I have eaten at the old location and have gotten take-out from the new spot a few times. Every visit has been excellent. The crust is buttery and crispy and the toppings are fresh and delicious. The sides/appetizers have been hit or miss and are a bit expensive in my opinion for what you get, but the pizza is always consistent. The melanzane and the salciccia pizzas are great… the porchetta definitely needed some salt when I ordered it though. The new location is very warm and inviting inside with an open kitchen. While the space is still somewhat small, it is definitely more comfortable than their old location across the street. The BYOB status keeps cost down and a small pizza easily serves 2 people. I would love to see them branch out a bit and offer some different or special pizzas in the future, but for now, I cannot complain and they remain a regular on rotation in my take-out ordering line-up. Just be aware that parking in this area is very difficult to find at night… so I recommend walking or taking a cab.
Megan R.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Philadelphia, PA
Me and my boyfriend are obsessed with this place! I usually like thin crust pizza but I ended up loving this thicker crusted version. Probably because it’s well done so it’s not doughy. Also I the salad they have there with the artichokes is literally everything! Thanks for always making quality food and friendly service!
Ann F.
Évaluation du lieu : 1 Philadelphia, PA
The 2 times we have eaten there food was good. I do not understand a business that is half full at 6:30 and tells people no food will be available for at least 90 minutes. Thought it was a problem with the pizza oven but no pasta or salads. No one seemed to have food and staff was just standing around. As they do not take reservations I will have to cross this off as a dining destination as I will never know if food is available. If it is a problem with t/o orders then take reservations for dining. No offer to reserve a table for later. Bad business model.
S Z.
Évaluation du lieu : 1 Philadelphia, PA
Tried calling for a pick-up order at 8:25 and got an answering machine. Tried calling back a few more times and got a message stating the line was busy. Tried one last time at 8:45 and got the answering machine again. Just trying to order a pizza, but I guess I can’t during normal business hours?! Have never experienced this when calling a restaurant.
Shazia M.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Philadelphia, PA
Best pizza I have ever had in Philly. It’s byob too which makes it even better! Pepperoni pizza — deep dish perfection. The crispy flavorful crust was my favorite part. Meat Caveteppi Pasta — 3 big pieces of meat come with the pasta. It was very filling and delicious.
Joe B.
Évaluation du lieu : 2 National Park, NJ
After reading the glowing Unilocal reviews, I decided to try Square Pie. Went Saturday afternoon about 1PM. It was a busy day in town– warm, so a lot of people out and about. My first tip that it was a dud is that there were no people there. Totally empty. GF immediately commented. We both thought it was a bad sign, but went ahead and ordered a large cheese & tomato pie. We immediately dug in to try it and were sorely disappointed. Nothing– and I mean NOTHING– about the pie stood out as exceptional. If I were to pick one thing I liked, I would say the crust had a nice texture. There is nothing about the pizza there that makes it worthy of all the Unilocal stars. Either someone is massaging the Unilocal reviews, or a bunch of naïve suburbanites are just mindlessly jumping on the bandwagon.
Curtis A.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Queen Village, Philadelphia, PA
Just ordered the ensalata and a pepperoni Brooklyn style pizza for takeout. Pizza. Was one of the best I’ve had in Philly and the salad was also extremely good. On top of the excellent food the service was strong. The staff clearly wanted to make sure the entire experience was positive. We will be regulars for sure
Peter V.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Philadelphia, PA
Omg. I went here based on a recommendation from my barber. He told me that I should really check this place out for their pizza. It took me awhile to get there, but I’m glad that I did. Best pizza ever! You have not lived until you’ve eaten a pizza from Square Pie in Queen Village! Drop everything and go over a eat right now! If they are closed go camp out of their door until they open you won’t regret it!!!
Darragh C.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Pennsport, Philadelphia, PA
Great pizzas… probably the best in the neighborhood. Now my favorite over another decent place around 10th and Christian. They only one salad on the menu but it’s excellent. They made a mistake with my order on probably the busiest night of the year and gladly refunded me after I called. Great customer service. Highly recommend this place anyone in the area.
