Downtown Pizza

Paid $ 10 for chicken souvlaki with fries which is listed on the menu as $ 8.50. It didn’t even have tzatziki sauce! Wait was long and the people seemed to have a bit of an attitude.

horrible, despicable, appalling, atrocious, horrendous, foul, disgusting, inhumane… and any other terrible word you can think of to describe their customer service, would fit perfectly!
Mustafa, the owner, is rude af! I ordered the pepperoni pizza and jalapeño poppers, but received a pepperoni pizza with jalapeño peppers. I wasn’t angry about the mixup at all. I called back and spoke to the owner in a very kind manner, stating, «I ordered a pepperoni pizza with the jalapeño poppers.» He immediately told me that I didn’t order the poppers. I told him one more time that I ordered the poppers and he replied, «F$&* You!!!» Then he hung up the phone.
I called back and asked to speak to the owner. Mustafa the A**Hole replied, «I am the owner, after cussing me out again.» I will never ever order anything from this place again and I’m trying to go through every avenue to spread the word on this despicable spec of a business.

Great pizza. Imagine if Pizza House (my fav pizza spot in New Haven) delivered, lowered their prices, and didn’t take so long. Voila! Downtown Pizza! The location is a lil seedy when it gets dark, but isn’t that like most of New Haven? So, delivery and pick up are your best options. Dining in… not so much. I haven’t tried any of the sandwiches or meals, but everything on the menu seems reasonably priced.

I got some food delivered from here last night to my motel (here for one night only) and my family ordered dinner but I got spaghetti with meatballs, garlic bread, Caesar salad, and also a hamburger.
Hamburger: It was pretty good, I liked it. It wasn’t out of this world, but I think it got the job done (I was really hungry). I ordered a hamburger for $ 3.50 but received the $ 4 cheeseburger instead.
Spaghetti with meatballs meal that included bread and choice of salad: You get a whole lot of food for $ 8.95, I think. It was a large pan of spaghetti, and while the noodles tasted a little bit undercooked, the meatballs and sauce tasted pretty good. It was so much food after having the hamburger I could only finish less than half of the spaghetti. I was nearly full, so I only ate one of the two slices of garlic bread, which was pretty good too. I ordered a Caesar salad but the only thing that was Caesar about this salad was the small container of mediocre Caesar dressing that came with it. The salad was what I assume is their «garden salad»: a mix of iceberg lettuce (no romaine), tomatoes and cucumbers (which both do not go in Caesar salads). I wish the salad would have been better.
A minor quibble was how everything was wrapped: as noisily as possible to unwrap haha. In our motel room, two of the five of us were asleep and we kept being afraid of waking them up because all of the noise that the unwrapping foil and styrofoam and paper and plastic bags. That was kind of annoying. However, some good things were that they drove out to our motel in the snow, and they gave us a free 2-​liter bottle of Brisk lemon-​flavored tea, which I liked. My other family members ordered dessert and gyros, but I don’t know how they were.
Overall, this was a decent restaurant, and will get the job done if you are staying there for a night or two. The prices are good for the amount of food you get, so much so that we chose this place over another we almost ordered from. I would recommend it to travelers.

Ordered delivery for lunch at my work for myself and coworker.
I ordered a Chicken Cutlet with L, T & Mayo with a slice of chocolate cake and my coworker ordered a Chef’s Salad. I really enjoyed my cutlet & the cake was delicious, though my coworker wasn’t wow’d by the Chef’s Salad.
The delivery man was very nice, online ordering process was simple, and the prices were reasonable. I would probably order delivery again, but only if my first choice deli wasn’t available: B&B (also on Dixwell, also delivers).

Awesome pizza! We have never eaten in the restaurant, so I can’t judge what the quality of the restaurant is like but the food is great. We always get their amazing cake along with our pizza – and soda because it comes for free with the online coupons.
I definitely recommend this place for pizza delivery!