This should have been named Best pizza ever. I live over an hour away and happen to be stuck in traffic with an appetite. Tired of the conventional fast food I saw a sigh NY Best pizza and thought let me give it a try. From the moment I lay eyes to there pizza I knew it would live up to the name .I have travel multiple states and countries and this is by far the best pizza I’ve ever tasted. Thin crust, zesty sauce and mozzarella cheese. You know the pizza is good when just the chess pizza taste incredible
Fredi M.
Évaluation du lieu : 1 Wesley Chapel, FL
Awful! Waited 40 minutes, asked for refund because we could not wait any longer, still charged me for drinks. No accountability, poor service, highly priced subpar food. Paid $ 40 for a clazone and 3 drinks… Pizza tasked nothing like new York pizza. Save your money and go to hungry Howie or papa johns, much better pizza.
Cj M.
Évaluation du lieu : 3 Wesley Chapel, FL
Pizza is good but, definitely over priced. If they would do specials for regular patrons, anything to show your business is appreciated always helps !
Marco R.
Évaluation du lieu : 1 Wesley Chapel, FL
The pizza was nothing like advertised, definitely did not taste anything like a N.Y. slice. Mind blowing how they have more than a 1 – 2 star rating. Beware.
Carlos A.
Évaluation du lieu : 2 Wesley Chapel, FL
Born and raised in NY. This pizza was Super greasy. Needed 4 paper towels to absorb a large pizza worth of cheese grease. Why you may ask? Because they use cheap cheese. Went straight home after a pickup order, 10 minutes to home, it was like biting into rubber bands. Think it would be a 4 or 5 star review if it had a better cheese blend.
Krista A.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Wesley Chapel, FL
The pizza is good, but a little more expensive than other places. They do not deliver. I like how they open the box to show you the pizza when you pick it up so you never get home to discover that you were given the wrong thing!
Kevin S.
Évaluation du lieu : 3 Tampa, FL
The pizza was pretty decent, but not true New York pizza. For one thing the prices are too expensive. I probably won’t go back.
Nicole B.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Hilliard, OH
Delish! We had a wonderful server(ask for Lakin) … the knots were yummy. Marinara sauce is pretty sweet. which is my preference and thought it was the bomb. All toppings are fresh and sliced thinly.. highly recommend pizza. Will be back again. it was our first time. We went to the one in westley chapel.
Mike K.
Évaluation du lieu : 3 Spring Hill, FL
Pizza was ok, much better then Amy chain but Def not the ny nj pizza I’m used to from living in jersey whole life. At 18 $ a pie I would expect a little more however still better then most down here.
Benjamin Catapia C.
Évaluation du lieu : 2 Dade City, FL
Disappointed… I had been wanting to try this place for a while and finally had a chance to last weekend and was pretty let down. I ordered a 14″ White Formagio Pizza, a 14″ Meat Feast Pizza, dozen garlic knots, calamari and a 2 liter soda for take out. Total was around $ 55. The garlic knots were just to garlic-y, no salt whatsoever, tasted like eating a semi-warm garlic clove. The portion size of the $ 9.99 calamari made me feel a bit ripped off. The pizzas were good, just nothing spectacular. Not what I expected from a place called«Best NY Pizza». Maybe I expected too much but I don’t see myself coming back when there are better tasting pizza places in Wesley Chapel.
Ashley F.
Évaluation du lieu : 3 Mission, San Francisco, CA
The pizza was good, I didn’t care for the garlic knots. A little pricey. I’d probably come back.
Katherine T.
Évaluation du lieu : 2 Tampa, FL
On 2÷04÷2015 my family inquired about a medium tray of meatballs and spaghetti and a small tray of eggplant Parmesan for company in town. The owner told my Mom he could do it but it would cost her $ 200.00. She laughed and told him she would go to Amichi’s down the road. Amichi’s only charged her $ 100.00. Amichi’s was also REAL Italian food. Today, 2÷06÷2015 my boyfriend and I stopped in after dropping our son off at my Mother’s and the waitress walked out with two completely burnt pizzas and asked, «if you don’t want these I can make new slices. Can you eat these?» There is no possible way I would ever have brought out food I wouldn’t eat myself! The food is not the«best» as they claim and nowhere near true NY or Italian! Don’t waste your money, they’re a rip off.
Milania D.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Tampa, FL
We always order the«Best» pizza on a gluten free crust(ask for it extra crispy) and it’s awesome! We’ve also had non GF pizza(White and Sicilian) and loved it. The calamari and meatballs are great starters and the staff is always very friendly and accommodating. Great little family joint!
Stacey M.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Boiling Springs, SC
Really good pizza and cold beer for a weary traveler. My daughter and I each got a 10″ pizza– me white formaggio, her all meat and both were delish! Only reason for 4 stars vs 5 was the garlic knots were not fresh or warm. Would recommend highly!