The Ice Cream Store

Fantastic! Went on a afternoon so no line and the server let us try unlimited samples! We didn’t even ask she just suggested ones once we said what we liked. The chocolate I don’t give a fork was to die for. So was death by peanut butter!

The long line outside of this little ice cream window is there for a reason. The ice cream is that good. I went with the very safe Delaware Peach. I wished I had been braver and branched out more. On a second trip, I had Cardamom for one scoop and Fig for another. YUM. Be brave. Try something crazy. You’ll be so glad you did. this place has the best ice cream of any place that I’ve ever been other than … well… anywhere I can think of honestly.

We signed the waiver and tried the ghost pepper ice cream, it was not so hot. It was not very flavorful either. The Death by Peanut Butter and the Better Than Sex were both good,

After a few days in Ocean City, Maryland, my boyfriend and I drove up the coast en route back to Pittsburgh and decided to check out the infamous Rehobeth Beach area. My god! We should’ve come here and will definitely return! In addition to its quaint shops and atmosphere, we came across The Ice Cream Store and it being a hot day, we decided to grab a cone.
First off, it looks overwhelming and you think «there is no way in hell that they have all of these different flavors!» BUT THEY DO!
I walked up and said I wanted the Peanut Butter Pretzel and the girl looked at me like I said I wanted to eat a pile of dog poop. She immediately said «no you don’t…here try this» and ran off and fetched me 3 different samples of peanut butter flavored ice cream. I picked Peanut Butter Overload (at least I think that was the name) and boy was it the best! Smooth and creamy with a thick peanut butter ribbon throughout. Sometimes when you get peanut butter ice cream it doesn’t *really* taste like peanut butter but not this one!
When my boyfriend stepped up and said he wanted a coffee flavor, her eyes lit up like Christmas morning and ran off with a handful of spoons. She came back with 5 different samples. He ended up with the All Nighter — coffee ice cream with Oreos and cookie dough!
Seriously do yourself a favor, skip Kohr’s and Dairy Queen and give all your ice cream dollars here.
We will be back!

I died and went to dark chocolate heaven with their homemade flavor: «Serious Chocolate Addiction!» Ice cream can be expensive at Rehoboth Beach, usually costing $ 4.50 or more. For this price you should spend it on something special. This place has 100 different ice cream flavors and everything is home made. They’ve also got funky names of some of them, like «Motor Oil,» «Bacon,» and «Better Than Sex,» LOL. The service was great too. There was a huge crowd, but they have alot of servers who will even leave the stand to come into the crowd to get your order. We will definitely recommend this place to our family and friends.

Really good ice cream can be found at the Ice Cream Store. I first heard about this store from the Food Network. Although I chickened out from trying the Ghost Pepper ice cream, I did try their Ooey Gooey, Creamy Strawberry, African Vanilla, Milk Chocolate Crack. All were freaking awesome! I will definitely come back whenever I visit Rehoboth Beach. It’s a must not a maybe. I am intrigued and interested in trying their Bacon, Corn, Catching Fire, and Booger flavors in the future.

If you’re craving ice cream, and happen to be in the Rehoboth Beach area, then this is the place you should go. They have an insane amount of flavors, a lot of which you won’t find anywhere else. The flavor I got was called Chocolate I Don’t Give A Fork, and it was delicious. It’s milk chocolate ice cream with chocolate chips, cookie dough, brownies, pretzels, and crushed oreos. Other flavor they have include Zombie, Booger, Ghost Pepper!, Lucky Charms, My Milkshake Brings All the Boys to the Store, African Vanilla, Peanut Butter and Jelly, Pumpkin Pecan, etc. You have to go to the website and checkout the flavors list.
It is a little pricey, but the place is located on a beach boardwalk so you can’t expect anything different. I believe it was around $ 4-​$ 5 for a small, but so worth it. Make sure to check this place out if you get the chance.

My family just happened to come across this ice cream place while exploring the boardwalk at Rehoboth beach. Of course the most appealing factor was the fact of the 100’s of different ice cream flavors and different choices they had! Many of the flavors were homemade giving an extra appeal to them. In addition, their creative names can give a good laugh. I tried three different flavors that day, «I Don’t Give a Fork» «Stifler’s Mom» and «Hella Good Lavender». Among these, I’d say «Hella Good Lavender» was really hella good and interesting taste It’s a very strong lavender taste with some of the actual flower in it! And although some might think it would taste bland or herby, the ice cream was just the perfect balance of sweet and lavender XD If I ever visit Delware again, this is the way to go for ice cream *3*

This is it. This is a hit. It has 4.5 stars right now, and it deserves them.
This is ice cream heaven. They make their own flavors… And they live up to the «cream» part of «ice cream». The ice cream here is very creamy, and the flavors are bold and live up to whatever it is they happen to be called.
There are an array of toppings, an array of flavors, cones or bowls, and you can even get your ice cream on a waffle.
Oh, and they have ghost pepper ice cream, which you have to sign a waiver to try or buy.
All-​in-​all, it lives up to the hype. Don’t let the huge crowd of people at night scare you off… It may be hard to read the signs and all, but service is still super fast and efficient.

