Buffalo Grille

This place knows how to do buffalo chicken. Came down to this area for work and happened upon this spot on Unilocal.I’ve had buffalo chicken basically everywhere I’ve been and these guys are good.
Several different heat levels available. I got hot on my chicken fingers with a side of blazing to try with the fries. Both were fantastic with a great amount of flavor, not just heat. All the sauces are made in house. This isn’t franks red hot with Tabasco or butter to change the flavor
I’d stay away from the mozzarella sticks. They’re short and very thick so they just don’t cook right. Cruncy outside but hardly cooked in the middle.
Overall, great place with great food, prices and a friendly staff. If I’m in the area, I’ll be coming back to try more.

Been here over 15 times for lunch. I order from the blackboard specials. Never disappointed Food is fresh staff always upbeat n helpful. Small sitting area but do great take out n delivery. I eat in because I like the atmosphere

Ode to Buffalo Chicken Sandwich: oh blue cheese crumbles so melty and fresh, I delicately clutch the soft bread much to any diets protest. The buffalo sauce, so zingy but boss. Soon the sandwich is gone, I mourn it’s loss.
Onion rings were dope too.
Friendly staff, easy phone ordering, pleasant pick up. I mean, I wrote a small poem…

Love their food whether it’s a quick chicken chili to take home on a cold night or a lunch break wrap. Always good service is great

Found this place by chance on Unilocal and couldn’t have been happier that we did. We had ordered the grilled chicken caesar salad, buffalo fingers and pulled pork quesadilla. Everything was excellent and the staff was extremely courteous/​friendly. Highly recommended and will definitely be going back.

After reading the reviews I decided to give this place a try. I ordered the buffalo chicken salad and meat chili to go. Everything was ready/​hot on time and all of the food was delicious. Fresh ingredients with lots of flavor. I’ll be back again!

They’re too stupid to add a delivery person during their busy time so you have to wait 1 ½ hrs for your lunch. Food is good, but not worth waiting an hour and a half for.

I ordered delivery recently during prime lunch hours. The lady on the phone was patient and courteous, as was the delivery person. Really superb customer service. The delivery came in 18 minutes, not the estimated 30.
The chicken wings were delicious, moist on the inside. The fries were crunchy and held up well through the entirety of my meal. And the Governor’s Chili was chock full of goodness.

My new go-​to sandwich spot for Lunch. Conveniently located right down the block from my office, this place has the best quality ingredients for all their food. You could order the most simple menu item and it will blow you away from the quality standpoint alone. I’m not going to list all the things I’ve had here, just go and enjoy. I compare it almost to like my other favorite sandwich place Roast sandwich house on route 110. Both great fresh food every day, I can’t recommend this place enough. You’ve got to try the onion rings here, they are perfect.
Oh by the way I’m a big hot sauce guy, to my surprise they make their own hot sauce in house all ranging from mild to spicy, and it is delicious! I hate going places asking for their hot sauce and you get tobasco (yuck). 5 stars!

I have eaten all lot of buffalo wings in my time. I have even traveled to the city of Buffalo to experience what actual buffalo wings are supposed to taste like. I can tell you with 100% conviction that the wings at Buffalo Grille are hands-​down the best in Nassau County if not the best on Long Island. And you would think something simple as buffalo wings would not be all that difficult for most places to get right. But, my experience with wings on Long Island has almost always been disappointing… until I found this place. Check ‘em out… I’m confident that you’ll agree.

Really good fresh food. Everything is made to order. Very nice staff that goes out of their way to help you. Small place, a few tables for sitting and eating in but it’s very clean and bright. Ample parking because it’s located in the Morton Village Shopping Center next to CVS.
We usually get their wings, chicken quesadilla, salads, and burgers. Good soups too.

Always looking for places like this to stop for lunch in between appointments for work.
Great grilled chicken sandwich. Everything (chicken, cheese, peppers, mushrooms) tasted fresh!
Service behind the counter was extremely friendly and very helpful.
Will definitely be stopping back in next time I’m in Plainview.

