Solorzano Bros Pizza

We have ordered from this place before and it was okay but Pizza Pi had a problem with their ovens. Anyway, we ordered takeout and when we got there we paid but the person at the counter didn’t say how long it would be for our order. We we told 30 min from when we called. They were very busy and he waited on 15+ people and several phone calls before gathering our order which was sitting on top of the oven since we got there. Then when he started to collect it he realized they didn’t make the garlic bread so the guy waiting on us made it. It was nothing more than hoagie bread with butter and cheese. Don’t get it. The best part is when he realized the delivery person took one of our pizzas. He made another but we had to wait for it. He did apologize but did nothing for our bill or offered anything for the inconvenience.
The food. The 2 pizzas which sat on top of the oven were dry. The fresh one was better but average. The Italian hoagie was pretty good.
This place is pretty expensive. $ 18 for a plain cheese pizza.

the pizza is shitty and seriously overpriced. their only redeeming quality is that they deliver late.

This place looks very small but I will always say «don’t go by its look». This place bakes our pizza right in front of your eyes and they have some best lunch deals and staff looked very professional when compared to people in other pizza places and friendly

As a Bostonian, I appreciate great pizza and didn’t think I’d ever find great pizza in Florida. I was wrong… this pizza is outstanding, as good anything in Boston!
I had pizza delivered and picked up a couple of orders. Very nice staff. When my pizza was delayed the counter man gave me a free garlic roll to enjoy while I waited. Way to go, I’ll be back!

A couple of things…
You can’t split a pizza?! What the fuck kind of shit is this?! I was told that if I wanted to split one if have to pay $ 2 extra for whatever I was changing on the other side.
So let me get this straight…
Half of the «Hoboken Heart Attack» and half «Classic Margherita» is more expensive than a full Hoboken Heart Attack (which mind you… has meatballs, pepperoni, sausage & bacon)?!
Really?! So me taking OFF 4 ingredients and adding 2 is gonna cost me more?!
Because THAT makes sense! Said NO ONE EVER!
Also, after checking in — and being notified that I get a free soft drink if I order 2 slices… I figured I’d get one of I ordered… I don’t know…8?! Which is a full pizza. Well WRONG!!! You literally ONLY get it IF you order ONLY TWO
slices!!! So I changed my stupid order from a FULL pizza to 2 slices to get the drink. How the fuck does that even make sense business wise?!
They are idiots!
Then my friends get their white pizza they ordered… only to find out they fucked up and added red sauce. Smh.
Awful!!!
Just fucken skip!!!

I’ve lived in Hoboken for some time now and thought it was funny that there is a pizza place in Siesta Key that markets «Hoboken Pizza» right on the window. When you walk in you feel like you’re right back in Hoboken with all of the pictures or gangsters and Frank Sinatra on the walls. It reminded me of Luca Brasi’s Deli in Hoboken (another spot that you must go to when in Hoboken).
I had the Sinatra slice, my gf had a plain and we split a garlic knot. The garlic knot was massive and delicious and the slices were just like back home. My only complaint is that there are so many great food places right in the area that it’s difficult to get hungry for a slice of pizza! My gf and I usually get a big breakfast at another restaurant in the area and then have no room for lunch!

THis is our second visit here. The staff is sooooo nice. They were quick to take our order. The menu is all pizzas. None of that extra dishes that have nothing to do with Pizza and make the menu unnecessarily long and the produce less fresh. Their pizza combinations were witty and delicious.
We got a Greek pizza. Surprise, they have a gluten free crust that was surprisingly tasty. We got the Greek on a gluten free crust. We also got a sausage pizza on a «normal» crust. As an appetizer we got a house salad and an Antipasto salad. Both were great. If you feel splurgey on the calories, please get the garlic knots little sandwiches. Those were scrumptious to look at. We wanted to save them calories :/​. Decidedly they were every bit as good as we remembered, A most!!!

PERFECTION! Every other word of this review you read is wasting your time that could be spent eating the best pizza south of New Jersey. If you want incredible pizza in an atmosphere that cannot be beat get directions and get over here!

Surprised by low rating here on Unilocal.Appears reading review that the negative comments are related to delivery service. I cannot comment on the delivery service because we ate at the restaurant. The experience that we did have was amazing shaded outdoor seating. The atmosphere was nice with mostly Frank Sinatra music inside and out. The pizza was a wonderful surprise. I had spinach and white cheese pizza. It was the best pizza I have had since Naples, Italy. That is not an exaggeration. And that was about six years ago. Would definitely encourage people to check this out. Before 7 PM two slices of any kind of pizza and a drink is only seven dollars. Can’t beat the price or the taste. Will definitely be back.

Ordered a pizza for delivery. When they said it would be more than an hour we said we’d pick it up.
The pizza was not good. The crust tasted like it was pre-​made and was tough and leather-​like. It had no taste at all. Wasn’t even puffed up on the edges.
The toppings were just okay. I don’t think they care about putting out a quality product By using good ingredients.
I will keep trying other places to find a good pizza.

