Cornerstone Pizza

Best pizza place around! Calzones are huge! And incredibly delicious. The prices are super cheap too. Definitely recommend

The pizza is ok. We had the cornerstome large pizza expecting an amazing experience but got just an average pizza. It was ok but was not worth the price. The canolis are great though and i would recommend those!

Pizza and wings are soooooo good! Authentic and great prices! The wing/​pizza deal is what keeps us coming back.

Came here for a late night bite. I wanted to get a good cheap pizza slice. I had a nice experience. My pizza was delicious, thin crust and crunchy on the border just how I like it. I wish I have gotten my order a little faster though, we were the only ones on the shop and had to wait like 15min for a few slices. But they were super good!

Got the wings. Really HUGE and made right. Flats and drumstick mix. Got bbq garlic sauce. The blue cheese is really good. Cheese all up in it. Under 13 bucks for 20 of them. Im stuffed

First time trying this place last night. Overall we liked the pizza but then again, we were sorta starving and would have eaten the box. Bit too much sauce in my opinion though. Staff was very nice and pie was ready when the girl at the counter said it would be. The place could use a face lift and WiFi would be a plus. I’m leaving room to grow as far as my review goes because we will give this place another shot I’m sure.

Since I moved away from Orlando 6 years ago, I miss this place. Pizza was always fresh and hot, and I love their crust. Funny to hear the people working the counter yell the orders to the back. LOL

This pizza is really good. Just everything is right tasteful. Big recommendations.
I had cannoli too and it was very fresh and yummy. I should’ve took pictures.

There’s been a pizza joint at this corner for more years than I remember (used to live on the south side in the 90’s), and Cornerstone has been in the spot for quite a while now. I was visiting a friend nearby and had the idea of grabbing a pie. I had not been to Cornerstone in a few years, but gave them a call anyway. When I showed up on time, my pie wasn’t ready… I had to wait 15mins extra. The tiny place shows it’s age and has a dank smell to it, so even though the staff seems nice, I would not recommend eating in. Once back at my friends place I was ready to dig in… much to my dismay, the pie was orange with grease and the spinach looked and tasted as if it was plucked from a can. Lame! I feel fortunate living on the northeast side that I have so many great pizza places to choose from…

Too bad Cornerstone Pizza didn’t have our order ready when promised. We called the day before to order 4 large pizzas for a party. When we showed up for our pick up, the restaurant was not open during the time our pizza was suppose to be ready. We ended up supporting another local pizzeria who treated their customers professionally. We liked the pizza but not the customer service. We will not be back :(

My niece and my neighbor and I went to Cornerstone for lunch today. Had calzones and a pizza. It was great! The sauce is just delicious! The cannoli was almost like New York. The young guy and the girl working the counter were both polite, helpful and efficient. Cannot wait to go back and try something new each time.

Never been to the physical location. But my bf has ordered delivery and the pizza is amazing. The first time I tried their pizza it was an orgasmic experience. Wow every time is the same. After trying Cornerstone Pizza any other pizza is just not the same. LOVE IT!!!

I order here all the time, food is good depending on what you get. I ordered the other night and the delivery driver gave me complete disrespect and attitude because I asked for my 6 dollar change back. I was still going to give him a tip even though my house is not even a light away. The driver walked away rudely saying «oh I’m sorry you didn’t like your service» and some other shit about me not giving him a tip. I call cornerstone right after to ask why I was treated that way when I just PAID for their service and the manager did not sound at all surprised and just guaranteed better service next time. Never eating from here again! Horrible service

Large one topping for eleven bucks= a win in my book. Especially when the pizza is a cheesy, salty, perfectly cooked pie. The building is old and ratty but who cares? Get takeout and nom in the comfort of your sweats.

Good pizza. I just moved to Orlando and I’ve been looking for a pizza place. This place has good pizza and prices. When I picked up my pizza it looked very family owned. I was excited to try this pizza from looking at the reviews and told the manager or owner and he was really humble. Opened the pizza in the car and rushed home it smelt amazing.
Definitely try this place out, I know if I want pizza in going to cornerstone for now on.

This is my favorite pizza place in Orlando. I just wish that I regularly received coupons from them. Their salads are also really great. If you like NY style pizza this is your place.

Cornerstone Pizza is a small mostly take out pizza place on East Michigan. Stopped in and ordered two slices of pizza for dinner one night. This is by no means a fancy place. The inside was pretty dated and there were only a few small tables and chairs.
It had a very family feel to this place. It appeared that the people eating inside the restaurant were family members of the owner. I ordered my pizza and then waited about 7 minutes while they heated it up.
I was pleasantly surprised with the pizza. It was very thin, but it had a nice crunchy thicker crust. The prices here aren’t bad either. I heard they have a great lunch special.

New Yorker here. This pizza is beyond bad, in fact it is offensive. Crust is not stretched out enough because the pizza guy doesn’t work the dough properly. Sauce is like eating battery acid. In fact if you drop a slice on the hood of your ex-​wifes car I am sure it will eat through to the engine block. Crust is completely tasteless. Never in my life have I felt further from home than during my ill advised venture into this abyss of pizza ineptness. I walked out of there in a cold sweat, got into my car and closed my eyes trying to convince myself it was a bad dream. Each time I awoke I was still there. Does anyone know if Ellio’s frozen pizza is still available? Fear not you have Cornerstone.

I’m giving them two stars. If I could do halves, I’d give them 2.5 stars. I’ve had the pizza here several times while visiting from Massachusetts.
I was not in the mood for pizza one nite, so I ordered spaghetti & meatballs. Bad move. I went to pick up my order. I got this sideways look from the counter person. Then they said that they had no knowledge of my order. They were not very apologetic about their error, but said that they could make the food in about 10 minutes. In the interim, I had to watch the counter girl and boyfriend groping each other in the lobby. That’s ok… but the food better be good. It stunk. The meatballs tasted like bread crumbs, not meat. The sauce was like Ragu. Bottom line… it’s obviously a pizza place. The quantity of the food was below average.
Next…comments about the pizza. It’s ok. Not bad… decent pizza overall. However, they skimp like crazy on the toppings. The ham, hamburg and bacon pieces are so small.
My advice… stick with a basic cheese or pepperoni pizza and check the website for specials. If I go back, it won’t be for a long time. I’ll pick up frozen pizzas at the Publix around the corner.

Totally love this place. Reminds me of a typical NY pizza parlor with pizza by the slice, huge pies and terrific sauce. I treat my employees once a month to a bunch of pizzas delivered and they count down the days to that lunch. Have picked up dinner to take home and eaten in. Those that said it was a hole are absolutely correct. But some of the best food is made at Mom and Pop places that aren’t worried about their décor. Just great food at a great price.
I think I need to pick up a pizza for dinner tonight. Mushroom and Tomato sounds good. :-)