Mary Carroll’s

This is an okay bar. My lady friend and I went on a Tuesday. The drinks are moderately priced. The bartender is friendly. The music was a bit loud and the bar is dimly lit. There were several beer options, including some that departed from the most bare beer lists, including some seasonal, local, and specialty beers. I had a double IPA from Brooklyn Brewery and my lady friend had a mixed drink with Tequila. Although she asked for a drink light on the sour mix, it came out a bit too sweet for her. Would recommend.

Tall bouncer with the glasses and shaved head has a thing against the Hispanic community… Went to three different bars before with no problem and this guy made «an exemption»

Nice Irish gin mill. Attentive staff where buy backs still exist. A dozen beers on tap and a nice outdoor patio is great seasonally. A genuine public house. I’ll definitely be back in the future. Oh yeah one of the oddest men’s room setups I’ve ever seen.

I’m giving this bar a two because the bartender was being shady when we asked for the check on Sunday 08÷30÷15. When my friends and I first arrived at the bar everything was going well. We had a few drinks ordered a pizza from Little Vincent’s and sat outside and enjoyed our pie. We were at the bar for about two hours and had a couple or rounds. When we first got to the bar we gave the bartender a card, and he asked if we wanted on the same check and we said yeah. When we asked for the bill the bartender told us he bought two of the first three drinks, and we graciously thanked him. When we got the bill it was about $ 30 bucks a person for three people who were being charged for two drinks each. We thought that was odd. Furthermore we never got an itemized receipt. My friends and I all work in the restaurant industry so we’re familiar with the micros terminal they use. We were each charged the same amount on 3 different transactions opened at different times. We were all skeptical of why that happened but instead of making a scene we decided to just sign the bill and leave. Be careful of what you’re getting charged for when you go to that bar.

Beer selection is shoddy and the Guinness tasted weird last time I went. It smells heavily of cigarettes. There’s a patio to smoke outside, but it makes its way into the bar.

Cool dive bar in Huntington that has a nice outdoor smoking/​sitting area. Came here to meet up with some friends and was not disappointed. Really small place but has a few TVs and high bar table and chairs. The taps are actually pretty good, especially for a dive bar. A little pricey for craft beer though, seemed like a dollar or two more than I am used to paying for the same beer somewhere else. I would easily come back here for a few pints.

Definitely the late night spot. Stays open until 4 every night, no matter what. Just installed a ton of new tap lines, although the system is a little overwhelming when sitting at the bar. Younger crowd especially during the summer, but the bartenders are cool guys, the jukebox is cheap on weeknights

Yesterday, on 1÷17÷15, I attempted to go to Mary Carroll’s. Thanks to the bouncer, Mary Carroll’s instead lost $ 500 of my money to Huntington Tavern down the street (which was much more pleasant)
I say attempted because when I gave my perfectly real and legal ID to the bouncer at the door, he scanned it and, because it was real, it passed the scanner just fine. He then bent it nearly in half (damaging the mag strip), threatened to confiscate and snap it, and refused to take another look at it when I very politely asked him to take another look.
I then offered to get a police officer to look at it. At which point he told me I «wasn’t fucking getting in even if you brought 3 police officers to look at the ID».
So, I did get a police officer. Who informed me that what he had done was illegal, but because the bouncer hadn’t actually snapped the ID he couldn’t really do much about it.
To the management/​owner of Mary Carroll’s: if he had snapped my ID, my lawyer would have been in contact with you IMMEDIATELY, as I had a flight the next morning. I would have been unable to get on it, due to your incompetent employee.
I suggest you do something about your employee and his unbelievably poor behavior and incompetence.
Especially considering the fact that he let in a girl without an ID immediately after me. I’ll be happy to report that to the police.

Great little cozy place in Huntington. Was there this past Sunday afternoon. Football was on each TV. Bar was pretty empty. Megan the bartender was very personable and a good bartender. No food, but that’s okay. Plenty of other places nearby for dinner. Would definitely go back again. Men’s room needs some attention.

This local dive is a fan favorite among the young party goers that flock into the area only to enjoy the late night party scene. But don’t judge a bar by its cover kids. The London dive look on the outside only somewhat represents what goes on inside. The great beer selection, whether on tap or out of the cooler, is matched only by the state –of-​art jukebox playing anything your fingers can punch up. Please don’t be taken back from the absence of a kitchen. The staff at Mary Carrols is more than willing in allowing outside food into their wonderful establishment. What’s better than sitting, either outside or at a cozy booth, enjoying some great local food, excellent beer and a friendly late night atmosphere. Cheers!

Always the first stop my friends and I make when we spend a night in Huntington. It’s become more and more saturated with high school and college kids which makes it that kind of scene. The bartenders are cool and knowledgeable, the set up is versatile, the seating is great. Im very upset they got rid of the fooseball and bubble hockey.

After coming here a couple of times recently I have to say this place really is pretty decent and it’s a decent place to stop by when you’re in Huntington.
Only thing is that while the urinals have dividers, the toilet for some reason is totally in the open — keep that in mind if you really need to go.
Aside from that this place is decent with good prices.

When I travel to Huntington with friends, we bar hop and start off with Mary Carroll’s. It’s your typical dive bar with a musky smell. Drinks are a cheap, but also watered down.

Used to love Mary Carroll’s, but now I refuse to go there unless its during the week. The crowd on weekends is full of high schoolers with fake IDs and very little clothing, not my scene at all.
Worth checking out during the week, as their drinks aren’t too badly priced and the staff is very friendly.

Love this bar, I’ve been coming to this place since it opened and it has never failed to deliver on a good time. The bartenders are all great dudes (and girls) and are extremely quick. No matter how crowded the venue has gotten, I’ve never had to wait too long for a drink, in fact most of the time the only thing slowing the service down is the customers who don’t have their money ready when they order a drink.
The décor is warm and has a very homely feel to it… minus the smell of spilled beer and smoke. This is Huntington’s pub and I always feel a bit like I’m home when I’m here. I’ve gotten completely smashed at this place so many times, and plan to have many times more in the future.

I went with a group of 5 or so ladies on a Friday night, around 10 or so. It wasn’t as crowded as I expected but I prefer that. We were hopping, so we only had one drink but staff was great and their service was quick, and the crowd was young but friendly. Nice pub with an old timey feel and nice dark wood. Would go there again.

I had fun. There was nothing special about the place. I had fun with the big group I was in. Drinks are okay, room is crowded/​smokey. The bathroom line took forever. It was the most coventional definition of a bar. plain and simple.

best bar in Huntington.
very clean good service.

Awesome bartenders, they take pride in their job. Very clean! The staff there clean their bar, goes to show their dedication!

A bars a bar, and that’s what you got here. Buts it’s a damn good bar. The inside is always clean and the staff is always friendly. You can bring your own food because they don’t have any… The prices are more than reasonable, the weekend can get crazy but with plenty of girls. My favorite part is there fighting policy… One punch gets you banned for life, NO exceptions!!! Thus the lack of greasy blowbacks and steriods. Ask for Jake he’s the man.