Scotty’s Brewhouse

We had an excellent experience at this location!
I’m particularly found of the downtown location, so I never thought to look to see if there were other locations near me. Turns out, there is! This is a fairly new location, opened December of 14′ I believe.
Same menu as downtown with all your favs like The Shewman (Peanut butter on your burger? Yes. It’s awesome.) I was a little crestfallen to see that the beer selection was, in my opinion, a little limited in brew house standards, but we each found a beer to love and pair with our burgers.
The restaurant itself was very clean. A decent sized parking lot is also a huge plus. It’s a little tucked away behind some other businesses, so unless you knew it was there you might not see it.
I’m grateful to have this gem on the Southside and look forward to meeting many a friends here!

I have been to scottys twice before (once in brownsburg and once in Carmel) and I am starting to realize these are a hit or miss. Took my family from out of town after raving about their food and atmosphere. We were seated almost immediately and the waitress got our drink order. About 5 minutes later we got our drinks and ordered appetizers. Got our order taken about ten minutes after that and then nothing… for a whole hour… I had to go to the bar to get my drink switched and then again for a refill. After a hour passed with no appetizers they finally brought out our food. No appetizers. The manager apologized, brought them out about 5 minutes after we told him and gave them to us with no charge (which was nice) but by that time we were almost done with our meal and no longer even wanted the appetizers. The food was even a bit disappointing as the cheeseburger patty was thin and dry, worse then Mc Donald’s patty honestly. It was a big disappointment and I was a bit embarrassed that I had talked it up to my family just to get this type of service.
One cool thing they have there is an area where kids can go and play but all the toys are old, broken, dirty and missing pieces. So if anyone is looking to donate gently used toys I suggest heading to scottys lol

Poor service at this location due to a poorly managed service staff. Manager was too chummy with the female servers and a lot of socializing going on. No hostess to be found so seated ourselves at a booth in the bar then told we couldn’t sit there. 2off the clock servers were in the booth next to us. Food was ok when we finally received it nearly an hour later, except missing condiments. Refill drinks requested were forgotten. No pen brought with the check so had to get one from the bar. Come on Scotty’s you can do better than this.

Again, a huge disappointment by wait staff making what would be an awesome meal, not so great.
I have eaten here many times, as I really do like many of the menu items! But man alive, I think I’ve only had one or maybe two times that the waiter was good and prompt. But almost without fail we are left waiting and waiting to see a server and get refills or anything additional to our meal.
We had the Tidals Dip (pic attached) for an appetizer and as always it was really good! Also tried the Black and Blue salad, and it was amazing (see pic)
But our service was lack luster, and the cherry on top was my friend ordered a Pepsi with cherry flavor. You know, grenadine. Well they charged him double saying if you ad the flavoring, it’s no longer free refills…
It was beyond silly and a pointless effort to up the tab.
I think I’m relegating this establishment to take out only from now on! I want the food but you can keep the staff.

Today’s server was Myra. Fantastic service– and left with a to-​go water. It’s a small gesture, but I love that she was that conscientious.
Very clean. Fresh greens– awesome mixed salad as I typically order. Delicious appetizer split at the table– I love the simplicity of tater tots.

Horrible service on more than one occasion. Over a half hour for curbside and I’m only vehicle.

I’m saying this as a person who has gone to other Scotty’s restaurants and had a good experience.
First, the waiters by the take out order door ignored my bf, then rudely told him to go to the front entrance to get his to-​go order. The waitress there was slow and the food wasn’t ready for the time we ordered it.
The food was probably about a ³⁄₅. The order was wrong, and the condiments were skimpy on both burgers. Food was just lukewarm. Honestly, I probably would go back if this was the only problem but rude waitstaff is a dealbreaker.

Loved this place
Buffalo Mac and cheese wow
Best Mac and cheese I have had
Others had peanut butter bacon burger and fried pickles
Great food even if you don’t drink

Visited Scottys for dinner, was ok. Staff was friendly. Service was a little slow… food was average. It’s a lot like TGIFridays. Would I go back? Sure

Stopped here on a Saturday night this Spring and couldn’t have been more pleased. We had about 15 of us, about half adults and half kids. We were sat next to the ‘kids corner’ which was great for our 3 or 4 younger ones. The teens sat by themselves and were taken care of by the waitstaff. Food options on the menu was huge! I ended up with the hot chicken on a salad entrée which worked out super with the several ales I tried. Great selection of microbrews! We stayed an extra longtime because of a downpour outside, but never felt rushed to leave. Everyone had a good time, and this place is definitely on our list of places to go back to when in the area again.

