Panther Pub & Eatery

They seem to have put some work in to make this place better. Had the buffalo chicken sandwich again and it is night and day from when this place first opened. Sandwich was warm and tasty, wing sauce didn’t taste like it came from a generic bottle. Good selection of drinks. I think beer could be a a dollar cheaper. For places in the area I’d say this is a good bet.

We didn’t stay for dinner. The TV’s were too many and too loud. The menu didn’t appear to be anything special for us to sit through that.

Panther is easy and comfortable like a good pair of jeans.
We frequent the Panther because it’s easy to get to, the people are nice, the food is pretty good, there’s a few good beers, and we can take the tot.
I thought I had more to say than that, but I actually don’t. We probably appear here once a month or so. We like it. It’s our Cheers.

Clean, cold, but a darn good turkey bacon club. I was having a hard time deciding where to go and what to try for dinner. I stopped in here for a beer and selected the bacon turkey club sandwich and I thought it was delicious. I will review this place again once I have tried something else, but if you want a recommendation on where to get a great turkey bacon club. It’s here.

Stopped in and had a meal. Got a burger and the chips. Burger was pretty good, not the best but a well done pub burger. The homemade chips were really nice because they had a good crunch and fresh taste. Service was excellent, very friendly staff. Beer selection is above average and the actual restaurant is very clean. Will will defiantly visit again.
If I had to nitpick, I would say the place looks kind of cookie cutter on the inside, but still a nice place.

Panther Pub & Eatery is nothing special. It’s a solid 2−½ stars but I’ll round up to 3 for good measure. I visited with my husband and son and my husband had a beer (bottled) and I had a decent Pinot Grigio. They had a $ 5 app special so we tried the mozzarella sticks. They were tasty, but I think they purchase Saz’s mozzarella sticks and cook them on site. My son had chicken strips and fries — standard kids meal fare. My husband and I both had the Panther Burger. I was disappointed with the burger. It wasn’t very flavorful and, considering it bears the name of the restaurant, not very unique. The fries were good. My husband said the chips were dry.
Our server was friendly. He was young and seemed a bit inexperienced, but he did a good job. We sat on the patio, which is really nice since it’s tucked away off Greendale’s main drag. I will say, however, that I was surprised to see two different tables where customers had their dogs. I also was disappointed that smoking is permitted on the patio. I know it’s outside, but I’m not a big fan of dog hair and smoke near my food. Now I can say that I’ve tried the Panther and I probably won’t go back.

Kids food was great and very reasonably priced. The Jacked Up Mac n Cheese was alright, good size for the price. Staff was very friendly.

My wife and I are here for the first time and we will be returning, burgers are tastey, wife got ‘jacked up’ Mac and cheese with grilled chicken and it was excellent, music selection was very good, rather expansive beer selection, service is rather good, would recommend giving it a try!

Great beer selection. The soups are always good and the fries crisp. The sandwiches are flavorful and fresh. I wish there was a bit more variety besides just sandwiches and salads some more main entrée type dishes would be nice, but the food they do have is good. The service is always friendly especially as my cousin and I are regulars, it is nice to see the same bartenders and chat it up.

I traveled 51 minutes from a coffee shop in Delafield on the recommendation from the «Friday Fish Fry Guide» on Facebook. The picture was 3 pieces of battered fish and potato pancakes. The latter is enough to coerce me into the trek across counties. The Pather Pub is inviting, full of happy Greendale residents, proud of their local establishment. The menu is not overwhelming while still offering a nice selection of appetizers, sandwiches, salads, and burgers. They even provide a variety of microbrews on tap and bottled, as well as a not-​too-​shabby wine list for the suburbanite.
It did take a while to get a drink menu though. The bartender was busy chatting with two women sitting a few stools down from me. When he did manage to lay down a cocktail napkin in front of me, he slid it there without breaking eye contact with the ladies. It was a little insulting. I am a lady, and it felt like I wasn’t worthy enough to have the one conversation end and have an introduction to the person serving ME. I ordered a glass of Von Stiehl Riesling while I perused the menu and decided what to bring home for dinner. The bar was a good spot to view the Masters and Santa Anita horse racing.
When I arrived home with my four styrofoam containers, I took a good look at my to-​go order. I ordered the pretzel «bites,» mozz sticks, and two fish fries (one with french fries and one with potato pancakes). The «bites» were actually standard pretzels. You receive 3 with the order. Unfortunately, they were likely frozen and heated. I would love to see either pretzels purchased from a local shop that makes them or see ones made in-​house. The cheese sauce was delicious, and a homemade pretzel would’ve made it the perfect starter. The mozzarella sticks were good, but they were probably also frozen at one time. I don’t mind «frozen» if the item was made in bulk at the restaurant and they freeze for future use. I was disappointed by the fish fry. Even after an attempt to reheat in the oven on 350 degrees, the fish and the potato pancake were limp. There was a lot of batter on the fish that could not crisp up. Even the french fries had a hard time getting crispy.
I am not going to write off the Panther Pub after some apparent boo-​boos. The take-​out could be different than the dine-​in. I would like to dine at the restaurant and see if there is a difference. I am sending some friends from the neighborhood there and I will get their feedback as well. I really like the restaurant, and I want to give it another go.

