Picciotti’s Pizza

They have great pizza, my problem is that everytime I order pizzas the toppings are no longer on the pizza by the time I get them. Either the driver is slamming on brakes or taking turns too fast. TIP: order the pizza extra crispy. This will keep the bottom firm. Also, they have AWESOME onion rings.
All and all Picciotti’s is my go to pizza delivery.

Being from Long Island, pizza is in my blood. I gave Picciotti’s pizza a try for the first time today (for takeout). I ordered a 16″ half veggie. Tip: check their website — they offer a $ 1.50 off coupon for any 16″ pie.
In short: I have to say Picciotti’s is my new favorite pizza in and around Richmond. It’s just like some of the best pizza found on Long Island and in Queens. Excellent!
The pizzaria looks to be a little small, so I’m not sure how the dining experience would be for those who dine in. The 4 stars is for the pizza in and of itself.
My wife had some veggies slices. She slightly prefers Nonna’s veggie over Picciotti’s — mainly because she throught Picciotti’s veggie was a little too salty. Then again, my wife didn’t grow up in a pizza household… so her vote doesn’t count. Jk… this would have been 5 stars otherwise.

Have gotten pizza from here many times and it is great NY style pizza. We have had the white pizza, pepperoni and sausage. Everything was good. Highly recommend.

First visit a few days ago. Small, clean restaurant. I placed my order: extra large with pepperoni, bacon and fresh mushrooms. I waited in my car til it was done. When I came back inside about 15 mins later, the pizza was ready and pipping hot! The guy who brought it (seemed to be the owner) was very nice and very proud of the pizza. It was still hot when I got it home about 10 – 15 mins later. Really good pizza! Great amount of toppings, good crust. I think we found our local spot!

I happened on this spot by chance and I’m glad I did. The pizza is very good. The subs are too — the Italian is my favorite.

This place is awesome NY style pizza. My go to pizza place. My favorite is the white pizza. Ricotta on pizza is the truth! It seems a little expensive at first but the pies are big. Even I get a few meals out of one.

Based on recent Unilocal Reviews, I noticed this Picciotti’s was fairly close to my home so I decided to try it out.
Good first impression with a clean atmosphere and welcoming staff. With only time for a quick lunch… I ordered a Chicago Deep Dish Style slice and a NY thin crust slice. Both were fantastic.
I did have to ask for real utensils since only the plastic ones were there at the self serve kiosk.
This place is a fairly small space however if you love pizza… this is one pace to try.
The next time I will order a whole pizza for take out so I can be assured it hasn’t been sitting out and served slice by slice until I get the last reheated slice of a 2 hour old pie.

Solid NY pizza at reasonable price. The real deal. Loved the portobello white… love this small place.

Best slice shop in town. It’s to the right of the Food Lion off Broad east of Costco. It’s worth traveling for. Good New York style, Chicago deep dish. You’ll be glad you made the extra effort.

I’m from NY and would say it’s best pizza in Richmond or close. Thin crisp crust, sauce just right and the cheese was the correct blend. I am too far for delivery but pick up from here when I can.

Closest thing to NY pizza … he has knishe n garlic knots too. Will be back for sho.

We tried this pizza for the first time last night. We will be back. It is a great thin crust pizza with a slightly crunchy crust. The pizza is very similar to NY style pizza, and the best one we have been able to find in RVA. I would go back. We also ordered the cheesy garlic bread. It was nothing special. I would love to see them add some type of a cheese stick to the menu.

Avoid this place ! They are super rude.
We ordered pizza from this place for a business meeting and spent about $ 100. They thought is was necessary that folks ask for napkins and if they don’t they don’t provide any. Rude customer service and blah pizza (maybe my appetite was ruined by the customer service my colleagues and I received)
Its pizza who eats pizza and doesn’t use not 1 napkin?! The guy I spoke with claimed to be a manager and supports the ridiculous «rule». We order from others establishments after that.

Horrible grilled chicken salad the chicken looked very old and dry!!! I didn’t feel comfortable eating it. And the employee acted as if he didn’t care at all!

I ordered a pizza, Greek salad and jalepeno poppers. Pizza was delivered hot and fresh. The pizza ingredients were generous and the pizza was delicious. The Greek salad was jumbo and the ingredients were fresh. The jalapeño poppers were delicious. I’m very satisfied with everything I ordered. I will order again. Everything was larger than expected and very delicious. The delivery person Sal, was very professional and thoughtful. I will definitely order again.

Moved to Richmond from New York area. Been hunting for our fave spots locally and tried this spot for take out.
Definitely enjoyed the white pizza. Lots of garlicy goodness but wish the ricctoa wouldn’t have been a dollop but spread around more. Easy fix, of course. Would give it a solid 7 or 7.5 out of all the amazing pizza I’ve had in my life time.
The Chicago style will be a pass for me. Stick to thin crust on your order in my opinion. The crust felt a little stale — not crispy crunchy like I would have hoped. Maybe a 5. We did take out too so that may have ruined the crust a bit in all fairness.
Definitely going to keep hunting for our pizza joint but may come back and go steady with the white pizza if no better luck other places.