I have lived and/​or worked in Plainview since 1991 and have no idea when this place opened! I never noticed it. Last time my work colleagues and I went out for lunch someone mentioned «the buffalo place» and I thought they meant the MIXED GRILL because they serve buffalo chicken wraps. So we went to the MIXED GRILL for lunch (a place I love).
Today, we went to eat at the MIXED GRILL again but there was no parking so we were going to go to the Deli in Morton Village. At the same time, my colleague and I noticed the Buffalo grill and said «Let’s look at the menu.»
A. Food: We both ordered the blackened chicken sandwich, which also came with fries or salad or a third choice that I no longer remember. It was $ 9.95. I wasn’t expecting much from a place that is so tiny and not so pretty. It was DELICIOUS! I walked in there in a pretty awful mood and left feeling great. We both loved it! We brought one back for another colleague and she said «That’s the place I wanted to go to last time!»
B. Service: Excellent. It took longer to get our food than expected and I was a little stressed thinking we might be late going back to the office but it all worked out fine. They could not have been nicer.
C. Atmosphere. Not the prettiest place I have been to. It was way more busy than any of the other places in that shopping center is at that time (other than the Blue Angel, which is always packed). We lucked out and a table opened up just before our lunch was ready. There are only ⁴⁄₅ tables in the place.
I can’t wait to go back and try their chili… and the wings that have gotten wildly different reviews on here (their wings have gotten 1 star AND 5 star reviews!)
I will definitely go back… I just ate the leftovers for dinner and I am so happy right now!

Great wings, wraps and kids hamburger. Service was very good. We will be back for lunch again and for take out wings.

I’ve gone back multiple times since my first review and had to up it to 5 stars as this place continues to serve consistently good food. It’s not over complicated but it’s always delicious. Have since gone back and tried the Mexican chili wrap, the broadway burger, the southwestern wrap, and the buffalo chicken finger wrap and all of them were delicious. The fries continue to be amazing!

Excellent food, good prices. Between me and my family, we’re here almost every week, whether it’s delivery, take out, or in person. It’s a great option if you’re looking for something different than the usual Chinese/​pizza takeout. The food is always on point. My mother hates avocado but loves the Avocado Spring Rolls, they’re that good. I’ve tried just about every sandwich on the menu and have yet had something I didn’t like. I also love that they have baked potatoes as a side option, not just french fries. The staff is really nice too!

Boneless Buffalo strips at this place are pretty darn good. They have a very friendly staff and quick with delivery. Atmosphere inside the restaurant is very simple but comfortable. Good place for a quick bite!

Considering this is a wing place, not so good. Wings are small and dried out. Nothing special. Can do better on my own

Excellent lunch spot. I usually come here for the buffalo chicken sandwich or the turkey burger. Both are made fresh, quality is superb, and flavor is great.
The staff is super friendly and they make you feel welcome and that makes you want to come back to support the business.
They have a lunchcard so every 15 you get a freebie so be sure to get the card!

To be completely honest, the wings here are not the reason I continue to order here. The reason I continually order from Buffalo Grille is the price, consistency of service, and the Burgers/​Sandwiches. I first tried this place on a whim when I saw I can get delivery burgers Chinese take-​out style. In fact, this place is right next to a Chinese take-​out place, and it’s setup is similar.
I have never eaten in the store, though I often pick up my food. The burgers and sandwiches are always good, and the fries crispy. Their menu is varied enough that almost anyone can find something they like, and their daily specials (that they post on Facebook every day) are great!
I have only ever encountered the one employee who seems to always be working the phones and the register, but he’s a really nice guy who seems to remember me and my girlfriend now when we come to pick up our food.
It is quickly becoming a Sunday staple.
It brings me back to college when I was able to order any kind of food I could think of to be delivered to my dorm room. Now that I’m home from school the options for delivery are Pizza or Chinese. Now I can order good american/​barbecue to my door.
The pricing is very good, and the delivery is quick. You get a lot of food for a little money, and they give you a frequent diner card that gets you a free meal every few orders.