Graeter’s Ice Cream

I love the ice cream, the location, and the outside seating!
My visit today was outstanding. Ben, was super helpful and knowledgeable of the new fall flavor a they had in stock and the few summer items still left. He also knew a lot about the cones for a cure fundraiser! Great ice cream and great fundraiser! I will be back.

They were out of peanut butter chip and totally over run with soccer kids but the Buckeye Blitz is to die for!!!

I’ve been here so many times that I’m surprised I don’t own a part of this franchise. I love the Buckeye ice cream that they have and so many others. The atmosphere is so loving and warm. I see a lot of families that come to this particular location and just to see the kids faces when they get the ice cream that they want makes my heart happy. The staff is very ingratiating and kind. If you have any questions about any of the flavors that they have, they take time out to explain each one of them to you which I think is very special and has that one on one individual touch. The ice cream is always fresh, cold and tasty. They have a rewards card that is very beneficial and also gives you discounts. I wish they had more parking in that area since city barbecue is right next to it but other than that, I enjoy ice cream and will keep coming again and again

Great place to hang with the family. You can get dinner next door at city bbq as well. The service is great. The one on the Bethel road in Columbus has play area for little kids.

Ice cream may just be my favorite food. So when I found myself in Columbus, I was pretty excited to try out the big names Jeni’s and Graeters. I have many friends who are from Columbus who swear by Jeni’s and who swear by Graeters. So I was pretty excited to see for myself which Team I would be on. When it comes to the ice cream itself I got the Buckeye Blitz and the Hazlenut Gelato. Honestly I really wasn’t that impressed. I mean the ice cream was good! It was nice and creamy, and had a good flavor to it. But was it amazing? Was it the best I ever had? Unfortunately not. I think it’s average ice cream. But my heart and my stomach doesn’t like to settle for average.

I have been visiting this store for two years now and am very impressed with the staff. These are young adults so there is turn over but this location consistently hires friendly conscientious staff that always give me a warm welcome.
I would suggest adding noise reduction tiles-​there are often large crowds showing up at once and the noise is deafening.

Amazing ice cream with both classic and inventive flavors.
Columbus is a great city for ice cream. There are many many options, but Graeter’s is in my top two (I eat a lot of ice cream). My favorite flavors are the Coconut Chocolate Chip and Buckeye Blitz. The Blitz is an Ohio reference and has smashed «buckeye» chocolate candy in it. Very delicious!
This location is always very clean as well. And it’s situated right next to an excellent BBQ place called City Barbecue. A great place to stop and get food and dessert!
Highly recommend!

Convenient location with plenty of parking behind the store. I enjoy their ice cream — rich, smooth & creamy. Some of my favorites have been the black raspberry chocolate chip, black cherry chocolate chip, strawberry and mint chocolate chip. Okay … I love chocolate. Their chocolate chip versions have been more dark chocolate chunks which more than satisfy my chocolate craving. Their staff have always been willing to let you sample a taste before choosing. I usually get their dish version, but they offer waffle cones if you prefer. And the scoop sizes are pretty generous scoops. Definitely a great place to take friends or family for a sweet treat.

Was told this was better than Jeni’s (2 stars I think on last review) and proved them wrong.
When I think of ice cream I think of stuff that is made with whole milk and fresh ingredients like just picked strawberries. This place resonates none of this. Average at best. I’d rather buy ice cream from a supermarket. Avoid.

I really only go for one type of ice cream, raspberry chocolate chunk, all other flavors are a waste of time in my opinion.

This is the best ice cream, ever! Raspberry chip, peanut-​butter chip, and coconut chip are my favorites. No one else compares to Graeters.

We went because we had been told that this was the place to go for real down to earth ice cream. So we went… not impressed at all. The flavor wasn’t very rich or creamy at all. Kind of put me in mind of something you could get at the grocery store (Breyers to be exact) and although the mango sorbet/​sherbet was good — it was close but no cigar. Both flavors we got (mango and vanilla) were lacking in full taste and had too much in the way of ice crystals in them.
Our hunt continues.

I haven’t been to Graeter’s in years — but it’s just as good as I remembered it — if not better!
We were back in Cbus over the past weekend and had to stop in for a treat. I had a junior scoop of Cookies ‘n Crème and a junior scoop of Buckeye Blitz. Yum-​o! I enjoyed both of them equally. I wish they sold the Buckeye Blitz and Cookies ‘n Crème in the pints out here in Colorado. They have other flavors (Cookie Dough, Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry Chocolate Chip, Mint Chip, etc.). I’d be in trouble if they did… especially after looking at the nutritional facts. Oh well — I will burn it off with all of my Ironman training.
If you live in the Cbus area, you HAVE to go to Graeter’s for ice cream.

Best ice cream i’ve ever had! I’ve had ice cream in about half of the states in the US. I’ve eaten it at hundreds of places. Graeter’s has the BEST ice cream anywhere. The creaminess and richness is what sets it apart from all other places.

There’s been quite a few ice cream places that have opened in Powell in the last two years. I may have visited them once or twice, but I always come back to Graeter’s.
The ice cream is rich and my favorite thing to find is a monster piece of chocolate (bigger than my mouth) in my cookie dough ice cream.
If you weren’t smiling before you went in, you will be on the way out. In the summer it’s always busy and has a circus-​like atmosphere (in a good way). They have enough knowledgeable staff that we never wait long, even when the place is packed. The best part is being able to sit outside on a patio and not worry about the kids ice cream dripping on the floor.
One of my favorite memories of this Graeter’s is watching 4^th of July fireworks from the city of Powell while eating ice cream with family and friends on the patio.

This is my favorite Graeter’s location by far! Service here is always top notch and it’s about as close to familiar as it gets. Where else do you get to see the little leaguers meeting after a game and other little ones feeding ice cream to Spike the dog?
Not really sure who Spike the dog is but it sounded good at the time AND they do have dog nights which are typically funny. Also, a lot of the ice cream is Kosher. I’m just happy I don’t have to go all the way to Main St. or Dublin for it!
It’s Graeters… portions are huge and not nearly as expensive as some other ice cream shops around (you know who you are!) The chocolate chips are ridiculously huge and from what I hear are to die for.