Your Pie Downtown

This is my favorite restaurant in Athens. However, the woman who I encounter here every time I come is very rude and sloppy with the pizzas. She always seems to be in a hurry and annoyed at the fact that I am in the restaurant. She once complained to me that the restaurant was too busy and was rude when I asked her how her day was going. I am not one to post complaints or to get people in trouble, but the degree of rudeness that this girl gives me in Yourpie every time I come is ridiculous and does not need to go unrecognized. I suggest avoiding the Yourpie on Broad and going to the one on Alps Road. Her name on the receipt said Devann K.

Took my family in for pizza the night before a UGA game and got great service and great pizza.

Not particularly impressed. Your Pie is to pizza what Subway is to sandwiches. I’ve been there several times; in order to get the pizza to be sufficiently filling (and of slightly better nutritional quality) one must end up spending a larger amount of money than one would expect to be spending. And the texture of the veggies screams «frozen package.» Certainly not terrible, and you can surely do worse, but there’s better pizza to be found.

This place is delicious and the staff is awesome. Came in for a pie and panini today and were blown away by quality and taste. The guy working was super nice.
We will be back many times.

Stopped by a few restaurants in the area to find out that they have modified store hours for the summer so we were happy to find that Your Pie Downtown was opened at 1am on a late Saturday night. The concept of the place is really cool and it’s smart of them in a college town to have meals and combos as low as $ 8 per person. The inside of the restaurant is really spacious and there is outdoor seating.
FOOD:
Both my friend and I opted to build our own personal pizza that has four slices each. There were tons of toppings that you could use to built your pizza. The toppings I remember using was pepperoni, meatball, bacon, spinach, green peppers, onions, and mozzarella. Even though there were three to several pizza sauces (marinara, pesto, EVOO, etc), I opted for the traditional marinara. They place your pizza inside the open oven and you can watch it bake. Within maybe 5 – 10 minutes, your pizza is ready. The also provide sauces like ranch, Parmesan, and red peppers flakes to accompany your pizza which is awesome! I saw the awesome combos that they have (drink with either salad, house-​made gelato, or chips). I opted for the gelato (cookies & cream). Maybe I didn’t choose the right flavor? Both my friend and I enjoyed our pizza and it was good. They have the Coca-​Cola Freestyle machines here which is pretty cool and adds to the entire experience.
SERVICE:
The staff behind the counter were really cool and attentive. I like their fun and positive attitude even at 1am on a Saturday. They were great and we didn’t feel rushed to finish our meal. They even brought out the pizzas to where we were sitting.
Overall, I would now consider dining here the next time I’m in Downtown Athens.

I love this place — pizzas are perfect size for one person and you can make your own if you don’t like any of the ones on their menu! The dough is a little thin for me, but it’s still good. And they have gluten free pizza for those with a wheat allergy! I wish I could find one outside of Athens!

There’s something with this location. At the one in college station when you order a bread bowl for your salad they make it on the spot and it’s warm and delicious. At this location they give you one that had been sitting in their fridge making it disgusting. Who eats bread out of the fridge? The rest (pizzas) is good and cheap.

The pizzas and salads here are excellent and the prices are great. I’ve been here twice so far, and I’ve been real satisfied. My wife put it in her top five pizza list and that list includes pizza restaurants in Atlanta.
The staff are courteous. I see why the previous reviews were great. I would definitely eat here again.

To be honest, this YourPie in Athens was the best one. Loved coming here weekly during Undergrad before/​during/​after classes. This might sound a bit snobbish (I apologize!) but… I rarely ate at other pizza shops b/​c of YourPie. It’s just that good.
I’m starting to review more Athens places b/​c I keep forgetting which ones I loved most! :(My memory fails me sometimes now. Sad day. But anyway…
I ALWAYS had awesome folks make my pizza here. From lunch to dinner time, I never had a problem with them. Even when it was super busy, each of the folks there made sure not to rush me or make me feel lame for taking longer to pick haha.
Times — I believe they’re open really late like.2AM? Not sure exactly, but I do know folks go there when they’re done with Athens’ night activities or if other places close early. Your money won’t go to waste!
Parking — I was a student, so I literally walked to YourPie from campus. It was great! It’s nice to enjoy UGA’s campus + the scene. Hmm. miss my college days. But if you are a car driver/​non student, park behind the old Suno (Last time I checked it was free after 6?). Or just park somewhere DT and walk on over. DT isn’t that big nor is it sketch, so it’s not a big deal if you park further away. I myself can say I’ve done it multiple times during the day and evening. It’s good exercise. :D
Food — I will choose YourPie over almost anything in Athens. All the ingredients are pretty fresh and they have a decent menu to choose from. You can make your own and choose what they usually have. I’m always game for Southern Heat with Tofu! They also make it right in front of you, so you can edit it however you want. It’s awesome.
They also have gelato here, never really tried it. When Suno was near this YourPie, I used to stop by and get their desserts. But I heard Suno left :(Regardless, I have heard from several of my friends their gelato is pretty darn good.
Seating — they have lots of it! Indoor and outdoor. So no worries if you won’t find a seat.
Love Athens shops. Truly awesome. I was SO happy that YourPie came deeper into ATL. Woo! Will be back here though soon!

Great experience! I had the Heritage pizza and a side salad, my wife had a build your own and a side salad. I highly recommend the Heritage, but everything was fresh and tasty. Great service and great food — hard to beat that! We will be back again. This will be a regular.

Food was amazing. Truly enjoyed it. Ingredients were fresh. They made my pizza in a timely manner. I will be returning to this place.

A classic Your Pie. Good tasting pizza, but a rather small amount for how much it costs.