I’m from NY. I’m snobby about pizza. I LOVE this place. I love that when I call I feel like I’m talking to Uncle Tony’s college buddy whose happy to hear I’m doing well. Go here, eat here, enjoy.

I just stumbled across Picciotti’s because I was cruising the Eat Street app looking for something to eat. Since then, we’ve ordered delivery from here several times, and I’m always happy.
I’ve had the meatball and the sausage parmesan subs, and the cheesesteak. we’ve had the white pizza (INCREDIBLE) and just regular cheese pizza. My daughter loves the ravioli, she eats the entire plate every time (and she usually eats like a bird).
It’s definitely more like quality NY pizza, so I love that, and I’m never disappointed. It’s a great deal for the price and consistent. The menu is typical Italian/​American cuisine and everything we’ve had tastes fresh and delicious.
The pizzas are pretty exceptional.

Closest to NY style pizza on the area.
We decided to try them tonight since we saw the reviews. We ordered hot wings, white pizza and a cheese steak. We loved that when we came in they were actually chopping their own mushrooms. They were very friendly and prompt, it only took 15 mins for everything to come out. Everything tasted fresh and authentic, the hot wing sauce tasted homemade. We will definitely be trying them again.

There’s no hiding it, I love pizza. Even more than ordering out whole pizzas, I enjoy pizza by the slice. Unable to decide what we wanted one night for dinner, we decided to stop on by to check out Picciotti’s. In short, best decision we probably made that day.
–Food: As the place is newly opened in the last couple of months, they’ve been promoting their menu through ValPack, newspapers, and other ads. You’ve likely seen what they offer, but basically they have your typical pizza place fare; pizzas, subs, and some pasta dishes.
The first time we went here was with my fiancée’s family, and somehow after all was said and done, we ended up just ordering an Extra Large Cheese pizza and some garlic knots. We came around 6:30 PM or so I believe, so they didn’t have many by-​the-​slice options available, hence why we ended up with a whole pizza. (A 20″ one at that!)
Simply put, the pizza here is great. The immediate stand out quality is their crust, which is nice and crisp. More often than not, I find Richmond pizza a bit soft and grows soggy, but Picciotti’s stays crisp the entire time. The end is especially nice and has a very nice flavor. The rest of the pizza is good too, with not too much sauce, good tasting cheese, and a bit of herbs. It’s not an overly seasoned pizza, which I suppose is a negative, but the pizza still tastes great overall. Honestly, this is one of the closest things to that «New York Style Pizza» that I love so dearly.
The garlic knots were pretty good, but nothing stood out about them that I feel I need more than a sentence describing them as anything more than good garlic knots.
The second time we went (just today actually), we went around lunch time on a Sunday. They had plenty of varieties to choose from in by-​the-​slice form, including but not limited to: Pepperoni, Cheese, 4 Cheese and Sausage, Tomato, Pepperoni and Bacon, Buffalo Chicken (!), and «The Grandma». Buffalo Chicken is designated with the exclamatory punctuation as it is uncontested my favorite type of pizza. If you don’t think Buffalo Chicken is the best type of pizza, you are simply incorrect. (Just kidding!)
The slices were great. They have one of those warming /​crisping ovens that gives a nice added crisp to the bottom of the crust. Basically everything that applied to the above description of the whole pizza applies to the individual slices. Probably our new favorite place for slices.
–Cost: The Extra Large pizza was $ 16 and the garlic knots about $ 4. Two slices of cheese and a drink is a $ 6 lunch combo and two slices of specialty slices (like buffalo chicken) and a drink is $ 7. Just about average with any pizza by the slice place.
–Atmosphere: Picciotti’s is located in the lot with Food Lion /​Teppanyaki’s Buffet. It’s not my favorite lot just because I don’t particularly go to anything in the plaza, but it’s easily accessible from West Broad and has a huge parking lot, so you won’t run into any issues there. Don’t let the plain and uninspiring area throw you, it’s what’s in the pizza oven that counts.
–Service: Fantastic. Everyone that works there has been really great, both in letting us know what options are available, explaining the meal deals, making sure we were happy throughout the meal, and even helping us set up some tables together outside.
–Overall: We wanted a good New York Style pizza and Picciotti’s delivered (get it, because pizza, delivery joke, oh, just forget it.) I think we found our new favorite pizza by the slice place in the West End. There are probably more unique and flavorful pizzas at one of Richmond’s specialty wood fired or hipster pizza places, but if you’re in the mood for a couple great slices of pizza and a drink for $ 6 or $ 7, you can’t go wrong.