Bad job tonight guys. Cold fries, cold pulled pork sandwich, beer was same temperature as most of the food. Saw the waitress once and the place isn’t even full.

I was really disappointed eating here. I have been to Scotty’s on the Northside and the one downtown and had excellent food at those locations. Here not so much. We tried the fish tacos and the buffalo chicken wrap. The tacos lacked flavor and the buffalo wrap was over spiced drowning in sauce. The volume of food was very large but we all left with a meh. feeling which was surprising. The service was very friendly and prompt so absolutely no complaints there.

Got the special $ 2 street tacos. Dry, dry, dry chicken. Do not recommend! Must use leftover for this dish. Service was great. Hats off to Kellie!

Solid place for a beer and a bite to eat. Scotty’s is always very convenient for me since it’s directly next door to the hotel I always stay in when in Indy.
I try to watch my waistline, on occasion, and enjoy the Veggy burger and a cup of chicken dumpling soup… all for under 450 calories.
BOTTOM LINE: A perfect stop for a business traveler looking for a good beer and burger… and make sure to ask bartender Mike about his 17 year old Jack Russell. That’s 119 in dog years!

Excellent, unique burgers. Great beers.
I travel for work and was staying near the restaurant. I was looking for a place to eat Sunday night after my flight and stumbled upon this place.
I tried the twisted pretzel burger and it was really good. The meat seemed to be fresh or the patties hand-​formed. I’m not sure but it was good.
Came back a few days later and had the bacon jalapeño and peanut butter burger. Was very unique and the peanut butter kinda tames the heat of the jalapeño.
Also, I suggest the double ipa. That’s my favorite out of what they had.

I really love this place. The bar tenders are such a delight. Even though I’ve only been here 7 times Emily calls me by name and has since my first visit. Nice touch. The service is prompt and friendly. I only sit at the bar so I can’t speak about the table service. I see an awful lot of servers so I can’t imagine that the service is anything but good. The microbrews that I have tried are absolutely delicious. My favorite is the pale ale. The black bean pattie sandwich is absolutely scrumptious. I love it with the buffalo or the sriracha. Actually everything I have ordered has been quite good and now when I’m in Indy I stay at one of the nearby hotels just so I can come here. I’m so glad to have stumbled upon this local gem.

It’s Scotty’s, man! Maybe those who eat away from the bar area experience a problem, but I never have. Inside the bar area, I’ve been treated better than well. The beer is always cold. Samples are always at the ready. I get what I ordered quickly. It’s always as expected. The deals offered for beer are great. (Though, I would go so far as to say that if you’re not a beer person, Scotty’s probably isn’t (never was) a place for you.) Scotty’s doesn’t get a 5 simply because it does have too much of the «chain» feel. If it were as unique as 3 Wise Men in it’s setup and ambiance, it would have 5 all the way.
Keep rocking Scotty’s South! Hopefully, I can hang on to my title as Duke.

I had been wanting to try Scottys for a while and finally got the chance last Friday for lunch. I got the appetizer platter with fried pickles, pretzel breadsticks, buffalo chicken strips and loaded waffle fries. (Nothing else on the menu really looked appetizing) the pickles were greasy and were clearly frozen just 30 minutes ago. The breadsticks were over cooked and the waffle fries had waaaaay too much cheese. The service was great at the bar but then again I was one of maybe seven people in the entire place. I would not recommend Scottys.

Giving Scotty’s 3 stars for the following reasons:
Pro’s — The food is pretty good! And pretty good value options to make it really reasonably priced.
Had buffalo chicken sandwich and it was great, except the waitress or cooks messed up my request to have it done w mild and have an extra side of hot and mild sauce
So here are the cons!:
–Waitress, adorable — but not good… Just not experienced
— wait time was unacceptable to get someone to even acknowledge us
–Table next to us had a horrible experience .all their food got brought out at the same time (apps, salads, entrée and dessert) — and the ‘serving manager– who was all of 10yrs old (no experience!) was an idiot in handling the situation!
Finally what recouped this — was the main manager that had been there 3 days!
They have a lot of work to do w this place… I like the one downtown Indy and Bloomington– but this location needs help

Great food spice stack sandwich was great not too much heat, chicken sandwich was good also. Good beer selection.