Blue Moon Pizza

Great food and top notch service
Katie n was awesome very attentive
Very clean and high class

I came in by recommendation and my server was a gentleman named Billy. He recommended a Blue Moontini and the Classic pizza. I couldn’t have been happier with the friendly service and the amazing food and drinks!!! I’ll definitely be back!

Sometimes a girl just wants a gluten free pizza without making a mess in her kitchen. Tried it out on a whim yesterday when I dropped by to pick up a GF white pizza. When you call for a to-​go order, Youll be happy to find that they have a curbside pick up area in the back where they’ll come out to deliver your order. Didn’t intend on eating the entire 10″ pie by myself, but it happened. And obviously I wasn’t too bothered by it, as I went back today. Today I ordered the gf classic, a pizza loaded with veggies, Italian sausage, and asked to hold off on the pepperoni. It made my feel a tad less guilty. My niece had the kid tenders and fries (delicious), and was so excited to hear her meal included a scoop of ice cream. I will return when I’m ready for my next cheat meal pizza. Which might be sooner than I’m proud to admit.

Came here for a lunch date with Miss Jesse H. Jesse H where are you?! Come back to the Unilocal World, we miss you:-)
We originally wanted to go to Mad Fresh Urban Bistro to ask for ketchup because we heard the owner refuses the right to serve it on his burgers or at all for that matter. He gets annoyed, it’s even written on the menu. :-D. Troublemakers? Maybe:-) Unfortunately, we had to leave because they did not have high chairs for kids FYI .
What to do now? Blue Moon it is. She had been telling me about this BLT they serve that she absolutely loved, so we decided to go, so I could get a taste.
She was right. It was a nice sandwich with cayenne-​candied bacon strips, shredded lettuce, tomatoes, onions, house cheese, and chipolte mayo. They also use the pizza crust as bread which is a nice change from the original regular toasted bread. Tasty, Tasty.
We also ordered the Stuffed Portobello Mushrooms– with Goat Cheese, Sundried Tomatoes, and fresh Basil leaves sprinkled on top. Loved those.
My only complaint is about the drink. I ordered a Mojito, it was very weak and pricey for what it was. Thumbs down on that.
Next time, I’ll stick with a beer.
This is a nice casual place for lunch with a friend to catch up on small talk. I liked the vibe. Would I come again? Yes!

Amazing pizza. Service is pretty good. Been a couple times. I love the pizza. Surprisingly not that packed. Would definitely recommend giving it a try if you haven’t.

We’ve been regulars here for almost a year! The pizza and garlic rolls are fantastic. Very good atmosphere & above average service! We’ve recommended to family and friends and they love it to!

Would have liked the pizza more if it was a homemade crust. The crust seemed like a commercially bought crust with cheese and toppings thrown on and pizza baked. The pizza was OK, but I have had better at many other places. I rate Dominos higher… I had a pizza with pepperoni, mushroom and sausage. Interesting I ordered the classic and had them remove items since it was cheaper than the make your own.
The Chicken wings tasted like they were bought at Costco or Sams Warehouse. They weren’t bad but again weren’t the quality I would expect in a restaurant.
They have a good beer, wine and mixed drink menu. The service was very good but that was because the place was deserted between 6 and 7PM.

Great place. Nice atmosphere. Food was delicious and service was good! Love the GF options!

Our office came here for a business lunch and we are glad we did!
The food is great and the portions are more than enough! We definitely will be returning soon. The only thing we didn’t like was that our lunches came out extremely staggered so we were waiting a bit. However, our waitress was nice and attentive so we went with it.

My favorite pizza in Fort Myers. In fact, I love it so much, I put a review on my own business website if you’d like to check that out. Thin, crispy, crunchy crust … and I’m all about that crust!!!

I can say that I’ve had 2 delivery ’ from
Blue Moon. Not a fan, pricey and nothing exceptional. ….

This was the best pizza I have had in a very long time! Everything was fresh and made from scratch. Appetizers and salad were great too. Our server, Xavier, was awesome. The noise level was high; there was a «Friday Night Out Group «that was loud. But, hey, it’s a pizza place.

