Baby Tommy’s Taste Of New York

Really the best pizza I’ve ever had! I love it! The slices are great on the run and the Stuffed Cheese Burger is incredible! The wings are also some of my favorite in the city, nice and crispy and they can make them spicy as well! Really great and affordable!

My first experience with Unilocal Eats! Score.
In holiday-​trip-​packing-​mode, something delivered for dinner was mandatory. Wings and mozz sticks sounded perfect– and ta-​da!- I remembered that I hadn’t tried Unilocal Eats yet. Again, score.
Love that you can order from your phone — including adding a tip, so all you have to do is run down and grab your food which is great in a packing crunch– and I enjoyed the Baby Tommy’s picks. Good LPWS; basic mozz sticks, probably better eaten immediately after cooking than a little while cooled off.
I do love that there are a good number of places near me that will deliver through Unilocal Eats so I will definitely be using the service, and I imagine Baby Tommy’s again now that I know they deliver!

The food here is really good. I’ve had pizzas, pasta and salads and am always pleased with what I get. I especially recommend the knishes. I used to get them in NYC but in the 30+ years I’ve been here, I haven’t found a reliable source of them until now. Potato knish + spicy mustard. Yum.
The service is also excellent. I dropped a pizza I was taking out earlier today and was pleasantly surprised when they offered to make me another one… for free. I’d made quite a mess but they were calm and understanding. One can’t ask for more than that.

Food arrived by DealDash was the only good part of the meal. I ordered the gyro with strips of beef with lettuce and a cucumber. Really guys? The next disappointment-​the garlic knots were strips rather than actual knots. The least you can do is to imitate something, at least make it almost near right if it doesn’t take anything like it. One word comes to mind-​wannabe.
I’m from NY and the ny taste and style is lacking big time. If there was a rating of zero, I would have given that rather than 1 but not one of the choices… NEVER AGAIN!!!

Delivery was fast. Food was excellent. How can I complain? Definitely try the cannolis and their Philly cheesesteaks!

I went here today and was surprised that it was a bit empty for a Friday night. I ordered the stuffed meat and pepperoni pizza whereafter I concluded that it was an okay experiment. The location is way off my end because I have nearby NYC style pizzerias around my area. However, I just wanted to give it a try because if it is good, it is definitely worth a come back.
Let’s just say I’ll be trying their Philly cheese steak next only because the recommendations are flattering. Not so sure about the pizza though. It was good but not what I expected for a NY style pizza. Bland crust, no crunch (chewy) bleh cheese but I guess the sauce & portion was the best thing about it.
Side Note: Staff was somewhat indifferent to our presence… polite, but just there. It didn’t feel like a nice ambience to dine in so we decided to carry out.

Got delivery through eat24. Everything was great. Exactly what you would get in NY. Authentic casual food.

I ordered a calzone and sprite. Delivery was very quick and I soon found out why. Apparently calzones must be pre made with base topping and additional toppings added when ordered. That is the only way I can see getting a calzone that was totally molded.
When I opened the box I was disappointed to see that it was partially burnt but oh well I thought. I had to break apart the crust with my hands because it was so hard. When I finally tasted it I couldn’t figure out why the taste was so strong and overpowering. Since I couldn’t pick it up with my hands I tried to break a piece off. The cheese was a block, I’d never seen ricotta so solid before. I assumed they had put egg in it for some strange reason.
Then I saw the green. At first I foolishly thought it was maybe parsley but upon further inspection and breaking through the entire crust, I saw that the entire top layer was filled with mold.
I am writing this right after my experience and I am still feeling ill about this.
I called GrubHub and they contacted Baby Tommy’s for my refund. They refunded the calzone only, not including the tax. So I basically paid 6 bucks (tax, delivery, and tip) for a soda to be delivered.
Never again…

Great casual spot for authentic New York pizza. Service and ambiance is kind of the last thing on your mind when you are enjoying pizza that good. More so than the pizza, I would suggest getting a calzone… I haven’t had one quite like it since I lived on the East Coast.

I really had to read through all the reviews on here seeing as the rating was lower than I’d like. There’s a difference between bad food & poor service, and just one’s personal bias or limited palate. I have had nice, prompt/​speedy service, and the food I got was good esp at this price. The Stuffed Cheeseburger Pizza is so good and big, it lasted two meals. Crispy Chicken Salad is just as great — must have. Sausage roll is so good too, as well as the Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich! On the contrary, the garlic knots with cheese are not tender, and the cheese is hard — it’s settled and terribly oily at the bottom of the pan. Ordered without the cheese it’s alright. The fries are also always soggy, albeit free. For the quality and price I wldn’t scoff at the place, I always order for delivery and likely wouldn’t dine-​in.

I’m from New Jersey so normal pizza to me IS New York style pizza. I got the eggplant parm pizza slice and it was exactly what I was expecting: Large and thin slice with crispy egg plant parm covered in cheese.

