Insomnia Cookies

They have the best cookies and ice cream! Open super late and have very fast delivery. All of the workers in the store are friendly and helpful!

I came home from work on girls night and the girls actually had on a movie I wanted to watch. So I sat down to watch it and these bitches would not stop talking the whole time. As I sat there squinting at the tv, somehow hoping the would allow me to hear it better, a cookie delivery showed up at my door. For the next ten minutes these ladies were completely silent while they devoured your cookies. Amazing! If only your cookies were a bit cheaper then I would have had more than ten minutes of peace and quite that day.

I’ve ordered from Insomnia Cookies a few times now, with varying results. It seems to be hit and miss. I’ve never been in the actual shop, but I have gotten deliveries to my dorm room.
One of the things that I do really like about Insomnia Cookies is that it is one of the few places in town that delivers ice cream, and I think it’s the only place that delivers whole pints. I’ve tried both the mint chocolate chip flavor and the strawberry cheesecake flavor, and both were good. I preferred the cheesecake. I was pleasantly surprised that the ice cream was still completely frozen and not at all melted when it got to my door.
The first time I ordered, I got the TBMOC, which is 24 cookies for 28 $ dollars. I got a combination of chocolate chunk, double chocolate chunk, peanut butter chip, M&M, and double chocolate mint. I also got three milks, and a pint of ice cream. The milks are $ 3 each, and the ice cream is $ 7 for a pint. They were warm and chewy and absolutely amazing, the perfect thing I needed to sate my sweet tooth. The delivery girl was super nice and friendly, and it was a good experience.
However, the second time, not so much. I got the same general order, with the flavors switched around, plus a premium Smores cookie for $ 2.95. The boy who delivered my order was annoyed by the fact that he had to call me to get my order. I live in a dorm with security, I’m sorry it was an inconvenience to you that I wasn’t going to wait outside for half an hour? It was rude. The cookies were also underbaked. They weren’t just soft, but fell apart like they hadn’t been baked enough. The smores cookie had a weird, salty taste that wasn’t worth it.
I do think they’re overpriced. I understand that I’m paying to have it delivered, but seriously? $ 7 dollars for a pint of ice cream and $ 3 for a single serving of milk? I’d order a lot more if the prices weren’t so steep. I’d order from them again in the future, but I’ll definitely be paying more attention to service and quality to decide if I should keep them in my regular take-​out rotation or to call it a aday.

Stopped in over the weekend. I almost didn’t go because the hours listed on Unilocal said they were only open until 3pm. They are actually open until 3am. The cookies are average but at a premium price. A single cookie: $ 1.45, a dozen cookies: $ 15!
The place is super small, but had 4 college age employees sitting around texting and waiting for a customer to show up. I know they offer delivery and that means you need to have people available to go out in the community but come on, do something while your at work besides sitting and playing on your phone.
The different type of cookies are displayed in a basket at the cash register. When you make your choice, they pull your fresh cookie from a tray that is kept below the front counter. I picked a chocolate chunk and a peanut butter cookie, but when I opened my package of cookies at home, I noticed I got two chocolate chunk cookies instead of one of each type. The girl helping me obviously wasn’t paying attention to my order.
Overall, pretty poor service and an average cookie. In the future, I’ll stick with the local bakeries that have a much better product.