Pita Pita On the Hill

I love stopping at small local shops for lunches. This one offered sandwiches and soups so it seemed a good place to try. Very clean well kept restaurant, menu boards are easy to read, so on first glance impressive. The Monte Cristo I had was definitely not a traditional take but was tasty. The lettuce gave it some much needed texture. But the honey mustard was bland. Other than that no complaints on the food. My biggest complaint and reason for fewer stars, is how I saw who I can only assume was a manager essentially reprimanding another employee about how they rang something up in front of a customer and seeing how visually embarrassed both he the other girl was. One of my biggest pet peeves is a manager not knowing how to professionally solve a problem and bring the reprimanding in the back away from public eye. Something perhaps they can do so I don’t feel awkward watching it when I didn’t really need a meal and a show.

They were kind to accommodate 20 of my friends and I. Let’s get right down to business. I had the gyro with lamb. On presentation, it looked a bit underwhelming, with the pita most notably being dry, flat, and lacking texture (think: fluffy, moist). However be aware that the meat was not prepared from the «rotating spit» you and I are familiar with, aka «shawarma.» So the meat was moist, but lacking the thin shaved texture and the natural smoked flavor that’s imparted by charcoal/​wood. The tzatziki sauce was thin, and lacking flavor somewhat. I craved more sourness from it, wishing it had more scent of dill, lemon, and cucumber. But it tasted more like a «lite yogurt mayo.» ⁴⁄₁₀
However, their gyro is redeemed because of the paninis my friend let me try. They were delicious. They surely know how to make paninis. I saw that the italian panini had real mozzarella balls, pesto, tomatoes, and peppers. Gosh, so darn good. I actually liked it better than the tuna one he had me try. ⁷⁄₁₀

Quick service, great value, and delicious food.
My friend and I had «The Italiano» and the «Tuna Melt» panini’s. (All panini’s are $ 7.49)
The Italiano features their famous pesto sauce, red peppers and chicken that go REALLY well together. The chicken was a little bit dry, but it was overall a really enjoyable sandwich.
Next, I tried the Tuna Melt, which has lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and A LOT of tuna. I’m talking like two BIG scoops of tuna. GET THIS if you’re really hungry and are a big fan of tuna. You won’t regret it.
The workers are kind, and they bring the food to you! I would definitely come here again for lunch if I wanted something quick to go.

Great fresh sub/​panini/​pita shop! Walked in to a clean shop with lots of fresh cut veggies behind the counter ready for sammiches! Had a panini and it was huge and delish! Hubby got a sub and it was PACKED and he loved it… we will be back!

not Greek as far as I can tell, could be wrong, but really good lamb gyros. loads of salad, generous helping of really tasty meat and fresh tahini. Well worth it for a good takeaway dinner. reasonable prices.

Nice, clean and friendly. Nothing spectacular, but good nonetheless.

Love the food! The service is good too. If you can grab a coupon from the clipper than the prices are great otherwise they are a bit higher but the food is so fresh that it doesn’t bother me too much.

Good stuff. Pita sand wraps are tasty. Especially like the Gyro wrap. Lemon hummus is yummy. Lots of variety here. Worth a trip.

Great food. I liked everything I’ve ever eaten there. I end up going there a lot because there aren’t a lot of other sandwich places on Onondaga Hill. My only issue is with the prices. $ 18 is a lot for two sandwich lunches. Still a favorite, though.

I make it a point to stop here on my lunch break at least once every couple weeks. Great selection, fresh ingredients, and the pitas are huge. Highly recommended for a quick bite.

We live near Pita Pita, I was surprised it was not on Unilocal.So I added it! My family loves this place, the food is fresh and tastes great! We find coupons in circulars which is even better.