Waterfront Pizza

Great pizza and the greek salad was good. Place is really small and we had to wait to be seated but they take your order while you are waiting. Nice touch.

Oh, my goodness, that crust! Nothing better than that crust with a bottle of eight-​ball stout. We take the ferry over just to go here to have pizza and beer. LOVE it! The music playing all of the times we have been there has been great, including some Etta James and Ella Fitzgerald.

Always great food! I’ve never had a bad piece of pizza there! I’ll drive to port Townsend just for the pizza!

We had excellent pizza here on Christmas Eve. Greek and Hawaiian pizzas are both very good and I would recommend both. Good beer selection, and the charmingly-​outdated Trivial Pursuit questions in a basket at the table were entertaining. Our server was wonderful.

This place always makes a great pizza, but Holy $&”$, whoever is was making pie on 12/​12/​2015 produced a masterpiece! It was better than any others we’ve purchase there and the others were great pizzas! You guys are awesome! Keep that shit up!

4 star pizza, 2 star atmosphere. Pizza is delicious but they *loudly* play obscene music (each of the few times I’ve gone into the street side entrance) I don’t want to hear that as I try to eat it’s offensive. That said, their pizza is delicious and certainly worth a try. I’m sure I’ll be back but this is definately making want to explore other options in the future.

Yum! Their veggie veggie salad with their homemade dill dressing is to die for. So fresh, crunchy and awesome! A bit overwhelming at the slice counter (a bit new york style, loud and everyone hard at work in a tiny space) but head upstairs for a dining experience like none other. So family friendly with games at every table to pass the time. And their pizzas! So many options to choose from! Our favorite go to is pepperoni, jalapeño and pineapple, sounds odd I know but so great, everytime!

I «stumbled» on Waterfront after finding another local place was closed a half hour before the posted time. What a great discovery! The guys were working to close also but willingly agreed to make my pizza and cooked it perfectly. They turned out to be very friendly while I waited. I took the pizza to go. The crust is fantastic! The pizza is very good and overall would absolutely recommend Waterfront Pizza!

I order these pizzas to go and take them home to Seattle and freeze them. They’re amazing!

One star for delivery to our campsite, and the other star for being so friendly!
Unfortunately the pizza was a disappointment. The crust was thick and doughy. It was neither a thin or deep crust, just mediocre. The Portuguese pizza was topped with linguisa. The good news is it wasn’t greasy as I feared, but I come from a background that knows linguisa and I’ve never had anything like what was on this pizza. It had an odd crumbly texture and bland in taste. We were hungry but didn’t eat much, which says much about this pizza.
Perhaps this is par for Port Townsend but it wasn’t what we had hoped for.

Waterfront Pizza may not have been in Port Townsend forever, but it sorta feels like it. It has been here as long as I can remember and it hasn’t ever changed. It’s a tiny place. Really tiny. There is seating for maybe about a dozen people inside, and a couple more outside on the bench that faces the sidewalk.
You can order pizza pies or pick up pizza slices. The slices are in the glass cabinet as you come in, and the selection varies with the time of day, etc. They usually do a pretty good job of keeping it full enough to provide a couple good choices for both carnivores and vegetarians.
They make hand-​thrown crusts. Actually they’re mostly hand-​rolled-​out, but that works. The pizza is very good, but not mind-​blowingly good. It’s a great, quick place to grab lunch on a sunny day in PT.

Well, in a town full of cafes for the sophisticated palate, we opted for pizza as a family friendly meal, something everyone could enjoy. We went here based on reviews, but ours was not a great experience.
We came mid week during lunch and there was only one other table seated. We ordered fairly quickly, then the place began to fill up.
We ordered the extra large pizza based on the serving size the server explained to us. Then we waited, and waited. When the pizza finally arrived, and it took a very long time for that to happen, they were much larger than described so there was much too much pizza, and they had gotten one completely wrong, leaving us having to wait that much longer. To top it all off it was only so-​so.
All in all, this town does not have a lot of options for family dining, crossing this one off our list.

Everything besides the crust and traffic were good.
The crust is pretty bad, there’s a bunch of leftover flour specks that get all over your fingers and the crust is just chewy and not crispy and crunchy like most other good pizzerias.
The only other problem is the traffic, its in the «problem zone» of the town that takes forever to get to by its standards and the pizza delivery takes about an hour if you decide to go that route.
Its still worth a try, don’t get me wrong, just don’t eat the crust and plan ahead

Let’s start with the good: the pizza is great! The crust is unique and delish! I’m not much of a crust fan but this was perfectly crispy but soft on the inside! Yum! The staff was sweet and attentive!
The ok: the seating is ultra limited. I think there is a total of 5 tables?! I would def. recommended ordering take out instead!
Also, they only offer two size pizzas with no options for kids. You either go small or extra large! Again, order to go and share with a friend!
Lastly, it was a bit slow to get our food. Very rewarding once it came. But still slow.
Overall, I would opt for take out next time and enjoy the yummy crust in my own place!

Excellent focaccia bread. Average vegetarian pizza. No waterfront view! Took 55min for the pizza to show up — weekend lunch!

The pizza was quite good, but we almost didn’t get to enjoy it. We were quite tempted to leave before even tasting their unique creations. The service was inattentive and, once they acknowledged our presence, they were surly and rude. We attempted to get a seat in their upstairs dining room and were ignored. We ended up ordering slices downstairs and were patronized when we had the audacity to ask what the various toppings were.
I would never return to this restaurant. It’s simply not worth the bad service.

Waterfront pizza is awesome their sausage is over-​the-​top the atmosphere is friendly and old-​schoolwhat an amazing group of employees if you have never tried one from pizza you’re missing out on the best pizza in the northwest my family loves waterfront pizza again they are the best.

There is definitely something different either in the seasoning, the sauce… something. I mean that in a GOOD way. Had a simple pepperoni and it had a certain tang.
The crust, for the style, is decent. The other half and I tend more towards your Neopolitan style, wood fired.
This was stop two on what has been dubbed the pizza tour of Port Townsend. We would return, just to grab slices!

It you have any type of food palate. This pizza does NOT come close to the mark. We had three very different 1 meat 2 veggie pizzas. If you closed your eyes and took a bite of each different type. I was impossible to tell the different types. There was way to much toppings and the dough was at best below par. Don’t go

A last minute labor day weekend trip to Port Townsend found us wondering why all the restaurants close between 3−5pm. A young local man directed us to Waterfront Pizza, stating it was, «pretty good.»
Quite fortunately we found it to be very good! The upstairs seating is small but cute and we were seated immediately. Our waitress was super friendly and let us know up front that we could order aby combination of choices half and half so we went with Waterfront (sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, olives) and Greek (feta, Greek olives, artichoke).
The pizza was amazing. The service was fantastic and we’d definitely come back!