Sunset Liquors

Great selection of beer, wine and spirits. They have a friendly staff who don’t make you feel like an imposing tourist. And… Walking distance from our rental. Love this place!!!

The customer service is great! Everyone is always so nice and willing to help. Last time we were there, they had wine tasting that we technically missed but they kept it going and told us a ton of info about the wines.
I only gave them 4 stars because the selection can be kind of limited for certain things, but then again it is a very small store.

Best liquor store in Cape May. Fantastic selection of local beers, as well as a huge variety of wines.

Love this place. Colliers needed some competition, and these folks have eclipsed them. Very friendly, very knowledgable about their products, and they stock my favorite port… just for me. I make it a point to visit every day I am on vacation.

This is the urban outfitters of liquor stores. Even the light fixtures are cool. They have a top notch selection of alcohol and beer (cold and warm) and you can mix and match and 4 and 6 pack. Every time I have come here they have had everything I was looking for.
For a liquor store the staff is exceptional. The girl who works there, Katie, is so nice and friendly. If you ever have a question or are looking for a suggestion she is a great resource.

Sunset Liquors is a good place to stop for your adult beverage needs if you are near Cape May Point and want a fair price along with a good selection. They are stocked with a wide variety of wines as well as independent beers. The outside and inside décor is nice and the staff friendly. I would recommend this place over Collier’s everyday of the week.

A nice addition to Cape Island.
Great selection of adult beverages, particularly wine. The best part is the prices are quite reasonable considering the limited choices in regards liquor stores in the area. The service was excellent and knew their stuff.
My only wish is that they could move into the Cape May Historic District so they were in walking distances of the B&Bs and restaurants.

My friends and I decided to swing by this liquor store to re-​stock our supplies midway through our girls’ weekend. First impression: super cute, well-​stocked store with friendly, helpful and knowledgeable employees. A TV showcased a college football game and the store dog roamed the aisles. My friends and I spent a significant amount of time poring over the cold beer selection, before even noticing the wall of singles for mix-​a-​six and mix-​a-​four packs. We were encouraged to leave our larger bottles on the counter as we continued shopping through the store.
If Sunset Liquors was going for a welcoming, cozy vibe, they nailed it. We spent far more time in there than your average booze run which undoubtedly resulted in far more purchases as well. Nicely done, Sunset.

Visited the evening of 10-​7-​2012.
Brand new store that opened in May 2012, this was a great place that I was surprised was open late on a Sunday. Vast selection of items, very clean, nice interior & exterior, a bit on the expensive side.
Wished they stocked locally brewed beer — however, perhaps there is not a beer locally brewed in the Cape May/​South Jersey area.
Loved the fact that it is NOT a chain & is a locally owned business.
Would definitely go back if/​when I visit Cape May again.

I was very pleased to see this store open in Cape May as an alternative to Colliers. The offer a lot of microbrews individually by the bottle so you can get yourself a nice assortment to sample. They also have a good wine selection. Overall the prices were very reasonable and not marked up too much since this is a vacation area.

Sunset Liquors is Collier’s cooler, better dressed brother. This is a really nice, extensive liquor store with good prices. The exterior features a charming painted signboard as well as stools made from bottle caps. The interior is equally nice, with wood floors. The owner says he was going for an old barn feel, and he really nailed it, giving the place a rustic feel.
There are seemingly hundreds of wines (including chilled ones) to choose from, at all price points. They also had dozens of types of beers, including local breweries such as Victory, that you can buy in 6 packs, 12 packs, and even variety packs. They even have a whole wall of beers that you can buy individually or use to make your own 6 pack, which I always like.
Considering the great look of the place, the prices are lower than expected. A 6 pack of Presidente was $ 9. Angry Orchard cider was $ 10 for a 6 pack (I’ve seen it 2 dollars cheaper in supermarkets, but still not too bad). Beers such as budweiser were priced normally ($ 6 – 7 a six pack). You can get wine bottles for around $ 10, with some going up to $ 200.
Before you leave, make sure to check out the tequila selection. As to be expected, the tequila is pretty expensive ($ 50+), but they carry some interesting types (one comes in a painted skull, while another has a glass rose in the center). I probably wouldn’t buy any, but it’s cool to see.