So many different, creative, homemade flavors to choose from! Ordered two scoops of Rose Petal for myself, a bit disappointed that it tasted predominantly like mango. Had a few bites of Crack, too, and despite its creaminess still found it to be pretty bland. Sorry, but this place is a tourist trap. The most interesting part about The Ice Cream Store is that they offer a Ghost Pepper flavor, which requires you to be 18+ and sign a waiver.

This is a hole in the wall shop with the most amazing assortment or flavors. I haven’t gone too far off the beaten path in terms of flavors but have fond memories of their salted caramel and «third trimester». Their variety is overwhelming but worth searching and sampling to find the right choice.
There is almost always a line but they have a ton of staff moving as quickly as they can to move it along and its a great people watching spot. We don’t visit this area without a stop here.
Plus they have a self service sprinkle bar!

Have you ever been to an ice cream parlor with more than 100 flavors? Oh well, this ice cream parlor will bring you overjoy.
They are known for serving homemade ice cream. From tasting it, I agreed with it. Their choices are unique, creative, flavorful, tasty and inviting. A scoop is the appropriate serving. If you ask for 2 scoops, it will be too much unless you really have a sweet tooth. Pricing is above comparably. Is it the location or what they are trying to sell.
Come and try yourself. Worth stopping by. It will just made your summer day!

Creamy, unique, and homemade ice cream for a good price! I wish I were here for a few more days just to sample more of the intriguing flavors.
I ordered two scoops in a cup, one flavor each: the famed «Crack» flavor, and «Death by Peanut Butter.» Each flavor was super rich (both combined were a meal for me) and enjoyable.
Next time I’d totally go for the ghost pepper flavor (which requires the requester to be at least 18 and sign a waiver)!

Long lines but it moves quickly, some really indulgent flavors. Great quality and friendly staff. Had the Carmel river, with tons of Carmel flowing through the ice cream, Stifler’s Mom was awesome, slight heat from the chilis was a great touch! Wife had the elderberry ice cream, flavor of the month very subtle flavor but clean, cold and refreshing. Going to try the ghost pepper ice cream next time I am in town! Gotta sign a waiver so you know it’s good.

This ice cream parlor has so many flavors that it’s overwhelming. I think it’s the only store that has a huge crowd in front of it throughout the night, you’d certainly find it. I tried a variation of cookie dough, forgot what it called, but it was really good.
Go see for yourself. And go during the day or early evening if you don’t wanna wait forever.

OH MY…
This was hands-​down the best ice cream I’ve ever had in my life. Tried Lucky Charms (incredible) & Peanut butter Oreo (spectacular).
The best thing about this place is that their ice cream in general is very tasty. It’s very
creamy and super fresh. They have SO many flavors but I’m willing to bet majority of them are delicious. Get there early… the line gets very long but it’s worth the wait.

This is my favorite ice cream shop at the beach. They have the best menu with a ton of flavors. They have Booger ice cream as well as Better than Sex ice cream. Two of my favorites are Samoa and serious Chocolate Addiction. They even have an ice cream with Ghost Pepper. The best part is that they let you taste as many as you want.

You really have to see it. Got to be one of the greatest ice cream joints on the face of the Earth. You walk up to see the dizzying array of color panels representing the multitude of flavors. You’d be hard pressed to dream up one they haven’t already. They wisely installed a flavor roulette wheel on the counter to help people decide. Not a problem for me. One taste of the Salted Caramel and it’s all she wrote. Amazingly, they’re not just about variety. The quality is also exquisite. You can get your order in a freshly made waffle cone, waffle bowl or regular cup and there’s a big topping station out front. But they don’t stop at ice cream. There are smoothies, water ices and any milkshake imaginable or unimaginable.
Being a less than perfect world, on three occasions (in the last two years) they were out of my flavor. And, on the last occasion they did have it; it was different– less flavorful, less salt, less caramel. I’ve got my fingers crossed this was just an aberration.

Homemade Ice Cream with TONS of creative flavors.
Free sprinkle bar.
This is the best place for ice cream at the beach.

Super delicious ice cream. Line moves very quickly. Many times we walked right up (let’s be honest… we hit this place like once a day).
Free sprinkles! My 3 year old would give 7 458 765 stars just for that alone.