Solid Place. I think the burgers are great. I recommend anything on the pretzel bun. Frys are good and the portions are to be expected. Nice beer selection.
The High School Pictures are fun to look at on the wall, but there really is not much of «vibe» other than all the photo wall art.
Overall, I am happy that this place is in Greendale as it is a great compliment to the other restaurants on Broad Street.

Living a few blocks away, I really want to like this place. I REALLY want to. I have been there a number of times, the food isn’t consistent, and that is my biggest issue. They have a terrific Friday Fish Fry when you happen to get a good one. We would go every Friday, had 3 great fish frys in a row… then the 4^th was a oily pile of fish. It was so oily that my potato pancakes were swimming. Tried again a few weeks later and got another great fish fry… went back the next week to be handed another oily disaster…
They have some great stuff, the Panther Pub Chips, homemade chips with bacon and cheese, are always awesome. Great to snack on when having a couple drinks with friends.

Ordered a Cajun Burger, and my wife ordered Pico De Gallo Burger, both were amazing, and the kids ordered chicken tenders, I tried those, very good too!
Food came in quick too!

The first couple of times I was here, I was underwhelmed. But the last two times I went, it was really really good. I don’t know if they got a new cook or what, but I would recommend it to anyone looking for good bar good. It’s definitely not fancy or formal or anything, definitely more of a bar atmosphere, but it’s a great option for us because it’s so close. The patio is great when the weather is nice and we have brought our daughter in her stroller a few times and it had been a problem at all. We will definitely be back. Lots of TVs, too!

This place was a mixed bag. My girlfriend’s salad was great with chunks of mozzarella cheese, green apple slices, walnuts and cranberries with a tangy raspberry vinagrette. I had a Philly Cheesesteak that was OK. The meat was a bit undercooked and it could have used a dash of salt to bring out the flavor. The service was good and our server extraordinarily friendly. There were plenty of TV’s to enjoy the football games that were going on this day. I will give the place another shot or two

I have tried this restaurant 3 times. I want to like it. I want to go there for lunch on a regular basis as I work in the area — but I can’t do it. The food is overpriced and isn’t good. The menu looks good, but the food just isn’t up to the standards I would expect at the prices they are charging. The Chicken has hard, overcooked, and tasteless. One time I had a Panini sandwich special — it lacked flavor and I was disappointed. Then my last visit I had the chick parm sandwich. Terrible. I wish Ricardo’s was open for lunch. Their chicken parm is really good — and large enough for two meals. The Panther Pub sandwich is worse than one I could get at Burger King and is 3 times the cost. It doesn’t seem as if they use fresh ingredients in their kitchen, that is the only thing I can think of for all of their food to be so bad.
I gave it two stars because it has potential. They need better servers, better food, etc… but the atmosphere is good, they have a great patio out back, and I really want them to succeed, from a location perspective.

The first time we went here, we were disappointed. But every time we’ve gone since, the food has been good, the service has been great, and they’ve got a good selection of beer.
In addition, they’re accommodating for kids, particularly on the weekends during lunch. I would choose them over the other options in downtown greendale when dining out with the family for lunch.
And the pickle chips are ridiculously good. You’ve got to try them!

Great pub food! This is our fifth time and have never been disappointed. Look at the bacon and blue cheese burger with sweet potato fries.

Was happy to see this place was open on the 4^th of July. Friday night in Wisconsin and I wanted a fish fry. Usual fish fry place was closed for the holiday and I’d heard good things about the beer battered fish here. The fish was good, potato pancakes with applesauce was amazing. Beer menu is great too. Happy to support local businesses in Greendale :-)

DISAPPOINTING — one word can sum it up.
Stopped in on a Friday night and the place was dead. Never a good sign.
Very cute inside and right in downtown Greendale. Nice sports bar feel to it and apparently like Cheers, everyone there knows everyone. I guess that is pretty cool too. That’s about it for the «like» factor
The menu had a good selection of sandwiches and apps to choose from so I was pretty excited… until the food came.
The food was bad, just bad. We ordered pretzel bites with cheese and they were the kind you can get at the dollar store in a box and microwave and they charged $ 7 for them. Horrible.
My chicken sandwich was on a stale bun that was chewy and I had to pull it off. My sweet potatoe fries that I had to pay extra for were inedible because they were not cooked all the way. Hard and greasy, gross. Food was pretty pricey for something I can buy and heat up myself.
Service was sloooooow, not sure why since it was dead inside. When half of our food was untouched, the waiter didn’t’ seem surprised to even ask if everything was ok with it. To me, it wasn’t worth even addressing because I got the impression no one would care anyways.
For that reason, we will NOT be returning. There are other places to choose from in Greendale, keep walking by this one.