Mike’s Pizza

Just had the stuffed meat lover pizza it was great! This was my first pizza from here I usual get food which always seems to hit the spot. Ordered online with their app which also was very quick and easy.

Who come to a pizzeria and orders a salad? I know, I know crazy! But nonetheless very VERY good. I ordered the chicken caesar salad (I added my own avocado for FREE 99 once i got home) and it did not disappoint at all! The salad was very fresh and the grilled chicken too!
Check in with Unilocal and they give you a free pizza (which I had my brother take since im attempting to «diet») and he said the pizza too was great.
I would defiantly recommend this place as it’s one oft he best in the Sayreville area.

Tried this place several times now and everytime it’s on point! Ordered large amount for a house warming, the pizzas were exactly as I wanted, plenty of toppings and the sauce was delicious. Their online ordering is very easily and detailed so you can specify exactly what you want (10% off for first time online users), I ordered in the morning for the delivery in the evening and they were right on time! Pizza was still warm. Will keep going back. Check them out.

Wow, I believe this is my first review ever.
The food was absolutely delicious!!! I ordered a Jersey Burger and it was just perfect. The fries were not soggy at all, they were made so sweetly and nicely. I recommend this place to anyone. Thank you!!!

I just ordered my first pizza from Mike’s. It was absolutely delicious! The sauce is perfect. The delivery guy was super nice. I highly recommend this pizza place

One of the better pizzerias in the neighborhood. Good sauce and crispy. Portions of slices are good and wings are tasty.

The food is really good. We enjoyed the pizza and the kids keep asking to order from the «good new place». Tried the garlic knots, shrimp scampi, pizza, mozzarella sticks and everything was good. The nice little surprise was the garlic bread you get w your meal at no extra cost. As long as the food stays consistent we will be back again and again.

I have tried many «Pizza» places here in Sayreville, and hands down, Mike’s has it all. Their pizza is better than most, but their other foods are where they really shine. The salads are fresh, large enough for two, and their burgers are delish. I’ve even had some of their pasta dishes, and have never been disappointed.
To add to all of the above, they are some of the nicest folks around – from the store staff to the delivery peeps – all friendly and professional.

So I’m kind of a penne vodka snob, I had amazing penne vodka about 10 years ago before my favorite restaurant moved & I’ve been chasing to compare ever since. I’ve found a perfect fit now. The penne vodka with grilled chicken is outstanding!

My husband and I were running errands in the same strip mall as Mike’s Pizza and wanted a casual, quick dinner, which led us going into Mike’s.
We sure were glad we did. Although it looks like a small pizzeria from the outside, it’s a bright, clean, and inviting place to eat. We had planned on just ordering out, but decided to eat in instead because the place had a very relaxed, yet inviting feel to it.
The menu boards which were big and brightly displayed above the counter had their extensive choices all laid out — Burgers, Wraps, Hot & Cold Subs, Stromboli & Calzones, Pasta, Pizza, Soups, Sandwiches, Salads, and various Apps (Mozzarella Sticks, Calamari, Chicken Fingers, Potato Skins, etc). Basically everything you could possibly be in the mood for, Mike’s has it.
My husband had been in the mood for a Philly Cheesesteak so we decided to get the 18″ one and half it. We also ordered a side of Mozzarella Sticks (6).
The food out came out fairly quickly, especially given it was a Friday evening and it was busy. Aside from there being a lot of people dining in, many people were placing orders to-​go and a lot of workers were making deliveries.
The Philly Cheesesteak was good — the bread was nice and toasted. It was brought out to us on 2 plates and on top of that our halves were halved, which made it really easy to eat. The Mozzarella sticks were also good and came with a side of Marinara.
We’ll definitely be ordering from Mike’s Pizza again, both dining in and ordering out.

Service is still excellent at this location… Had dinner there again on 3÷8÷16… Food was excellent and the dessert rocked… If you have not been to Mikes than what are you waiting for?

The pizza is very high quality. Very well balanced between the bread, sauce, and cheese. Most places around here just don’t get it right. They’ll use too much of one and not enough of the other. Highly recommended!

Always amazing when we get from here. The apps and salads are always amazing, although what happened to the melted cheese on the potato skins? They are always packed with amazingness but this liquid cheese just ruined it for me today. What a mess and how gross! Bring back the shredded cheese!

I was looking for decent food while shopping for the holiday season. Mike’s Pizza looked appetizing so I took a chance and purchased the beef gyro. Wow! Simply amazing! Service was excellent and the restaurant was quite clean. On my third referral and everyone has enjoyed the experience. Thanks Mike!
P. S. Who writes bad reviews on restaurants based on accessibility to remote controls?

Good local pizza pace with slices that remind me of good boardwalk slices. Has a clean interior and looks modern. Plenty of seating and friendly servers at the counter.

Mike’s Pizza has been a go-​to pizza place for my family and I since it opened up. It is extremely clean, and has a friendly casual environment. The employees are friendly, though a little bit shy at times. They all do an excellent job, and provide great service. The food itself is fantastic. They offer the expected pizza place selection of delights, however, they surpass local competition in quality and reasonable pricing. They offer prompt and friendly delivery service ensuring the food arrives hot. I’ve gone to just about every pizza place in the area, but you’ll definitely want a slice of Mikes’ Pizza.

Great place for pizza and anything else for that matter! The lady that took my order was so friendly and helpful. Been there many times and even had some catering done. Mike is one fabulous chef! You will NOT be disappointed! Big yum!!!

We order here quite frequently to our business and they are always pretty quick to deliver. The food is always fresh and arrives hot. The wraps are excellent as well as their salads. The pizza and calzones are also very good.

Meat lovers pizza gross. Ham looks and taste like lunch meat. The thin mushy sausage was gross and the meatballs mushy and no taste. I’ll stick to plain there. Not nunzios that’s for sure.

Been here for two months and have been trying all the local places. Mike’s is by far my favorite. I havent had anything bad there. Everything is great.