Romeo’s New York Pizza

I come here a lot after school, pizza is good but pricey. The wings are ok but the pizza is really good!!!

The pizza when made by the owner is a Five Star Pizza however on the weekend the service is awful because no offense but the college kids are running the show and they could care less about customer service, they could care less whether your pizza is done properly, they could care less if they run you over as you’re coming in the door and they’re trying to get out the door to go to their smoke break. Needless to say on that Saturday we walked in, was run over by one of the workers as I walked in the door so we promptly decided to leave and we have not been back since. It’s really sad because the pizza is really good but without good customer service it’s really not worth the trip.

Great option if you’re looking for a quick bite to eat especially if you have to catch a movie next door at the Regal Cinemas.
They have decent seating room it’s not too big so I could see it being packed on a busy day. Most times I’ve been the wait was non existent. The restaurant’s décor does give you an NY pizzeria vibe.
It’s called Romeo’s Pizza but it serves more than that like wings and subs. The pizzas come in New York sytle flat crust. You can order a few different toppings like Meat Lovers and Marguerita to name a few.
The staff is pretty good from the few times I been here. You order at the counter but they bring it out to you to your table. You can grab different condiments from the counter and they have some at your table too
The flavor of the pizza is average to be honest. It’s good but it’s probably not the best I ever had.
Overall, Romeo’s is a good option all around for a quick and easy meal that keep your stomach and your wallet satisfied.
My Recommendations:
–Meat Lovers pizza

I came here on a Friday night, and there were a few other tables in there. There was a movie crowd that came in a little later, it is close to the theater after all. I agree that there are many young employees in there, but they are professional, quick, and helpful. They do keep the place pretty clean as well. We got the margarita pizza, and it was really really good. It is a pretty large pizza, and the crust is really thin, which is what I love. The very center was a little soggier than the rest of it, but all in all, it was a pretty good pizza.

Just about the best pizza by the slice I’ve had in Atlanta. What makes the place a must go for me are the chicken wings. From mild, for the kids, to spicy for me, they are awesome.
Service doesn’t always come with a smile, but it’s not fine dining.

Poor service. Had to wait 45 minutes for a calzone. Asked for a refund, she said but it’s ready now…

Went here on a whim after work with a hungry belly and desire for beer. Boyfriend and I ordered a large pizza with extra cheese and two Fat Tires and it all came up I under $ 30. The pizza was positively scrumptious, not extra thick which pleases me because I like thin crust. Extra cheese and very reminiscent of those New York style pizzas. Ahhhhhh.
Cashier was very sweet and I definitely do recommend. Will visit again.

Pizza is delicious and also the buffalo wings. Pizza crust is crispy, cheese doesn’t taste cheap, and the tomato sauce is just right. Wings are juicy and sauce (i usually get mild) has a savory tang. Plenty of seating depending on the time you go because common sense will tell you busy nights will be — — - busy.

Man, I really loved this place but recently they’ve been missing the mark. Just grabbed a Togo slice and they literally put it on a paper plate and paper bag. When I got home there was pizza grease everywhere and on my salad that came with the lunch special. Not only that but because the slice wasn’t inside a box, the cheese stuck to the paper bag, and left me with just greasy bread. –_​_​_​_​_​–

Really delicious pizza. Everything you want from a NY style pizza place. Nice and casual atmosphere. Reasonable prices. The slice was so hot, it burned my tongue. The cheese and sauce were seasoned perfectly. I will be back :)

.A young group of employees seem to be running the show keeping the place clean then getting food ordered and out in a timely fashion. Easy and casual, place your order at the counter, grab a seat and it will be brought to you,
Always plenty of meat on the slices and the calzones are huge. Drinks offerings are soda or beer
Sign up to receive the specials on pizza’s, salads and calzone you will receive them via text on your phone about once a week or so and have a 1 – 5 day time limit for use.

Everything a NY style pizza place should be. Good sauce, great crust, fresh ingredients, clean establishment.

We called and asked for a delivery and they gave an excuse as to why they couldn’t deliver. I was confused and my husband said he didn’t get a clear answer. So we decided we would pick it up. When we got home to eat it, it was gross. Crust was hard and chewy and toppings were not great. Everything kept sliding off the pizza. It was very difficult to eat. Will never try again.

I went in for lunch today and was greeted by a very unhappy girl at the counter. I ordered the two slice lunch special. It took 15 minutes to warm up two slices. The pizza was like cardboard, burnt and the cheese was nonexistent. I could not eat the pizza. I told the girl that the pizza was burnt and she shrugged her shoulders. I will never go back!

The crust (crisp edge, super thin, and good flavor) and sauce (not too spicy and not too sweet) were the saving grace of the pizza, so that is why this is a three-​star review and not two. But what has me teetering so close to the edge is the level of grease on our cheese pizza which, incidentally, didn’t have all that much cheese on it. So really, where was all that grease coming from? It wasn’t to oil-​spill level like what I’ve had from Mama’s Pizza down the street (gross) but it was enough to make me sigh in disappointment when I opened the takeout box. Maybe greasy pizza is the true definition of New York-​style. If that’s the case, I guess I can’t say I like New York-​style. Anyway, just know what you’re getting into and head elsewhere if super greasy pizza isn’t your thing.

No wait staff, have to stand in line to make an order. The toppings simply fall off the pizza if you are not holding it 100% horizontal.

Picked up a to go large meat lovers pizza on the way home. All I can say is the whole family really enjoyed it.
The location on Unilocal map is incorrect too. My GPS took me to Gino’s NY Pizza a few blocks away, which I’ll have to try as well.

Romeos before or after a movie at Regal is just a must!
I am obsessed with their veggie pizza. Who would’ve thought that that combination of flavors/​veggies would be to die for? Mushrooms, Eggplant, Caramelized Onions, Sun Dried Tomatoes, Goat Cheese = YUMMY
Their signature salad is great. Really full of «stuff» (Mixed Greens, Tomatoes, Artichokes, Sun Dried Tomatoes, Goat Cheese and Assorted Fruit) Definitely recommend giving it a try to share with the whole table.
They offer gluten free pizzas which is great for a paleo cheat meal, but part of me says if you’re going to cheat might as well go big right?
Great staff and fast service! Love this place.

I’ve eaten here twice now in the past couple of weeks. The pizza is great, as are the salads and garlic cheese bread. The store lacks in ambiance what it makes up for in flavor, but they deliver for free… only before 3:00pm? Bizarre.
To be sure, I’ll be back as often as I get the urge for good NY pizza.

Really diggin’ on Romeo’s, for sure. Was in the area hanging with friends when, after catching a movie next door, we found ourselves at the knee-​weakening stage of guy hunger. And in eyeshot, there it was, the savior from our starvation. We walked — no *ran — inside and despite it being half-​an-​hour before closing, Sharon R. treated us like members of the family and «talked us into» ;) getting a large pie split three ways, satisfying each of our varied tastes in one fell 16″ swoop. The customer service was killer, the pizza was killer (I’m no NY’er, but I know good pizza and that was it), and the location and chill atmosphere was killer (we sat right outside the door and just took in the night) — could not have asked for a better choice for a late Saturday-​night grub spot.
Definitely looking forward to heading back there next time I’m in the area. I’d recommend you do the same. ;)