Old Chicago

Great service, great beer and trivia on Thursdays. Overall a great place to start your weekends off.

Walked here from the hotel up the street. I should have kept walking. Instead i took a seat in the bar to grab a quick meal.
They do have a decent selection of beer. Heavy on the IPAs, but a few good ales and stouts to balance out the variety.
The service was a bummer. While the server was polite and friendly, but I was left alone with an empty glass twice during my dinner (while the place was not even busy).
Two things I tried were just awful. The boneless chicken «wings» were «dry-​rubbed». Apparently to Old Chicago «dry-​rubbed» means to sprinkle some seasoning unevenly across the food. To add to the ridiculous presentation of this plate the chicken was overcooked and dry.
The other «food» item I tried as a fried mac & cheese appetizer. Not sure how you can possibly screw up something like mac & cheese (with «bacon») breaded and fried and served with «beer cheese sauce». But somehow this was rich and bland at the same time. There was no visible bacon in the wedges, but the beer cheese went well with my «dry-​rubbed» boneless wings.
I couldn’t finish either plate so I polished off my beer, and waited TEN MINUTES for my server to reappear so I could pay and leave. During this time «Cowboy» by Kid Rock came on the sound system. It seems this song is a favorite of the two beer-​tenders because they proceeded to turn it to 11, much to the annoyance of everyone under 23 years of age and under .08 BAC in teh entire restaurant.
Anyhow, if you’re in Greeley give Del Taco serious consideration. At least they try.

Mediocre service at best. Waitress was indifferent to poor service. Food was okay — at least the pizza rolls and pretzel bites. Came in at 3:45 and did not want to honor happy hour until exactly on the dime, 4 PM. Ended up charging us extra for full orders that I did not intend on ordering. Met with resistance when I complained. Poor service and place to eat.

So I’ve been waiting for a week for my food now, starting to slip in and out of consciousness due to the lack of calories, I’m pretty sure my friend got diabetes from a giant cookie, the fact that he eats it in front of me while I starve taunts my very soul. Final verdict: it was OK.

Greasy mediocre food. Always packed and busy probably due to the beer tours. But I’m not a huge fan. Liquor drinks are expensive. Although I did have a good monitor there once.

Veggie sandwich was delicious. Calzone was slightly uncooked. I went 2 different times. Food was fast. Staff is friendly.

After making reservation we we’re told we had to be out bye a certain time. Not cool! Won’t ever go there again.

What a horrific dump! The place smelled of old grease and mildew! The food was horrible and the wait was long!

Always great beer! Love the food. Service was fantastic as always. Unfortunately, this time the kitchen messed up the Alfredo sauce. But my boyfriend loved every bit of his buffalo chicken sandwich. The tvs in the bar had the game on and the beer is cold

Service always prompt and courteous. .the Italian Natchos are to die for… crispy and full of cheese pepperoni. .the sauce is delish. Hint. Have the banana peppers served on the side. Hone had one of the single pizzas… just right. We always love coming here. Honey loves the 16oz PBRs..

i have never had worse service or been insulted so much. the bartender was grabbing the girls boobs next to me, being completely rude making foul jokes and when i got up to leave he told me to go back to where i came from… well i was just here on vacation so believe me i am going back home, BUT i will never visit this establishment at ANY location. PS the bar was filthy and practically empty but still not kept up… this place deserves no stars but it requires me to put at least one… but believe me, that is a negative one at best…

The best pizzas in town, hands down. Vast selection of craft brews. I just wish they would bring back their Lasagna… Great sports bar atmosphere with plenty of Tvs for the game…

I came here for dinner with my bf and my sister on our visit from CA. I ordered the crispy chicken salad and it was a huge delicious salad! I recommend to order the half size… our waitress was quick to refill our drinks and very attentive. My bf ordered a calzone which was very good but also huge! He only ate half… all in all very good food, great staff, and cool atmosphere!

Poor service. Manager was rude. Employees off the clock sat in corner table in the bar, loud and obnoxious. Manager sat with that table most of the evening. Music was loud, sounded more like a nightclub.

We visited tonight, waited 15 min for a table which is normal and actually less than what we expected, we were seated and then waited 24 min before anyone came to our table to even take drink orders. Our waitress was new, she said it was her third day, bless her heart she was flustered, she was very kind and apologetic about our long wait tonight, we were here an hour and a half before we got any food. The waitress even though she was new, we could tell she was truly trying and my heart went out to her. My complaint is to the two managers who were standing around the whole time, doing nothing, including not offering to help out our waitress, she was clearly struggling, why aren’t they stepping up to lend a hand? Hanging out at the hostess stand is more important??? Get with the program and help out the staff, that’s your job, you get paid way more than our waitress, you could surely help her out! Shame on you BOTH, yeah with two of you here working the same shift, you’d think one of you could stop standing around and help out!

Food is good, happy hour prices are great, but waitstaff is not. While I have had good service in the past, last night’s was piss poor (hence the review). This seems to be the case about 9 times out of 10. I really like Old Chicago and would be bummed to stop going, but I just can’t eat at a restaurant where I get the impression that my presence is a burden to my waiter/​waitress.

You just can’t get good pizza/​Italian food in Texas. Old Chicago’s is one place I miss when I am not in Colorado. I love the Italian nachos and the calzones are really good too. Great place for happy hour; a great place to meet up with friends and throw a few beers/​shots back. just a good place to be to spend a few hours.

Love the Italian nachos!
Old Chicago is still — and always has been — a great place to hang out in a casual environment, drink good beer, and have yummy food, served quickly, hot and tasty, by friendly staff. I’ve eaten at their restaurants all over the Colorado Front Range, and never left disappointed.
I wish I could join their beer tour, but I think by the time I’d earn a mug, I’d have lost my liver.

Good Spaghetti and Meatballs! As simple and it sounds, its amazing.

I ate here a few times while I was working in Greeley and the service, food, and beer is all top-​notch. Burgers and steak are big and juicy. Their beer selection is probably the best in town.
I definitely wasn’t expecting a Old Chicago in Greeley, but it’s my most favorite restaurant to eat at while I’m here.
Go here, you won’t be disappointed!