Michael B.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Philadelphia, PA
Stopped in here on a Wednesday afternoon and had a small pepperoni pizza. One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had, and for what it’s worth I lived in NYC for about 15 years and ate some of the best there. It’s a charming little place with an old tile floor and wooden tables with red checkered tablecloths. It wasn’t busy at all at that time. Do yourself a favor and treat yourself at this place. Seriously.
Hannah H.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Seattle, WA
I was a little surprised to see only seven reviews here so far so I thought I would help out by throwing mine into the ring. We have been talking about coming here since Cochon closed and we finally got around to it over the sleepy Thanksgiving weekend. Maybe it was the amazing 90s playlist in the background of the restaurant affecting my mood but I loved this pizza. We started out with the arancini, which was a win – I liked the little sausage surprise in the middle and the overall flavor was killer. We ordered two small pies after the appetizer, which I thought was sufficient for two adults and a toddler with a hearty appetite. Our picks were the salsiccia(sausage, onion, peppers) and the pancetta(pork belly, leek, potatoes, and cream). Both great choices but I admit they were so rich I was full after just one slice of each. The crust is thick and crisped to perfection on the edges, which I loved. The restaurant itself is family friendly, for those interested – they have a box of crayons and coloring books at the door to keep your kiddos occupied for a while.
Brian P.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Philadelphia, PA
My wife gets hangry. Like really hangry. She saved a pepperoni slice to stave off the hanger the morning after we went to square pie. I risked life and limb and ate the slice. This pizza is so good it was worth being assaulted for that morning. The salad, meatballs, service and atmosphere were all great too. BYOB never hurts either.
Tracy L.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 San Diego, CA
Another great addition to the neighborhood! I love thin crust but man, this crispy fluffy dream of a crust makes for some serious comfort food. Every pizza we got had an outstanding flavor and aroma. Delicious!
Vincent D.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Philadelphia, PA
We were looking for a great standby for pizza. This place had everything we wanted and while I have yet to go to the new location(literally across the street), I can say that their pizza is some of the best in the city. I kept it simple when I went and got the pepperoni pizza and a basket of garlic bread. The pizza crust was phenomenal and the pie itself wasn’t OVERLY greasy. I overheard the guys saying they were going to start making lasagnas(?) and if that’s true, I may have to start going to the gym a little more…
John D.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Cherry Hill, NJ
Went here last night with a small party to celebrate my wife’s birthday. Not a large dining area but seating was readily available. Ordered a salami plate appetizer with garlic bread that was surprisingly filling for the 5 of us. The salami was thinly sliced and the bread, which had to be pulled apart as it was a single small bun, was hot & garlicky. Ordered 3 large pies that were all excellent. Each hot with different spicing. Only criticism was the service was slow — undoubtedly from the large takeout service they do. Plan to go back soon.
Jason R.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Westville, NJ
HTF does this place only have 2 reviews so far? Their crust is phenomenal and is the real star of the show, so you can’t really go wrong with any of the pizzas, BUT you should probably try the Pancetta, which is off the freaking meat rack!!! Even if you’re like most people ’round here and usually prefer thin crust, I can assure you that you’ll love this thicker crust that it just the right amounts of crispy & chewy. The staff is friendly and I’ve only gotten take out so far, but it seems like a nice little spot to sit down for your meal as well.
Ashley V.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Philadelphia, PA
So delicious and the people here are so nice! The crust is AMAZING and you can’t go wrong with anything on the menu. Favorite is the sausage
Jim H.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Philadelphia, PA
I have always been a thin crust pizza guy and was hesitant to try this place. When they moved into their new location in Passyunk ave(the former Cochon restaurant) I decided to give it a shot. WOW! Amazing Pizza! I had the small Melanzane with tomato sauce, ricotta, olives roasted eggplant and it going to be on my list of GO-TO pizza places, Next time I am going to try the interesting selection of salads and antipasta. Nice cozy atmosphere and good service.