Excellent pizza, New Jersey style. We are close by and have stopped in whenever we are here. Get the large rather than the small since the difference in price makes it worth it. I had the meatball sub last year and it is good and huge. A very good value. Three dollar can cokes was not a good calling card nor the nine dollar glasses of wine which seem inconsistent with what this place pupports to be. Still worth a trip for the pizza and subs. Leave off the drinks.

Ordered late at night, delivered within 20 minutes, hot and tasty. Very good pizza and friendly efficient service!

Pizza was OK. Good, but not an «Oh boy! I want to have it again» taste. The salad we ordered was outstanding.

My wife and and I shared an SBP sub and Greek salad. Fresh, in house made, bread prosciutto salami ham provolone lettuce tomato red onion spices mayo oil and balmasic vinegar… awesome sandwich. The salad was huge with arachok black and green olives feta cheese onions and all in perfect balance.

This pizza is where it is at!!! Never did I think I would find New York Style pizza in Siesta Key, Florida!!! After a long day at the beach we decided we needed a little hold me over before dinner and passed by this pizzeria on the way back to the car. WOW am I glad we saw this place!!! SOOOO GOOD!!! We just got a few slices of the cheese and pepperoni but the crust was perfect. Not burnt, not too crispy, not too doughy… I’m telling you, it was perfect. The sauce was great and there was the perfect ratio of cheese to pepperoni.
Not only was the slice I had to die for but the inside of the restaurant was super cool… All done up in Italian mafia/​gangster paraphernalia. Being an Italian from New York it was cool to feel «at home» even though I was in Florida. I recommend this pizzeria if you’re in the area. I hope to be back someday to try more on their menu and even order a whole pizza to go. Bravo!

My family and I are from New Jersey and we wanted a really great slice of pizza that tasted like it was from home and that’s exactly what we got here! Wonderful family owned business. Service was exceptional and the pizza was PERFECT! We’re so glad to have found this Gem while on our vacation!

We are self admittedly Pizza snobs. My wife is from Jersey and we get our snobbery from amazing Pizza from Jersey & New York. The photos of the Pizzas look good from Unilocal and learning the history of the owners we decided to walk over. We were not disappointed. Staff was friendly and chatted us up.
We got The Godfather pizza. Prosciutto and Basil. It’s Jersey style Pizza. You can fold the crust. It’s chewy and has just a little crunch at the edge. Money! The sauce was very good. I would have loved just a little more toppings, but my guess is each pizza is different. We are only on Siesta Key for 4 nights and I’m already trying to figure out when we can go back.
The reviewer guy who says Dominos would put them to shame has no idea what he is talking about… The only thing Dominos puts to shame is cat food.
Try it and I don’t believe you will be disappointed.

Ordered from the late night menu
Not a fan. Ordered 8÷7÷15 late night around 12. Mozzarella sticks were under cooked and the marinara sauce was greasy and bland. Stuck with a std Pepperoni Pizza and it ok, not good but ok. They used TOO much fresh basil. It was very leafy and overpowering.
The best part was the boneless wings. We also got the knots but again marinara was not good, so. All in all, Dominos will put them to shame. Couple other good places in the area ncluding Ricos… Will not try again

If you want New York /​New Jersey pizza in Florida this is the place to go!
Employees are friendly and the place is spotless.

First time in Siesta Key today with the family. Drove all night, everybody starving after debacle of check in at condo. Ordered one large pizza with two toppings and an order of garlic cheesy bread.
Note: Two dollar delivery charge on all delivery orders and all delivery orders are credit card only (I offered to pay cash and they wouldn’t take it).
I was told 45 – 60 minutes on the order as they were busy this evening. I called at one hour, 10 minutes as I had one kid asleep already and one kid crying because he was so hungry. The person who answered the phone stated that the order had just gone out the door.
I then received a phone call from the delivery driver asking the address again. I gave it to him again thinking maybe he didn’t have a slip with the address number on it. He then proceeded to tell me that he didn’t know where my location was located; I asked him where he was and he read me off the current location he was at. I told him that addresses go in sequential order so that was how you could figure out where I was located.
He got out of the car and asked if I had a pen to sign the CC slip. I can’t say that I have ever had that done to me. Asked the hubby to toss down a pen after having him rummage thru my purse for one.
I signed the sheet and opted for no tip due to 1) delivery charge being assessed 2) not taking cash for a delivery order 3) order taking longer than I had been quoted 4) having to scrounge up a pen to sign CC slip 5) order not being brought to my 2^nd floor stoop and 6) not being able to comprehend how to determine that addresses of houses are in sequential order. Delivery driver then said that the tip is not included in the delivery fee and I explained all of my reasons why I was not giving a tip.
Pizza was okay. I would not order it again; not enough cheese on it. «garlic cheese bread» had no cheese on it whatsoever.