The Deli Counter

Everything here is good!

Great food! Yummy pizza! Owner and staff really care. They’ve been open for almost a decade! The lunch specials can be amazing! Starting a dinner menu also, will be open till 9pm. When my family visits I use their catering service. Delicious! Highly recommended

Love this deli! Stuck in Hsmpton traffic and came across this little gem! Food is really great… everything fresh and home made! BLT with avocado on croissant was amazing! Back to Hamptons two days later and couldn’t wait to revisit this place!
Prices are quite reasonable, considering the location… but the food is so good, you won’t care about the price anyway!
One guy from NYC pays the Jitney to
bring his favorite sandwich to NYC!
Don’t miss this place!
You will love it!

Excellent food! Fresh cut meats! Great atmosphere! Owner is one of the nicest people you will meet in New York. he was very hopeful to this traveler from Georgia! highly recommend this joint.

So, I decided so go meatless on this one. I know strange
But I opted for the grilled veggie pesto sandwich and I must say, it was daaaaaamn Rico!
Saucy.
And large. I ate half, took a 30min, break and finished the other half while making my way back to the city.
Eggplant, yellow and green pepper, onions are grilled and soft and very flavorful, w fresh mozzarella, tomato slices and your pesto sauce.
The grilled veggies are juicy, so it runs down your hands. Lick it!

Incredible food — the Mario Batali sandwich is simply amazing, I think it’s the best sandwich on the East End. It is actually enough to feed four people, so luckily you can just order a half. Imagine every type of Italian meat sliced generously on to a huge loaf of garlic bread, piled with fresh mozzarella and basically every other imaginable topping for the ultimate Italian hero. Excellent pizza, and good service!

I just got lunch from this place after not having been in since they first opened. I used to get their breakfast sandwiches which were great when they first opened. Today I got the Bobby Flay, and it was terrible. The pork was obviously microwaved, chewy and practically inedible. The onions were raw red onions and not sauteed yellow onions which is what they should be. I ate part of half of the sandwich and threw the rest out. I will never go back as they obviously take no care to make sure they are putting out quality food to the public. They were, however, packed with people when I went, and it’s obvious that they value quantity over quality which is a real shame. If you want a quality sandwich, go to Schmidt’s or Sean’s Place. This place is a waste of money.

Steer clear of this place. Mediocre food, overpriced ($ 20 for a kids sandwich and 4 meatballs) poor service, as if they are doing you a favor helping you. We went twice in one day and the blonde woman with negative energy clearly had better things to do than help us… While ordering my husband opened an ice tea, I told her but she forgot to ring it up. Once outside he realized she forgot and ran back in to pay… She didn’t say thank you or anything. There are so many great delis in the area, no need to go to this one… The meatballs were salty and I asked her to heat them… I guess she didn’t hear? Or maybe I’m being too nice… nothing special here unless you like pizza that’s been sitting out all day, runny expensive tuna salad, salty high dollar meatballs and poor service!

Well let see.
Music is ridiculously loud
Limited selection of bagels
Hot water for tea is molten hot so you need a double cup
The lids also don’t fit the cups right
Got two bagels with cream cheese, lg tea, lg coffee $ 8.52. Typical prices for the area
The music was so loud my ears were ringing when I left.
The food used to be great. Didn’t try any of it today

How can you not be a fan of Mike Mossalino (sorry if I butchered the spelling). He’s the hardest working chef in show business. A TV chef in his own right, always with a joke and smile but most of all he creates a dining experience with his catering that will leave you begging for more.
I’ve tried his pizza — simply marvelous, ask for a hamburger — one of the best I have had in the Hamptons, some of the pasta salad dishes are delish, when you ask for a meatball sub here get ready for a gigantic tasty sandwich but make sure you grab a box of napkins. Mike is as good at preparing the common man’s food as he is at fine cuisine. I forget the name of the appetizer he served at Dan’s Taste of Two Forks event, but it was exquisite. (BTW, the Dan’s Taste of Two Forks allowed me to try 40 restaurants and I hear they will be doing it again next July)
Mike runs this deli and serves a selection of meals to go that will leave your mouth watering — when you hire Mike as a caterer you GET YOUR MONEY“S WORTH. and he’ll deliver and serve it himself. I’m a fan.

Awesome Deli! They are definitely my new favorite. They have great sandwiches at reasonable prices, and a great selection! They also have one of the best pizza’s in town — no joke. I was hesitant to try their pizza since the place which resided in the building beforehand had hands down the WORST pizza and dirtiest atmosphere, but I tried it and it was great! Who would have thought!