I love, love this bakery. The girls are always so nice. I usually go in on a Friday morning to pick up donuts to bring to work. the Boston crème are like hockey pucks, they are so heavy and delicious! The jelly… Oh my God! I refuse to eat lousy dunkin donuts garbage after knowing Prestano’s. The only thing that absolutely kills me is my dad loved a good jelly donut. He passed away right after I moved to selden and before I knew about this place. I always feel bad that I never got to get him a jelly from here. He would have loved them.
Debbie H.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Selden, NY
So many selections and the smell eminating from it is amazing… bought the cheesecake which is delish
Zachary P.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Selden, NY
This is the best Bakery! The almond horse shoes are amazing and they always have good prices.
E K.
Évaluation du lieu : 2 Seaford, NY
Disappointed, girls there were not friendly and I was charged for bread different prices, each day.
Harry H.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 New York, NY
Parked behind this joint in one of the unmarked spots and ended up with a $ 3 raspberry crumb cake slice, which was tasty. A nice spot along MCR if you’re feening for something doughy.
Michael S.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Centereach, NY
I have never been to a bakery that I would give 5 stars to because I feel I can always bake something better at home. With that said this place is awesome. I have been going to the Prestanos in Nesconset my entire life, that is the brother of the baker in Selden. I thought the Nesconset location had the best jelly donuts even until I went to selden, they are insane. Their brownies are crazy too, all different sweet and sticky flavors. I also bought a black forest cake from there one day and that I had no hopes for because bakery cakes are usually made to last a few days at least which to me ruins the cake but not this one, it was great. Best bakery around.