So against my gut 1^st time ever to go to my neighborhood pizza shop and get a slice. Walk in guy was behind the counter eating some potato chips never once washed his hands… me being me pist didn’t want to cause a scene… so I pulled him to the side and said «when I came in you were eating some chips you didn’t even wash your hands… yeah but I put on a glove ! COME ON MANNN! Never going back there #disspointed smdh

This was my go to place for a quick slice when I didn’t want to deal with crowds or pretentious pizza. The staff members are friendly and the pizza is very good.

But for the fact that I hadn’t eaten all day, I would have walked straight out.
The guy working the counter was outside when I walked up. I opened the door and he walked in behind me, started up conversation, took my order and my cash… the proceeded to grab and prepare my food with his bare, unwashed hands.
I called him out on it, too. He tells me «well by law we are allowed to make pizza with our hands». Maybe so, but you just came from outside and didn’t even wash your hands after touching the door handle and cash! So, he does away with the first piece, puts on gloves and tries again.
Like I said, if my blood sugar wasn’t low as it was, I would have definitely have demanded my money back and tried another place.
On top of that, the pizza was mediocre. The dough lacked flavor and the sauce was bland. The toppings were ok though, and other than the fact that the guy serving me displayed very undesirable practices he was actually very nice.
Get your life, Tommy!

Delicious stuffed pizza. I got the one with lots of meat.
Dessert is bad though, skip that. Brownie was dry, cheesecake was frozen and tasted weird. Cannoli cream was gritty.

I was at a conference nearby and I found this place in the same plaza as Jimmy John’s. Usually when I see a place that advertises NY pizza I get skeptical. I’m from New York so I’ve been able to experience some of the best pizza and wings this country has to offer. Baby Tommy’s older Unilocal reviews put me off a little, but I’m glad I went. They must have stepped up their game because this place sells!
They have a really good selection of pizza including, but not limited to, spinach artichoke, greek-​style spinach and feta, chicken parmesan, and chicken bacon ranch. I’d have to say this place is pretty solid. The slices are large, thin, and crisp in the traditional style of New York City pizza. Sometimes attempting to make a thin and crisp pie can result in something dry, crunchy, and painful on the jaw. Baby Tommy’s did a good job maintaining good consistency in its bread, as well as its ingredients. My coworkers got salad and were real satisfied with how fresh it came out. For the price, this place is pretty excellent.
The service is not like a traditional sit-​down restaurant. You order and pay at the counter, and the pizza is brought to you — very laid back. I did appreciate one of the workers coming up to us and asking us how we were doing. She even collected our plates when we finished, even though most people took care of that on their own. This place isn’t Anticos, but if I’m looking for convenience, and good quality at a fair price, I’d definitely come back.

So I purchased a Groupon coupon to try out this spot and must say that I was very disappointed for this to be a pizza joint. My family and I love pizza so I thought it was a great deal and an adventure for a new pizza spot. We went here for dinner, hoping for some great pizza. When we arrived the restaurant was very isloated, there was no one in there (that should have been a sign… lol).The customer service was HORRIBLE. When we walked through the door we were not greeted at all. When you walk into an establishment — it’s just polite to greet your customers… nah — not here!!! I spoke twice to the cashier still no reply so I proceed to place my order. It appeared that they were more pissed that they had a customer. Not only was the service bad but the tables were dirty. There were used dishes and pizza pans from previous customers — left on the table.
The food was not worth the drive at all nor me spending money on the Groupon deal. I’m a Felini and/​or Rosa’s Pizza girl and with that I expected quality pizza. The pizza was not completely done. We also recieved a salad and I will be honest — that was the best part of the dinner. It had a variety of things in it and it was really good to be a salad. After this experience, I seriously doubt if I will go back here unless it is to purchase that same salad again. I firmly believe in trying something «ONCE» and then decide from there if you don’t like it and I tried it «ONCE» and fairly decided that I don’t like this place.

I’m wondering if the people who gave this place 4 and 5 stars have been anywhere near New York or within a 60 mile radius of a city with a Little Italy, like Boston or Philly. The pizza was bland and just overall gross. No flavor at all. The best part of my meal was the soda.
Maybe I’ll give them another chance and try a gyro or a parm sub or something. But not the pizza again!
The only reason I gave them 2 stars instead of 1 is because the staff was nice and friendly. But nice doesn’t mean good taste unfortunately.

I don’t ever get crazy for pizza, but this is some quality pizza! I really enjoyed the chicken bacon ranch and cheese pizzas here. I never eat the crust on pizzas but the dough here was good. The dough was semi sweet and stood apart from your typical dominos, papa johns, pizza hut variety. The slices are huge and 2 – 3 will fill you up. Make sure you go during normal lunch/​dinner hours so you can score some fresh slice by slice pizza.
They have a wide variety of creative pizzas namely awesomeness which is steak, gravy, mashed potatoes, and onions. Be sure to grab their loyalty card and get a stamp!

I’m actually a fan of this place. It’s not identical to NY pizza, but honestly I haven’t found the perfect NY slice in Atlanta. It’s a little greasy but that’s what I love about it. I also like the tomato sauce on the pizza. They have a pretty goodwhite pizza as well. The whole pizzas are huge and I can definitely eat off of it a few times. They deliver which is a plus in my book. I’m definitely a loyal fan.