Excellent gluten free dining. The cheese pizza my daughter ordered was one of the best GF crusts we’ve ever had (and we live in California where there are tons of options). It was crispy and had great flavor. The GF cheesy bread with dipping sauce was even better than the pizza!
They prepare all the GF food at a separate station, so very little risk of cross-​contamination for celiac concerns.
Service was fast, friendly, and helpful. We didn’t try the regular pizza, but I can only imagine it is really good.

Love the LaQuintas because they love my dog. They are clean rooms. Haven’t had a bad room yet.

Delicious very good freshly prepared pizza and best of all they delivered to our office off Metro! Thanks guys well done! oh and their blue cheese wedge… yum!

This place has top notch service and excellent cocktails. The extremely kind and professional manager comes by to check each table during the course of the meal. Outdoor seating is available, but my favorite place to sit is the bar! Sangria is a must.

I’ve had Blue Moon Pizza service twice since they’ve opened. Once was a pizza delivery and the second was a «to go» of appetizers only.
The pizza, a medium (i think. I was not the one who had ordered it) half cheese, half classic (it was absolutely loaded with sausage, pepperoni, onions, mushrooms and peppers) was interesting. The slices were cut in big single serve portions and easily foldable for those who enjoy «that way» of eating. The cheese side was a little drippy on the grease /​oil, while the classic side felt like every bite had too much topping. I had seen what the entire pie looked like, and the half with the meats and veg truly had a full topping pizza on just that side.
Besides the «negative» complaints, was it cooked? Was it good? Yes and yes. The meats were cooked through so they were crisp, the cheese was gooey (maybe part of the reason it was drippy with oil) and I’ll always say «sure!» to a slice. Always willing to try another restaurant’s specialties.
While the second time I had Blue Moon Pizza, I actually went into the location and did a take away order. It was the Cheese Fries (why? because I wanted to bring home a random app to go with a meal). With the fries covered in bacon, my car smelled like cured meat for 2 days. The website describes the dish as «Perfectly seasoned golden brown fries topped with melted cheddar and mozzarella cheese, and our homemade cayenne-​candied bacon. Served with ranch dressing.» Yes, the fries were golden brown and the cheese was plentiful. The downside was the ketchup packets and ranch dressing were on the bottom of the container, so a hot mess of fries, cheese and bacon were sitting on them, not only when it was delivered to my hands, but while I drove home. I didn’t partake in any dipping of the potatoes.
Outside of that, how was it? For me, way too cheesy and heavy. I may not be used to all that cheese, fried oil or bacon (which there was enough that a baby pig must have helped in the making of this), I felt like I should to go to the gym instead of having company over. Would I get this again? Probably not.
All in all: If I make it in for another round of pizza, I shall definitely try some of the more interesting combinations — any of the chicken (Thai, Jerk, Buffalo, Santa Fe) or the Margherita (my stand by no matter where I go). For the prices, although competitive, a personal pie is slightly out of my range for the poultry ones (I’ve seen similar ingredient pizzas for a couple dollars less).
We shall see where time and hunger takes us, and I’m definitely willing to try again!

After a talk with the manager a correction was made and Blue Moon Pizza is back in my good graces and still making the best BLT’s in town.

Blue Moon Pizza is a very warm and friendly neighbourhood pizza and sandwich shop. We actually ended up getting some chicken flatwiches, and they were delicious. We promised ourselves a go at their pizza the next time we roll into Fort Myers, so there will be an update on that. Good food and good service there.

I have been here twice since my first visit and I wonder how other places stay in business compared to the quality food and the stellar service you receive here!
I don’t normally order blt’s when I am out to eat because of the simplicity of the sandwich (I can whip one up in about 10 min. at home). But after hearing Craig D. talk about it for months, I had to eventually try it.
BLT Flatwich — ingredients as follows– Cayenne-​candied bacon, lettuce, tomato, house cheese blend, topped with chipotle mayo. OMG is what I thought after my 1^st bite. That Cayenne-​candied bacon is pure heaven!
I love chorizo, and they actually have a specialty pizza (the Luna) that has it as the main ingredient. I stuffed myself with almost the whole thing so I wouldn’t have to share.
The management here is actually doing their job b/​c every employee goes above and beyond. I had Emily today and wanted to ask her if I could have some of whatever she was drinking in the back, hehe. What a sweetheart! Every time I leave I can’t wait to come back.