Pizza Pie Cafe

Hate how your employees fail to rotate the pizza. I don’t want to eat the old Nast pizza when there is hot fresh pizza sitting behind it. Train your employees to get rid of the old pizza!!!

Great service! However the pizza is like cardboard with different toppings. Can’t say I’d recommend it! We waited over 30 minutes just to be seated, then waited some more for pizza, and the pasta is just as good as opening a cheap bottle of store bought Ragu! Utah people you will do way better picking up a Pappa Murphy! And if your looking for an evening out I highly recommend Two Jacks!

The pizza itself isn’t the most amazing pizza out there, but for a buffet it is still really good. The overall buffet is really great. They have a ton of different pizza options, both regular and dessert. My favorite pizza is the buffalo chicken pizza, big pieces of buffalo chicken on top and a tasty sauce. I also LOVE their Oreo dessert pizza, I usually eat this first! They have these super delicious garlic knots as well, that are great to dip in their marinara and ranch. If a pizza is ever out or running low, the staff is happy to get another one going asap.
They also have a large salad bar, which helps you feel slightly less guilty about all of the pizza you just ate. They have a variety of pastas and a lot of different sauces, the alfredo is really good. I think for a buffet the prices are pretty reasonable and if you keep an eye they usually have some sort of coupon or discount as well. This a great place to fill up at in a college town.

Love this place! The only reason it gets 4 stars is because the pizza isn’t a 5 star pizza. Saying that, it certainly isn’t bad pizza and hard to find a good 5 star pizza joint, let alone in a buffet.
For a buffet style pizza place, this place rocks. Always a good selection of pizzas, cooked fresh and plenty of it. They have some very unique pizzas as well. Always a featured pizza of the month„ always interesting.
The salad bar is small but fresh, with a good selection of just the right things to make a quick salad.
My favorite part is the pasta bar! Great pasta choices and a half dozen or so different sauces to top it off.
Drinks are self serve as well, so you never run dry.
Get in on their text club for some serious discounts. I eat here often, with a drink, for less than $ 6.

I mean this place is okay, but the food just isn’t that great. I’ve been to a lot better buffets. The pizza doesn’t taste very natural. I’d rather just make something at home.

If you are having trouble with your bowel movements I highly recommend this place. The laxatives they put in their pizzas worked wonders for me. After eating there I was in and out of the bathroom for 6 straight hours. I guess in a way it made up for the times I couldn’t go. The food is disgusting but trust me it’s worth it to be able to go poop.

Fantastic Salad bar, decent pizza in a wide variety. Service is always quick and polite, I highly recommend trying this place out.

Pizza when you want to fill up on the stuff and you are looking for it at cheap cost. Not much more that dough with some light sauce and scarce toppings. Not very good. But as I say, cheap and buffet style dining.

I know this was a buffet so you don’t expect top quality but this was a little worse than that. The salad bar was ok so that keeps it out of the 1 ranking.

They have really come together over here at the buffet, the food is great and the service has come along way! Very fun way to sit the whole family down for some pizza and a few laughs.

It’s a neat idea. However, the pizza is low quality-​which is expected. I wish the dessert pizzas would have sugar cookie crust. I think they would be a THOUSAND times better. The pasta is my favorite. Get the ratiatori with the carbanara and roasted red pepper sauce. Delicious.

Ahhh… Pizza Pie Café… how you have fallen from grace.
I used to frequent this place A LOT as a cool hip high schooler and I recall the pizza being WAY better. Now, it’s honestly as hard and tough as cardboard.
I want to love this place. I have so many good memories of playing cards at the table and discussing the HOTTEST guys at school while eating warm, delicious pizza. Now, they’re stuck in the 4 «unusual» pizza combinations, and managing to make them all impossible to eat.
The service is mediocre, with 2 – 3 waitresses/​busboys/​servers? to a full house of customers. I feel like you’re always waiting around for more pizza or salad to be put out. I can’t deal with this place because there are so many other pizza options in Utah County, even in PROVO, that are much better quality.
We had some good times PPC, some real good times. But I think it’s time we part.

