Times Square Pizzeria

Great pizza and pepperoni rolls! Huge portions; my husband’s «medium» sized philly steak calzone might have been enough to serve a family of four. We have eaten in the restaurant a handful of times and always had a good experience, and take-​out is quick and convenient, though their packaging seemed kind of odd and messy – they just put non-​pizza items each on a paper plate inside a paper bag. On our last order I tried the white pizza and I thought it was pretty bland, but that was the only disappointing item I’ve had.
Service is top notch. They have the nicest people working behind the counter – good energy, helpful, accommodating. It’s a warm, welcoming place and a great addition to the neighborhood.

Just tried Times Square Pizza and it is awesome! Had the Chicken Caprese Pizza and it was loaded with chicken and a delish white sauce and basil. Folks are super friendly and quick. Get there soon, we’ll be back.

Excellent pizza with a wonderfully friendly owner! He treated us to a spinach pinwheel app that was fabulous! Owner is a Brooklyn transplant via Naples so he knows how to put a great ‘za on the table. Good people and good food. Located in a shopping center so ambience is typical pizza parlor. Go — and mange

Is difficult not to notice the reviews. I’m not crazy of the area, but is worthy to go with that many stars. The owners from Napoli know what they are doing.
I ordered a eggplant parmigiana with spaghetti. Two thumbs up. The sauce, the eggplant and the bread knots were great. A little surprised of the flavors coming from a pretty new and unknown place.
I hope the quality and flavors don’t change with time. Everything is so simple, no over usage of garlic, no to sweet, a good balance.

That white pizza though! My husband and friend are obsessed with white pizza, when I saw reviews rolling in for Times Square Pizza on how awesome the white pizza was I knew I had to tell them about it. The white pizza is really awesome. White pizza isn’t my go to, but I really enjoyed their version. Highly recommend it! I was also really in the mood for buffalo wings and those were a big disappointment, not sure what happened. They weren’t crispy at all, just soggy with a weird texture. I would stick to the pizza and skip the wings the next time we order from here. The garlic knots are also pretty awesome. Way upgraded from your standard garlic knots; they are coated in delicious bunches of fresh garlic.
It is a bonus that they offer delivery, the last time we got delivery they messed up our salad dressings, but a small price to pay for connivence!

The pizza is real NY style pizza. Slices are huge and delicious. I usually get the white pizza and it is by far the best white pizza I have had since Little Vito’s changed ownership. Pricing is excellent for the amount you get. This place puts Burke St Pizza to shame. Maybe the best kept secret are their buffalo wings. I had the Honey BBQ and they were AMAZING!!! Their service is great and very friendly. I ordered a pick up order for Super Bowl Sunday for 5:30 and it was ready to pick up at 5:28. I must say the place was pretty busy at that time too so for the pizza and wings to be ready was pretty amazing. If you want real NY pizza, then this is the place to go to in the Triad. Location isn’t great but manageable. I can see them changing locations because the space won’t accommodate their success in the future.

Amazing! Delivery was fast, courteous, delicious, and a great price. They will definitely make it onto my future delivery list :)

I’ve eaten here on multiple occasions. My pizza yesterday was so good that I returned today! Their pepperoni rolls are like a garlic knot with pepperoni baked inside. Today I’m having 2 slices and a drink for $ 6.99. This plave can’t be beat. The staff is attentive. I will be back soon.

Outstanding experience! I asked how their lasagna was and they said it was great. No lie, it was awesome. Not the lasagna I expected at all. Great garlic bread on the side. Well done gents, really well done.

A new find. It is the first place in Winston-​Salem that reminds me of a real NY pizzeria. Have tried three different types of pizza — all great. Have not tried other menu items, so no opinion on those…

I came across this place when looking for a good cheesesteak. Well, I found it! I got a cheesesteak special to go with their seasoned fries (which they ask you at the counter if you want them seasoned, so you have the choice) so I said «sure why not!» It was worth it. The seasoning on the fries is perfect. They’re crispy and light even after driving 5 minutes home since I got my order to go. It took them about 6 minutes to make the cheesesteak & fries which is pretty fast. The bread they use is made in house too! The meal was still hot when I opened the box… actually it’s still steaming as I write this to let it cool a bit. The cheesesteak is seasoned well, the veggies (onion, mushroom and bell peppers) are cooked and caramelized to perfection! I also got their house made pink lemonade, which is house made because I found a seed in it, which is better to find than a powder substitute so take that as a good sign. It’s super refreshing!
The staff is super friendly and happy to help. They call your name with your order and hand it to you with a smile. Great food and great service!
Overall, I’m loving this place already and will be sure to come back! I’ll be sure to order other items as well since all the food looks amazing!

Really excited about this place! I was skeptical to come here at first. Being from NJ, I am definitely a pizza snob and I’ve found that most places that say they have NY style pizza only offer disappointing, cheap imitations. This is NOT one of those places! Times Square has legitimate NY style pizza and I can’t wait to go back! The true test for me was to see how their white pizza was. They make theirs with garlic (we ordered it without) and it was exceptional. The garlic knots were also very good. The only downfall of this place is that it’s in a seedy shopping center, but the restaurant itself is really cute. I love having this new option for delicious pizza!

Located in the space long occupied by Mayberry’s, Times Square Pizza is the best thing to come to Parkway Plaza in years and serves the most authentic New York-​style pizza in Winston-​Salem EVER! Great pasta dishes, garlic knots and salads (with homemade dressing) too. The place is hip and affordable and the staff here is awesome. Move over Mario’s and Burke Street — — - Times Square Pizza is a game changer. I cannot give it enough stars!

This place is excellent. We have gone three times, ordering something new each time. We got a New York Style pizza once: the dough was perfect and the crust was nice and chewy.
The garlic knots are excellent, I could smell them the whole drive home, though the marinara was a little thin for my liking.
I’ve also ordered a chopped salad– which was huge. It was definitely enough to share. I also got a slice of deep dish, and the crust was buttery and crunchy.
Each time we’ve gone, there has been a bigger crowd. They don’t deliver, but it is worth calling in your order and stopping by for take out, or dining in. The food is excellent and the staff is super friendly and enthusiastic.
I highly recommend this spot to everyone I know!

It’s been a while since I was impressed by a place upon entering. But when you see the display of food, you truly want a bite of everything. Times Square Pizza is located at the corner of Silas Creek and Peters Creek Parkways near the License Plate Agency.
The prices are very reasonable, with no entrees or combos exceeding $ 9. The pizzas range from $ 2.50 for a large slice of cheese, up to $ 26 for a massive 25″ pie. There are many daily specials on pizzas and sandwiches with a drink all around the $ 6 mark. This place has an authentic NY pizza vibe from the pies on display, to the staff behind the counter on an elevated platform that has them towering a foot or two above you. The staff is very friendly and helpful and they enthusiastically call out your name when your order is ready.
We tried the Buffalo Chicken Stromboli which had a great quantity of chicken and cheese in a mild wing sauce. It was delicious. We also had the Meat Lovers Sicilian style pizza, which had a crispy bottom and fluffy crust. It looks like it will be too heavy but the dough is pretty light. We also had the Caesar Salad Pizza, and this was fantastic. The flavor of the grilled chicken, the crisp romaine and tomatoes, plus a drizzle of Caesar dressing… All on top of a thin crust that was perfectly crispy and held up to all of the toppings.
While I’m a big fan of Mario’s and Burke Street Pizza, I think I’m going to be working my way through the menu at Times Square Pizza for my pizza needs for some time.