Wiseguyz Pizzeria

I see that Logan T. likened this to Sounds Easy pizza, and I think he hit the nail on the head. This is my favorite pizza in utah valley, it’s nothing fancy or niche, but great greasy pizza. We’ve been frequenting there delivery for quite a few years now, and we still keep coming back.

Wiseguyz has amazing pizza!!! My boyfriend and I used to go here all the time, but recently the customer service has made a turn to abysmal. Multiple times we have called in to order our favorite pizza, only to find out that when we got there to pick up our pizzas that they didn’t have the most crucial ingredients to make the pizza that we wanted! The last time we called in to the Orem store about a half hour before they closed at nine. We made our way to the store and discovered that the Orem store is closed and the phones had forwarded to the Lindon location… but we hadn’t been made aware that our pizzas were at a different location. We get to Lindon right at nine and they have already closed and thrown our pizza’s away. Let’s just say that even though they have great pizza, it’s too difficult to actually get the pizza you want!

This is definitely one of the best pizzerias in Utah County. I love the whole mafia theme they have going on with their specialty pizzas and everything tastes wonderful. There’s a lot of attention to detail. The garlic knots are amazing! Much better pizza than the big chains. My only complaint is that sometimes the wait can be a little long sometimes (they are a very small local chain) and there’s no online ordering yet. However, it’s well worth it. They recently moved their tiny Orem location and I haven’t had a chance to give them a try yet at their new location off Center St.

You know what, its good. If you walk in, take a look around at what the place is, and how its set up, then you’ll get a good idea of how this pizza is going to taste. I’ve had worse, I’ve had better. I didn’t expect an artisan pizza, but for 5 buck lunch I got a couple decent sized pieces of pie, a bread knot and a coke.
Its a-​ok. For a lunch on a budget its decent pizza. Better than convenience store pizza, but not as good as some of the others around town. They know exactly who they are, and they whipped up a decent value.
It is what it is. I had no illusions. 3 ½ stars for me.

It’s okay pizza. Way too much oragano and the sauce is salty. I saw that it had high ratings and thought I’d give it a try. The crust is okay, but not too tasty. You’d be better off going somewhere else for the price.

If you’re from Utah County and you you’ve lived here for 10+ years, you might remember Sounds Easy Pizza (where Matiki’s Island Grill is now located). If you remember Sounds Easy Pizza, then you’ll know EXACTLY what Wiseguyz tastes like. Its that yuck pizza that you just cant put down.
A bit rubbery, a bit solid when cold and lacking true creativity when it comes to seasoning.
But it is good. It is different. You wont find pizza like this anywhere else in Utah County.
I personally like this place but my wife does not. I think it is polarizing.
Try it and find out.

I got some pizza here a while ago and I must admit its solid.
Little pricey for what you get, nice variety of toppings. Sauce is pretty good, crust was good.
All around the place is «good» nothing great, just good. Sounds like I may need to try a sandwich.

Yum! We ordered «da family deal» and it was great! Two 2 topping large pizzas, a side of breadsticks, and a 2 liter of soda for 20 bucks. It was all really good. The pizza is kinda inbetween a thin crust and a pan pizza crust – so just right for us. Toppings were fresh, it was nice and hot, and we will definitely go back and take some friends to share with us next time.

We’ve ordered from this place a couple of times in the past week or so from here at work. No pizzas yet, just sandwiches. The first time I called, I was told the wait would be about a ½ hour because he was making the bread, which I took as a great sign. The prices are VERY reasonable for the size of the sandwiches. They are huge. A full will easily feed 2 people, or keep for lunch the next day. The steak sandwiches are filled with extremely tender chunks of beef, and one has a creamy alfredo sauce on it — awesome. 5 stars for quality (realizing this isn’t fine dining) and the enormous quantity at a very reasonable price.