Nick’s Pizza

I’d have given zero if I could have.
Delivery order placed 90 minutes ago. We were told 45 minutes. When we called to inquire about the order we were blown-​off and told «they’d get to it».
After 95 minutes it arrived. Cold
They’ve lost our business for good and should never get yours.

Only word I can use to describe this place is BAD!!! Food gets worse. Was forced to eat there tonite out of convenience. We visited a friend so we ordered local. Pizza has no taste and is like sponge. The rest of food not worth $ 78.00

Ordered takeout from here and 75% of the food we ordered was over cooked and/​or burnt. Fries were so hard we couldn’t even eat them. And the boneless wings were a little too crunchy for our liking. The rest of the food wasn’t bad, mediocre at best, definitely nothing to be impressed with. Took about an hour for food to be delivered which is a little longer than normal delivery times.

My friend usually orders stuff from here. He told me about a really good cheese steak which i’m a sucker for. I’ll probably be banned for saying this, but i’ll say it anyway… i think pizza shops in NJ have better cheese steaks than Philly. YUP… you read that right.
And Nick’s Pizza is one of them. The Rustic Cheese Steak is so bomb, so overwhelmingly delicious! I’ve had it once, and i’m a big fan of it. Even craving one now that i’m writing a review for it.
We also ordered some fries and two pies, one plain and one pepperoni. The fries they have are pretty good too. They are the extra crispy type and not overly salty. The pizza i thought was good, but the sauce/​cheese combo was slightly salty. The pizza dough was nice and the pizza itself was evenly baked.
We did pickup, so we had little interaction with customer service. The cashier that took care of us was pleasant.
Till next time, rustic cheese steak!

Very disappointed. Tonight I went here and the employees are not friendly. Most were sitting in booths eating. We felt very uncomfortable because God forbid we came in more than an hour before close. Food came quickly but I don’t love smelling cleaning products while I eat beside our table. Out of the whole place, they start cleaning the trash can next to us while we eat. I don’t appreciate being asked if the two pizza slices are really just for me and then when I went to eat the second slice I went up for a refill and they turned off the sofa machine at 9:10 when they close at 10. I will not be going back.

Nicks is ok great ways to order delivery or pick-​up. Foods ok not great but not Bobo either. Fast delivery

We were excited when Nick’s opened close to us a couple of years ago. We have had many pizzas from there. But lately the pizzas lack taste, have very little ingredients on them and they average of 10 – 20 longer than when they say the food is going to be ready. I hate having to stand there and watch people come and go with their pizzas when I was told 20 min and then had to wait 45 min for my pizza. The last time we bought a pizza from them there was very little green peppers and hardly any sauce. We ordered extra cheese and could tell no difference between it and regular cheese. It’s time to find some good pizza in Sicklerville. Sorry, Nick’s. We are done.

Bad customer service. Good food if they don’t mess up your order!!! I picked up my order and when I finally got home to eat it was incorrect. So I called them and had to drive back to correct my order and they did not care and charged me extra!!!

Best Pizza in Sicklerville for sure! My husband LOVES Nick’s Pizza and this location is always clean and the staff are always happy. My only complaint is the layout of the parking lot. There is a «one way» so I have to go around the whole parking lot because of the direction I turn in. Very frustrating, but the food is delicious. Pizza, Cheesesteaks, chicken fingers, crab chowder, you name it, its delicious.

Pizza was delicious and I got about three servings of chicken parm for less than ten dollars… awesome!
Four stars instead of five because my dine in experience was less than desirable. They had about six too many people working but the dining room was still somehow dirty. Crust and fries on the floor, tables with crumbs everywhere, etc. I’m not usually picky about that kind of stuff but the dirty dining room + surplus of people working screams they need better management.

Best pizza in the sicklerville area and best I’ve had in south jersey hands down. Nick’s opened not too long ago on Cross Keys in a little strip mall right near the corner of sicklerville road and after driving past a couple times I decided to give it a try. So glad I did. They have specials everyday ranging all over the menu. Not only are the pizzas great but their rustic sandwich’s are delicious too. So if your tired of crap over priced pizza (looking at you venuto’s) then give Nick’s a try. Wont be disappointed.