BJ’s True Old Fashioned Batch Ice Cream

BJ’s is a solid choice for some ice cream in Sisters.
They have 30+ choices for ice cream. I’ve tried 4 or so so far and all have been good. Huckleberry and Oregon trail (blackberry, chocolate, and hazlenuts) have been my favorites so far — but I haven’t heard anybody complain about any of their flavors yet.
The older gentleman that works there is super nice and friendly. The younger ladies were less so but still just fine.
Highly recommended!

Seems to be the local place for ice cream. The vanilla is great. No vanilla bean or double vanilla options or my review would be five stars.

I’ve had this bookmarked for a while and it’s been on my to-​do list when visiting sisters. I tried the huckleberry ice cream and it was amazing! You could tell it was homemade and the berries were fresh and flavorful. This is a great one to try! I also came back the next day to try to black cherry cheesecake and it was delicious as well.

Definitely the best ice cream between Bend and Portland with a partial view of the original Sisters Crosswalk. We stopped in Sisters to buy liquor, take a spin through the farmers market, try out the crosswalk and of course get some BJs. Don’t waste your time on alpaca blankets and that store that sells drawstring cotton pajamas, we were in and out of this town in under 45 minutes. Now that’s how you do Sisters.

Nice ice cream place in the quaint town of Sisters, OR. Went there while we were camping in the nearby Deschutes forest.
They have a nice long selection of ice creams. Very reasonably priced, and one serving comes with 2 huge scoops so you can basically get two diff. flavors. They had Kahlua flavored ice cream which you don’t see usually and that was excellent. The other one I tried was Pralines and cream which was very good to. definitely worth a stop if you like ice cream and are in the area.

A family favorite for dessert in Sisters, quirks and all.
There are no shortage of places to get dessert in town. The classic Sno Cap for soft serve, the newcomer, Cuppa Yo, for frozen yogurt and Ali’s, the other choice for ice cream, across the street.
BJ’s has been in Sisters for a few years, but it feels like longer since the signage references their first location in Florence that opened in 1978. They have a great selection of Oregon-​influenced flavors like the Oregon Trail (my personal favorite) and Marionberry, and have generous scoops. It is old-​fashioned ice cream, made with no chemicals and no colors.
On the downside, they tend to feel understaffed and so the wait can be longer than I’d like. But, there is plenty to see while you wait. They always have a bunch of other random items for sale in the store from herbal teas to Red Bull infused drinks, accompanied by funny signs. I personally wish they had more indoor seating and continued the old school ice cream parlor theme throughout the space. I’m always amused by the amount of blinged out accessories for sale, but never see anyone shopping in that area.
Great location in the center of town and good old school ice cream. All the rest is a distraction.

This place is a great place to take the family for an ice cream. They have a large selection for all tastes

Best ice cream I have had in years. And so many choices, I had a hard time deciding. Yummy!

So good.

BJs aren’t just… steakhouses. BJ’s Old Fashioned Ice Cream is a chain that started in Florence (Oregon) back in 1978. The ice cream parlor in Sisters opened in 2010. Sisters, Oregon, is a small town with a Wild West flair. Having an ice cream parlor with old Coca Cola ads blends right in.
They have diverse offerings– Italian sodas, malteds, frozen lemonade, Oregon Trail ice cream (chocolate with hazelnut&blackberries) It’s a friendly little place.

Delicious family owned ice cream shop! Super friendly service. They have a wonderful selection of flavors, many featuring local ingredients. I love that they make their own ice cream. Our whole family enjoyed it.

Excellent ice cream! What more could you ask for?

The best icecream in Sisters! We stop here every time through town and love it! My son also got the silver gumball this time and won a free scoop! He was so excited!

This is the place to go for ice cream in Sisters. Delicious ice cream and friendly service. We couldn’t have asked for more. They make their own ice cream and fudge and everything we tried was excellent. We had a bad experience at a different Sisters ice cream store so we know where we’ll be going from now on.

I had been to BJs Old Fashioned while passing through Florence on the coast. Was thrilled when, to our surprise, this excellent ice cream shop had opened up in Sisters. Outstanding homemade ice cream. Tons of flavors too. You’ve got to try the blackberry cheesecake flavor, it;s amazing! Very friendly service.