The Pizza Pie Guys

I went in today for the first time. It would have been nice if there was something that would tell the customers that they only have thin crust pizza. I ordered the Hawaiian Pizza. You would hope that the pineapple would mingle nicely with the sauce. Unfortunately, this isn’t the case. Their red sauce might be home made. But it has a very slight tomato taste. Nearly no taste at all. I paid nearly $ 18 for a large. Considering the crust was thin, I would say I paid too much. There are much better pizza restaurants in Omaha!

We ordered the White Pancetta Chicken Pizza and it did NOT have any pancetta and barely any chicken on it. Instead we got regular bacon. I’d be ok if you call it a bacon chicken or tell us if you ran out of pancetta just don’t advertise you are giving us pancetta when we paid $ 23 and got bacon I could have purchased at the store!

The owner reached out to me today and gave me a replacement pizza, I really appreciated that. We ordered it tonight and had an XL pepperoni pizza and some fried gouda Mac n cheese bites.
Let me just say that the owner is a very great guy. Very genuine and caring of his customers, I can really tell that they are wanting to be better. Good customer service is the most memorable to me when I go out. I want to feel welcomed and comfortable and I do here.
The food was good, I really liked the Mac n cheese bites but they are VERY decadent. I wouldn’t recommend for someone to eat alone, share these babies! They have a very strong stinky cheese smell (in the best way!) that was driving me crazy the whole drive home, I couldn’t wait to taste them! They reminded me of something but I couldn’t put my finger on it. Then it hit me. They taste like a better tasting, less greasy version of the cheesy tots they had at bk a few years back, which I loved. So I would order these again for sure. They are a bit pricey at 8 bucks a pop but with gouda in it, I understand why.
Now to the pizza, it’s a good size pizza for a good price. Its very thin crust and the pepperoni are huge! Not your run of the mill pepperoni. They had a bit of spice to them too. I prefer thick crust but it still tasted good. My hubby and son both really liked it and hubby said he would buy it again, next time a specialty though. I’m looking at you green chili enchilada or bbq chicken. ;P
I gave 5 stars because the pizza is wayyyy better than last time, not as greasy at all. Also because how impressed I was with the Mac n cheese bites and my expectation on how good the fancy pizzas will taste. And lastly, customer service. I was extremely impressed with the owner Dan. He is great! Check them out see what you think for yourself! (:

Pizza taste is pretty good. Turn off was the cleanliness. Inside was a mess. Makes you wonder what the kitchen looks like.

We always purchase the chicken strips! They are the best in town. They will deliver them to Mitch’s for you! Service is awesome! I would recommend this place to anyone!

Just moved to area and wanted to try something close. Very tasty pizza for take out! We got 2 large pizzas, one was a special the other was just a hamburger. I can’t comment on the restaurant itself as we didn’t stay and eat but it seemed pretty cool and low key. If you’re in the area stop to pick some up!

Great pizza and customer service. Very fresh ingredients and unique pizzas as well as the classics.

This is an update on my first experience. The owner contacted me and was very gracious and offered to deliver me a complimentary pie if I was willing to give them another chance. So what the hay, I figured, perhaps they were still working out the kinks as they are relatively new to this location and I accepted his offer.
Let me say just say the pizza I had tonight was absolutely night and day from my first experience. The pie was delicious, it’s clear they’re only using the most fresh ingredients– you can especially tell with the vegetables.
I shall look forward to trying out some of their specialty pizzas, I also like the fact they deliver– out west, it’s pretty much only franchises that deliver.

Incredible pizza! I have to admit I was a bit skeptical at first. But after trying it for the first time 3 weeks ago, I have ordered it 4 more times. Very good and delivery is very quick. Their Buffalo Chicken and BBQ are amazing. Highly recommended and would put them up against traditional franchise brand names any day. Their daily specials are awesome — even got to sample some of their «Pancake Guys» batter… delicious.

Fresh take on pizza. I’ve probably bought 10 pies from them and enjoyed them. We like the crust and other ingredients. Close to home which makes it easy for pick up.