Magic Mike’s Bar-B-Q

I loved my brisket sandwich! There was fat in the brisket, as stated (complained) by another reviewer, but it was still delicious. I had the spicy sauce and it was a perfect compliment to the brisket. My hubs had the bowl of q. It was amazing. The potatoes and slaw mixed with the pork was fantastic. Bottom line: I’ll drive out of my way every now and again to have a special treat from Magic Mikes. Mmmmmmmm.

What caught my eye about Magic Mike’s was the pint of brisket for $ 16 which I felt was reasonable considering brisket is expensive. However, once we got home, I was shocked and disappointed with the amount of fat we had to pick out of the meat before even being able to attempt to taste it. Aside from the fat, I will say it did had good flavor. Also, most BBQ vendors I have been to, always slices their brisket, this comes chopped.
The sauces were decent but the vinegar overpowered the rest of the flavors.

Super yummy pulled chicken sandwich! Huge sandwich and awesome taste! I am most definitely a fan!

Magic Mikes has THE BEST Babyback and Beef Short ribs — HANDS DOWN!
They also have fantastic brisket and potatos…
Magic Mikes truly is the best around… and consistently delivers!
We’re going to miss them when The Plains farmers market closes for the season :(

Two words:
Salt Potatoes!!!
Little nuggets of buttery love. To die for!
Magic Mike rocks.

Oh, I’m so sad! I really wanted to love me some Magic Mikes, but I can’t…
I was a starvin Marvin at just after 2 in the afternoon… I probably would have eaten socks at that point. Just our luck — BBQ!
Ran up, grabbed a pulled pork sammich (~$ 7). I squeezed on a couple dabs of each sauce just to try them all. Then we cozied on up to a railroad tie for a moww-​down.
Oy. The first bite was okay — even a bit flavorful, but as I made progress downward I found mushy, wet meat. I’m not sure if it was soaked in something to keep it moist, but it was so wet that the meat itself was actually soggy.
All of the sauces were pretty good — I wouldn’t turn my nose up at them. I particularly like the carolina-​style sauce.
I’m not sure if I’ll give it another shot, but I’m not gonna say don’t go either — he may have just had an off day… they happen. BBQ is hard work!

Went here this afternoon with my husband and a friend. We got chicken sandwiches and pork sandwiches. The chicken was almost inedible to me. It had the texture of pasty, canned chicken and tasted just as pasty and was very watery. When I found a piece that wasn’t mush, it was actually dry. The pork was better it had some flavor and wasn’t mush, but was soggy and actually had pools of liquid at the bottom of the container. I also had a limeade that was very watered down. We won’t be back. Save your $$$ and go somewhere else.

I LOVE Magic Mikes BBQ! First of all, they are at one of the best Farmers Markets ever in the Plains. I somewhat resent saying that, however, because I’m afraid everyone will now rush over to them and my usual go to Sunday lunch will be sold out before I arrive! Magic Mikes is seriously delicious. I’m a bit of a BBQ snob and their beef brisket sandwich with the sweet onion sauce is TO DIE FOR!!! Always friendly, always efficient. They have many types of BBQ and also Arnold Palmer, assorted soft drinks and water. It’s a perfect trip to head out to the Plains, browse the farmers market and get some amazing food! I’ve also heard that it freezes well so stock up as soon as you can so you can enjoy some yummy, smoky goodness in the dead of winter! Seriously, Go to Magic Mikes get a heaping BBQ Sandwich with your choice of sauce anywhere from mild and sweet to melt your pants off hot! I must warn you though, once you try it, you’re going to end up going every single Sunday until they’re done for the season!
Rachel