I came here for a work perty and wasn’t really expecting much, all you can eat pizza is never something I’ll turn down but I’d heard mixed reviews of this place. Overall, it was fine, not amazing but certainly not terrible either.
The pizza is okay, a little overdone but the variety is definitely impressive. The salad bar is pretty standard, and none of the dessert pizza was terribly exciting to me but I was definitely in the minority there, everyone else seemed VERY positive about those.
My favorite part was the pasta bar, it’s a little out of the way, sort of around the corner from the pizza area, so I don’t think I’d even have noticed it if my group didn’t have to walk directly past it to get to our table. They have a wide variety of different pastas and sauces and they flash cook it right there in front of you so it’s always hot when you get it.
Definitely worth a stop, especially if you have a big group, there’s something for everyone but don’t expect gourmet.

All you can eat pizza. Enough said, right?
So seriously now. The restaurant is well priced. Friday and Saturday nights are the busiest so I like to go on any other day of the week cause its alot quieter and not as crowded. Pizza options are good. I felt their were a good number of variety to choose from. I do recommend getting some dessert pizza aswell. If you have never tried their chocolate pizza than you have been deprived. I recommend it.
If pizza is not your thing (why go, right? JK) they do have pasta & salad bar available which is bad. So all thats left is for you guys to give it a shot yourselves. I do recommend it.

Even though some may call it a POS, the locals call this place PPC. I don’t mind the occasional visit to this all you can eat pizza/​pasta/​salad buffet. This is a kid friendly joint and one of my son’s favorite places. Kids will always love pizza, Mac and Cheese, and chicken nuggets.
Anyways, the salad bar was kept clean considering the quantity of people there. The high school/​college aged employees do a decent job of keeping the dining area clean too. The food quality is average but because there are so many «hungry» patrons, the pizzas are fresh and rarely last long.
Because it is a kid friendly joint, it can be both noisy and annoying sometimes but 3 stars seems fine.

We had a fair experience at this Pizza Pie Café location on Wednesday night. I maintain that $ 8.25 per person is a little high for the quality of food you receive, but I also realize it’s pretty standard for this type of set-​up.
The service, aside from our initial exchange with the cashier was non-​existent. Plates were removed from the table only once during the entire visit and drinks (which are not included in the price of the meal) are filled and refilled by the customer at a nearby fountain. The pizza was more than half gone for much of our visit. It was pretty busy, so when fresh pies were set out, there was a rush to get it before it was gone. My favorites were the buffalo chicken and the pepperoni and jalapeño (I think it was called «The Firefighter»). Dessert pizza was just so-​so. I tried the cookie dough and the Oreo.
We came to Pizza Pie Café with an elderly couple who chose the restaurant. If I’d had my druthers, we would have gone across the parking lot to Nicolitalia, where they know how to make a really good pizza. Quality trumps quantity every time.

Decent pizza and nice atmosphere. The crust is a little dense without much texture. Stick to pizzas with lots of flavor and you’ll be fine. The price is great and the dessert pizza is even better. Cinnamon sticks were more like cinnamon jerky but the Cookie dough was fantastic.
Great for groups and they have options for everyone. They kept fresh pizzas coming right up to a few minutes before closing. I’m impressed.

Salad bar is great! Pizza is… Buffet quality. Very bready. Good environment in the restaurant though. Very family friendly.

I think they need a less cardboard-​ish crust and more sauce. I only go here because my kids get free coupons from their school, but every time I regret it.
Maybe I’m just a pizza snob. No, I definitely am a pizza snob. To me, the best pizza the world is thin crust, wood grilled, fresh mozzarella, Margherita pizza.
At pizza pie Café you find a lot of pizza that’s slightly better than frozen pizza.

Pizza is average. Not that great, but not super greasy and it’s fresh and hot, so I can’t complain. You go there for the quantity and variety, not the quality, I guess. I’m always a fan of dessert pizza, which is one of the top factors that keeps me coming back.
The salad bar is great, though pretty basic. The ambience is fun and casual, as long as you don’t mind noisy. It’s usually packed. The service is good and they try to keep it up as fast as they can, and it’s always very clean.
Cons:
I think it’s a little overpriced for what you get. $ 8-​something a person not including a drink is steep. I could get a steak for the same price.
This isn’t really the restaurant’s fault, but I think I’ve been here at least 5 times and every single time, there is some unattended child that runs into my legs or wanders around in the high-​traffic areas. I almost trip over a kid most visits, which really sucks when you’re carrying a full plate of hot food. I can’t really figure out why it’s such a big family place because it’s expensive and the kids can’t even reach the pizza on their own… anyway. Maybe that won’t bug you.