what you pay for. If you are a cup cake conosur this is a must try.