I love the pizza. The linguini is outta this world. I’ve been coming here since I was a small child(circa 1996) and it’s always been fresh and delicious. Phil has always made me feel welcome. There was a point in 2013 where I ate a slice every single night at 9:30 before I went to work at graveyard shift with my company at WGM. I loved that they always remembered that I loved my slices extra hot(lava slice). Always a fan, forever a customer. They never let me down.
Kimberly K.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 East Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
To die for chicken fettuccine Alfredo or vodka Honestly I get it half/half for the spurge! Thank me later Delivery is quick also
Elise P.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Brooklyn, NY
This is my new go to for delivery. Always fast, cheap and good. The baked ziti only costs $ 7.95 and is fantastic! Also obsessed with their large Sicilian slices. Great value.
Eric M.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
The best! Magnifico! Their sauce reminds me when I was a kid an just came to America and my father would buy us pizza, iv tried pizza all over NYC and Brooklyn, I can’t emphasize enough how it reminds me of traditional late 80’s style pizza when it was all Italian owned and they made fresh sauce from scratch. Haven’t tried it? You really missing out. The competition across the street isn’t close they don’t make it from the heart.
Mike W.
Évaluation du lieu : 3 Brooklyn, NY
It was OK. I ordered Bolognese sauce and I think they just sent Meat Sauce. What I did eat was good, but would have preferred to eat what I ordered. Might give them another chance.
Junior M.
Évaluation du lieu : 1 Glendale, NY
Been a customer in this place for over 15 years. Spent $ 60.00 in food today, they messed my order and all they can offer me is a $ 2.00 credit. YOULOST A GREATCUSTOMER. Rude. Will never see me there again.
Xavier C.
Évaluation du lieu : 2 Sheepshead Bay, NY
Its rough because I want to like this place because the food is good. However their delivery service is very poor. I ordered 2 slices 2 chicken parm sandwiches and 2 pinwheels at 4:10pm It was 5pm I did not receive my order yet I called for an ETA. The gentleman told me the dlievery guy already left and should there any minute. He did not come until 5:30pm not only did the delivery take an hour and half I also had a completely cold pizza and the sandwiches were warm at the most. Its a shame that their great tasting food has to be ruined by something as simple as this.
Yajaida M.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Brooklyn, NY
So the kids want pizza on this cold night. So Tonys is my go to pizzeria. They are fast, pizza is great. It’s kind of a small place but with true Italians. Love coming here. Pizzas are so great.
Gina R.
Évaluation du lieu : 1 Williamsburg, NY
Just ordered took hour delivery for 4block from my home, was not fresh pie because was cold and bottom of pie was clean no grease, fresh pie should have grease on box. I was sent a reheated pie for $ 21.00. Call any whoever answer insulted me sending me to hell for complaining wth
FakeFoodBabyNY C.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Brooklyn, NY
#You have your choice between Tony’s or Carmine’s across the street. I think if you want a plain cheese slice or #grandma slice go to Tony’s. If you want toppings, go across the street. But both are #iconic for Grahamers.
Josh B.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Brooklyn, NY
Great pizza. Traditional. Do yourself a favor and pick it up.
Karina A.
Évaluation du lieu : 1 Flushing, NY
This place used to be great a few years ago. This time the man behind the counter was extremely rude and the eggplant rolatini was completely soured and inedible. When we explained this, he started yellingn. Bad customer service and quality all around. Moving back to Brooklyn now I will not be returning.
DjBig B.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 The Strip, Las Vegas, NV
Best traditional slice in the neighborhood by far. The Sicilians actually have a different flavor rather that other pizza joints who use the same sauce on every pie. The meatballs are to die for! Creamy, fresh & the melt in your mouth(pause). The Lasagna I bursting with flavor as well. This is the only place I go to get a regular slice in the neighborhood. The best part about it is that they deliver making this place BAWSE!
Masta S.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Brooklyn, NY
Love this place! Been a loyal customer for almost a decade now. I know, I know, carmines is across the street right? But what if I told you this pizzeria actually has itialians making the pizza? Which is a rarity now a days when supposed *authentic itialian pizzerias* have Mexicans making the pizza… where’s the authenticity in that?(Didn’t mean it to be racist, just my opinion) Portion sizes are quite big and everything is tastefull, I do love the caesar chicken slices though! Yummm Overall, if your looking for a itialian pizzeria this is your place to go, look no further! –MS–
Brian L.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Brooklyn, NY
The more understated of two very good slice joints on the same block, I kinda prefer Tony’s these days. Fresh, tasty and quick — it’s everything you should ask of a neighborhood pizza place. The counter guys are great, too — friendly, eager, and they clearly have a good rapport with regulars. My favorite slice is the olive pie. Piled high with green and black olives, it’s so savory and so hearty. Talking with neighborhood people, it seems as though not everyone knows Tony’s does specialty slices. But they do, and they’re so flavorful.
Kay. K.
Évaluation du lieu : 1 Brooklyn, NY
So I had a turkey burger to my surprise it look like the type of ready to eat burger that u just pop in the microwave. But he had the nerve to tell me they make their stuffs fresh ground up… ummm no mf. I waste a whole $ 7 on a burger I thought was going to be mouth watering so yeah I wont be back… cause its not that Im piss about the $ 7, im mada the fact that he was promoting this made fresh crap made me come in here for no reason!
Shay M.
Évaluation du lieu : 1 Brooklyn, NY
Just ordered a large pie and after waiting an eternity. I finally recieve my delivery and open the box and looks like my pizza went through war not to mention the guy who took my order hung up on me mid sentence when I called back to add something to my order NEVERAGAIN!!! Called back spoke to manager whom was rude as well WASTEOFMONEY !
Justin L.
Évaluation du lieu : 3 Brooklyn, NY
A Rather Average Slice joint that will Substitute while Carmine renovates.
Jack K.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 New York, NY
It’s so hard to find a good ol’ pizzeria in this neighborhood. Nowadays, everyone tries to be different by introducing all kinds of weird toppings on a simple slice of pizza. Not here. If that’s what you like, you can find that across the street. What gives Tony’s Pizza a solid 4 stars? Their mozzarella with basil pizza and cheesy pepperoni pinwheel. Try them as they come right out of the oven and you’ll see that they are absolutely dynamite!
Baramee C.
Évaluation du lieu : 3 Minneapolis, MN
Why do I go here… because it’s right down the street and convenient. Sometimes you just need an emergency New York slice. This is where I go. Crunchy crust on their plain pie. They have other stuff there too, but I haven’t really tried anything on the menu.