Cold Stone Creamery

I hadn’t been to a cold stone is ages, the ones closest to me closed and they are just a bit pricey so it was me treating myself. I got a strawberry blondie, instead of the graham cracker, I got yellow cake. It took me back, soo yummy. Only thing that took points off is when I came in there was three employees and only one was helping someone and the other saw me and basically pretended I wasn’t standing there then one of them finally asked it was being helped… really you saw me come in and that one was helping me. Maybe it was the time I went or the crew that night but when def go again when I was to splurge on ice cream.

This place is always busy, the ice cream is good nothing out of this world. The staff are always on their phones in between helping people and the store is for the most part pretty dirty. The few tables inside are never clean and everything just does not look in order or like it ever gets wiped down. Their cookie dough topping is so good, I always get that with mint chocolate chip. The owner is never available or there when you ask which is annoying. The cakes are super pricey I could never buy one for a party, I’d much rather go to carvel. But sill when you’re out and about in babylon this is a good stop to get ice cream if you can handle the wait.

Yum… what else is there to say. If its nice out you might expect a line, the people that work their do their best to keep it going as fast as possible.
Love this place.

Was supposed to get a Tall Dark & Handsome «Signature» cake — which, as the pictures in the ads and on their website shows — comes with brownie & oreo pieces mixed in with the ice cream layers. Instead, just got basic chocolate & vanilla ice cream.
Ice cream was still decent, and the marshmallow icing was tasty, but Baskin Robbins is a lot closer to me and cheaper and would have been a much better bargain.

I haven’t had Cold Stone ice cream in a looong time and after my experience here I certainly think would be coming back more often now. It’s very conveniently close to the Babylon train station just a block away and even has its own parking lot so you don’t have to fight for street parking. The lot does get filled up pretty quickly though I arrived at Friday on 2pm and was only one spot left.
Ordered a petite chocolate ice cream cake online with many toppings. The cake turned out really great and even better than I expected with kitkat bars actually embedded in the ice cream: D Inside is pretty tiny though its more of a grab and go kind of place. Perfect for the summer seasons where its nice to walk around Babylon Mainstreet with ice cream in hand :)
The staff that helped me was very friendly and they kept the store very clean as well. No complaints. Will definitely be visiting here more often in the future.

Love this place! My little brother had his birthday party here a few years back. The owner showed us how they make ice cream on site in the back kitchen. We also got to prepare our ice cream with toppings ourselves in the front of the store on the stones. We were able to make our own cones too! Such a cool experience for kids of all ages. They used to do parties for adults as well, not sure if they still do either one.
Service is friendly, shop is always clean. There is not much seating inside, but there are benches out front and nearby Argyle Park to walk to and sit when its nice out.

This is now the only Cold Stone in the area… The service is quick, the bathroom is clean, and the ice cream is creamy and delicious! My favorite is the apple pie alla cold stone… You can’t go wrong with this choice if you like apple pie!

Great ice cream. I had the cookie with ice cream and whipped cream on top for $ 6. I enjoyed the atmosphere with my friend. However, I didn’t appreciate one of the girl staff windex a counter after taking my order because my ice cream was on the counter where she was spraying,

Located just south of the LIRR tracks, up the road from the Babylon Bean, and walking distance to Swell Taco. This is on the corner next to an antique store i believe so it may be easy to miss this place. It gets busy with hs kids a lot and some of the kids working behind the counter are a bit too excited to be working there l o l. If you’ve been here before you already know what you like, if you’re new just know that any toppings/mix’s you want will be put into the scoop of ice cream later on.

Best birthday cakes ever!

The best ice cream ever. Cotton candy with cookie dough. Yum

We came here once for some ice cream. It’s typical cold stone. If you’ve never been to a cold stone before the main thrill of the place is that they will prepare your ice cream with your requested fix ins on a marble bar. It was pretty good, tasted like the Lynbrook cold stones which is the one I’ve gone to most of the time when I’m in the mood for cold stone’s and I’m passing by. The peanut butter chocolate ice cream combos are delightfully amazing.

I love this location. The staff here is always friendly and they’re always so generous in the portion sizes.

Friendly folks run the still-​fairly-​new CS, not far from the Babylon LIRR station. New Cold Stones mean new employees led my typically-​new managers and new cold stones, and therefore colder, stonier ice cream, with larger portions to boot. Get there while this novelty persists, and chill on the 2 indoor benches, awkwardly, or take a walk elsewhere with your frozen delight (s). While I passed on the chapstick/​lip gloss and fudge, I did go with some iced newbies (having been through the menu and back again many moons ago) = key lime w/​coconut & blueberry w/​graham cracker, capitalizing on a BOGO coupon expiring the next day (2 for $ 5 like-​its).
Incense and peppermints, the color of thyme
Key lime and coconut, tasty all the time