Little Anthony’s Pizza

For anyone that truly has an appreciation for good pizza, this isn’t it. It taste like overpriced Pizza Hut pizza. The food lacks any real flavor and the portions don’t fit the price. There are other places to get better food and much better pizza, G’s by Kohls is probably the best in the area.

I’ve lived here for over 15 years and this place is terrible. I tried with my husband and kids years ago and it was bad so then I never went back until yesterday. I went with 2 girlfriends. I ordered stuffed shells and my friend ordered tour of Italy. Both plates came out burning hot loaded with cheese. We both had to scrape all the cheese off to see our food. We had to allow it to cool for long time as we both burnt our mouths. The food has no taste!
I will never ever return and neither will my friend.

Lil Anthony’s is a love it or hate it type of place, I happen to love it ! Wife likes thin crust and Lil Anthony’s «Joe Baron «style is the best ! Cracker thin crust good sauce, delicious cheese. We got meatball and hot cherry peppers Which were nice and spicy.
My soda cup was constantly refilled without asking which is a huge thumbs up for me.

I love sit down pizza places and this is no exception! The décor is fun too. Delicious garlic knots and wings! Pizza was good too… not my absolute most favorite pizza but was very good. We will definitely return!

I just don’t understand how this place only has 3 stars?!? I’ve been here quite a few times and I absolutely love their pizza. Never had a bad Pie.
Service is always outstanding! Thank you!

Best ever! The pie is excellent and great crust. The service is always the best. They will take reservations. Kid friendly but a lot of screaming kids when we were there but the pizza made up for it. Highly recommended this place.

We eat here often because we live in Minneola. Although I’m not a pizza expert, I like theirs. The real treat here is the combo salad, which has a great mix of meats, cheese, tomatoes, and more. It is always freshly made to order and it is priced right.

Ordered pizza and wings… yum, yum, yum!
Pizza was not greasy, sauce is delish. Great prices.
The wings were not soggy, which is hard to get for take out.
Gentleman that took my order was polite and very helpful. Answered all my questions without seeming rushed…
Def my new pizza place while I’m in town!

This use to be our place; our favorite spot in Clermont to order pizza. We would always get the same thing and loved it. We were such regulars that when I would walk in one of the wattresses there would greet me by name. That kind of service is rare these days. I don’t know what happened to this place, but everything went bad. The pizza isn’t good anymore, the service is terrible. Our favorite waitress no longer works there. The past few times that we have ordered the thick crust cheese pizza, the crust has been thin. When we complain, the owner Kelly tells us that’s what we ordered. Then she’ll regrettably issue us a redo because our order was wrong and somehow we are made to feel like it’s our fault. We started getting pizza where the dough was fluffed up to look like it was thick, but once you try to pick up a slice the pizza fell apart. I took pictures the last time in case Kelly wanted to claim that we were making it up. So so sad to lose the charming little restaurant experience that we once had. The Little Anthonys that we knew and loved is gone.

To be fair, I haven’t gotten to their pizza yet. It could be worth more stars, if so, I’ll update. I have tried several others options though, and the lasagna and garlic knots seem to be a safe and tasty option. Highly recommend the to-​go option, as in restaurant service has been consistently inconsistent.

Well, I have made numerous attempts to like this place based on friends who have talked me into going here with them. The last time we were here, late on a Sunday afternoon, it took us over half an hour to get our food (nothing special-​sandwiches and salads) even though I saw three people in the kitchen. Not only that, we were the only customers in there at the time! My sandwich was mostly very thick bread with very thin toppings in between that came with a gross oil that you’re supposed to put on it. After tasting the oil, I opted not to ruin the sandwich further with it. In the past, I’ve tried pizza, pasta, you name it. The only thing I’ve tasted that is actually good are the garlic knots, but that one item will not bring me back. That will be the last time I set foot in that place as far as I’m concerned.

The atmosphere is kitschy with lots of references to NY lure. Sopranos and mob films are the theme. Decent pizzeria style menu. The Joe Barron pie is pretty good but not thin, thin crust as the menu describes. The traditional slices were not good at all. The veal parmesan sub was fair overall. The balsamic dressing on the house salad perfect. Service was great but it took a long time to get the food. Worth a shot to try if you’re looking for casual but not the best pizza by a long shot in Clermont area.

Only been here once, but it felt like Brooklyn! This is the kind of place that you want to order a REAL pizza from! The décor is real old school Little Italy/​Bay Ridge pizza shop, so it feels like you’re in a movie almost… like Goodfellas or something! Not to mention the pizza is really good! The staff seemed real cool, though not too personable… again, real Brooklyn feel to it… lol.

The best pizza in town for sure. Especially for a sit down pizza. The service is so friendly and quick too. There might be a wait on a Friday night– that’s a good thing– it means it is good pizza. The dough was so fresh tasting and reminds me of when I was younger working at a pizzeria — you can smell fresh dough when you walk in. The cheese pizza is perfection. I always ask for it crispy with light sauce and it comes out just the way I like it. There is another pizza they make with bacon and ricotta and fresh tomatoes– oh my! It is so good. I’ve tried to recreate the flavors when we visit other places and there is just no recreating lil’anthonys. I have not had anything other than pizza there– but that is all I want when I walk in the door and smell the dough :)
I have taken friends and family there and they all love it.

Terrible service. For the second time in a row. Won’t be back. Food isn’t that great.

Went here with a
certificate. They would not accept it!!? I didn’t even know they could do that! Wouldn’t even give a small discount! The manager refused to even speak to us and told our poor waitress to tell us it wasnt them that put up the certificate!!! We ordered for our kids and friends and spent $ 52 for 3, 1 topping pizzas! NEVER ever again! Fraudulent place that should be investigated! Nobody charges $ 52 for 3 pizzas! I have never been so angry at a restaurant before!

Went last Saturday night on a recommendation from a friend. The pizza was disappointing, the crust is not NY style. it’s actually a prefabbed crust, the edge of ours actually fell off and you could tell it was a pre made/​frozen crust. I’m a cheese kindda girl so that’s usually all I get, as I have said before, if you can make a good cheese pie, all the others will be fine… not so much here.
We also ordered the greek salad… it was NOT a greek salad but it was good :) The salad dressing is a balsamic vinaigrette which really was good but not greek, only thing that was «greek» was the feta sprinkled over it.
Kindda pricy for what you get. Service was good.
Don’t plan on eatin’ there again

This is probably the best pizza in central Florida, the atmosphere in the store is so NY. The pizza is very very good. When I go there I try and get the Lasanga it’s awesome

This place is nice if you just want pizza I would suggest this over pizza hut or papa johns if you get what I mean lol one thing I can say is the customer service is great! They are very pleasant! Also the restaurant theme is so neat! It is New York them and based of baseball which I’m a huge fan! Also great place to go with family and there garlic knots are really good! All and all it’s a cute little place okay pizza and great service!

Awesome New York style pizza! One of the best local pizza restaurants I’ve tried. The cheese is delicious and the sauce is perfect. It’s perfectly cooked, but my one complaint is that the crust could have a little more flavor. It was a bit «cardboard-​y». lol
We also ordered the chef’s salad which is HUGE, but so delicious. It’s crisp, fresh and delightful! My Aunt and Uncle love the balsamic vinaigrette which i believe is the house dressing. Totally give this place a try, the dining room is small but cute and decorated with tons of new york memorabilia of gangsters and etc…