Cafe 58

Been here a handful of times and both the food and customer service are top notch.
Come here once and you’re already treated like family… their sandwiches, pizza options, & breakfast options are all very good.
Sometimes we order massive 6′ subs for our workers and the big guy behind the counter offers up options galore, the vikings we end up feeding always compliment the food so we keep coming back.
I’m always happy seeing neighborhood joints succeed and with all the development in this Sunset Park neighborhood they’ll soon have even larger crowds at peak hours.

Stopped in to order some food for a group of people and I have to say, what a great decision. There was a bit of a line at around noon, but it moved pretty quickly. I stepped up to the counter and Alex (I assume he was the owner) took my order which consisted of several sandwiches and a couple pizzas. He told me it would take a while so I took a seat. A few minutes later, he motioned for me to come to the counter. He gave me some pasta, pork and a soda on the house and we started to talk about the neighborhood and all the great new changes such as construction of parks and ball fields. Now THAT is how you create a phenomenal customer experience. The sandwiches were tasty, big and very filling. The pizza tasted great as well. I’ll definitely continue to visit Café 58 as this place knows how to make great food and treat their customers well!

Really good omelettes

A wide selection of pizzas… and they toast the slice in the oven for you. I love it because it’s so crunchy. Taste great but a little pricey for a slice.

Café 58 features a nice selection of pizzas. Also, they have stromboli, which are very hard to find in Manhattan (one of the perks of working in Brooklyn, I guess). Pricing is decent on pizza, especially for the neighborhood. I just wish their drink selection wasn’t so limited. They often have more than one soup, which they seem to be heating up while you wait. It’s usually packed at lunchtime; unfortunately they can’t fit a lot of people in the front of the restaurant.
In my opinion, good if you’re looking for pizza, but I’m not usually willing to make the walk down the block to go there.