The Dock House

The lobster here rules. Really fresh and that butter dip doesn’t get any better. In a cool location near the marina.

We love this restaurant — the food is excellent. Recently, a group of us ate here and we had four different entrees (lobster roll, swordfish, fish tacos, and fish and chips). I had the lobster roll which was full of chunks of lobster, and the flavor was wonderful. We also had both kinds of chowder — New England and Manhattan. Both were great. If you are in the area and looking for fresh, good seafood, this is the place!

We liked this restaurant quite a bit. The soy burger was excellent. What was offered as paella was really seafood risotto But it was still very good.

Clam chowder and fried clams are good! Lobster bisque had one lonely piece of meat. Counter people not overly friendly.

Had crab cake appetizer and lobster bisque. They were both OK. The bisque had a tiny piece of lobster in it– I was expecting more– maybe it’s not supposed to have lobster in it but I was hoping it would. Both were super rich.

Legit new England chowder but should be served hotter. Average lobster roll.

I have been here for lunch and it was fabulous! At the end of August, eh not so much. Abigale takes your name and is amazing and on top of things!!! She will do you right. Our drink and dinner order was messed up however they did comp the salad they forgot but only after I pointed it out to them! As far as the cleaners YONIQUE has a great personality as is well up to the task!!! I would go for lunch next time or NOT in late August!

Great selection of mostly fried or grilled seafood. Minus one point for not having enough steamed fares. The price is reasonable, comparable to what one finds in the city. Everywhere else in the Hamptons the seafood prices are more than what one gets at the best seafood restaurants in Manhattan (Upstate, for example). It’s insane.

Ordered fried shrimp with waffle fries & fish tacos with nacho chips. The shrimp was crispy and served on a piece of bread; the tacos were fresh and came with a variety of dipping sauces.
The staff was friendly and the view of the harbor was spectacular!
My only complaint is that they serve everything in disposable containers with disposable utensils. It says that the containers are compostable, but how many people will actually do that? (We do, and took the containers home, but I assume most customers don’t have access to that.) Either get reusable dishes, or have a bin for composting the containers (and actually compost them).
We would definitely be interested in revisiting The Dock House… very good food here!

One of our favorite places in the Hamptons. Low key ambience, high quality food, drinks and service. Always a destination for my fiancée and me for the past 5 years visiting Sag! The lobster avocado rolls are always excellent as are the Bloody Mary’s. A must visit.

It’s a no frills seafood shack. Enjoy the harbor, walk the shops, and stop by for some quick fresh fresh seafood for lunch. Remember, it’s a «shack», but a nice one. You’ll be sitting at a diner like counter with a nice view of the boats in the harbor. So don’t expect a sit down meal at a table with a waiter. This is a place you get some great seafood, relax for a few minutes while you eat, then ramble on enjoying the rest of the harbor.

Came here on the way to Shelter Island. Very pleasant quick stop on the dock. Greatly enjoyed the lobster rolls. Very fresh cold lobster salad mixed with celery and mayo on a toasted bun. Tomato and lettuce on the side. They let you bring your own alcohol, so why not!

Got a lobster roll here over the weekend. It wasn’t the best I’ve had but not horrible either. There’s a ton of meat which is great but it’s a bit more of a lobster salad than chunks of lobster on a roll, but that’s a personal preference. Roll is nicely toasted and sweet. It comes with a side, I chose the salad which was 1 romaine lead and one slice of tomato. Next time I would try somewhere else for a lobster roll

Delicious we always get the fish and chips. Sit on the wharf and just chill life doesn’t get any better.

Classic seafood shack kinda joint. Fish tacos were excellent. Fried cod, huge pieces and great toppings.
Top 3 fish tacos I ever had. Raw oysters, average. Small place, right on the water. No alcohol served, bummer. I wanted a nice cold IPA.
Conclusion, 4 stars

Excelent spot for Lunch on a visit to the area. The lobster roll was super and seems to be the staple here, the fish tacos were excelent!

oooohhhhhhh me oooohhhhhhh my
Had the Oysters, Seafood Mix Plate, and cup of their award winning Clam Chowder.
Every bite and spoon of this meal was seafood heaven. Please take me back.

Best seafood in Sag Harbor! Everything was great.
The chowder was the perfect consistency, not too heavy, good flavor (tarragon?) but without detracting from the sweetness of the clams. Baked clams were the same, plenty of Clam in the stuffing, good flavor and not too bready. Lobster roll was what we came for and we weren’t disappointed. Big pieces of meat (near whole claws), just enough dressing to add flavor without covering up the sweet deliciousness of the lobsta’.
Clean and friendly interior. The only downside could be the size of the place. We nailed it during a post lunch lull in activity, but I’m certain the small shack has a real wait during peak sales.
Loved it!

They are located in such an amazing location at Sag Harbor. The location makes this place quite inviting. The staff was good to us. Welcoming, smiling and warm.
The food on the other hand, for the price you are paying isn’t that great. The lobster rolls/​BLT clearly is the best option, but is priced at a whopping $ 20. And the portion you get for that price. it’s too little! We also tried the Fried Shrimp. Decent portion here, but I am not a big fan of their fries. They look, taste a bit too greasy. Fried Shrimp on the other hand was pretty good.
1 Star for the Shrimp and 1 for the staff!

Have been here 3 times now and each time the seafood has been excellent. The salmon the other day was incredible. I highly recommend the mixed grilled seafood platter — skip the healthy salad and get the waffle fries! All great stuff. My only complaint– once again– too small portions of the fish!