Mike’s Pizza

I ordered online. Took about half an hour. The food was prepared and piping hot when it came. It was made to specifics. The cheeseburger was yum. Their chicken tender platter was amazing for the price.
I will definitely order again when I’m in town next time. Definitely recommend when visiting.

It’s been a year from my last review of Mike’s and it has grown to hold a special place in my heart, so much so that when it closed temporarily for renovations a few months ago, I had a minor existential crisis thinking it had closed permanently. The renovations freshened up the place and gave the order counter a better organization.
JJ and I stop by or order delivery regularly – usually a plain pie, but occasionally we add in sausage too. Mike’s is consistently good and a slice includes a thick, gooey layer of cheese, tangy sauce, and a crust that is chewy but not too hefty. Prices are still reasonable, and it does accept credit (even though it doesn’t give off that vibe).

I’d give it a zero if I could. Ordered at 11pm. They NEVER delivered my order, because they suddenly decided it was too far to deliver, even though I ordered via GrubHub and they had delivered to me before. When I called, there was no one available who could speak even broken English, and she just kept saying no and eventually hung up on me. To hell with this place, they deserve no money, no respect, and no business from me or anyone else. By the time I got this nonsense worked out, every other restaurant in my area had closed. Mike’s Crappy Pizza left me hungry.
Worst of all? They had no problem taking my money. They didn’t cancel the order. I had to get the charge reversed by GrubHub.

So me and my husband never had ordered from here before and believe me we never will again. When I called I had to repeat my address four times and spell it out twice. I still got three phone calls and the delivery driver had to text me in order to finally get my address right.
We ordered two orders of chicken fingers, a caesar salad and the mega fries. The Caesar salad was romaine and croutons with a side of obviously bought in Caesar dressing. The fries were undercooked and the bacon that topped it fatty…
But the real kicked was the RAW chicken fingers. As soon as the delivery dropped it off, we called in and let them know. It took over an hour to get a new order. The chicken fingers that arrived the second time were good, but serving anyone raw chicken is inexcusable.
Just an update to the idiot below me… A pizza place should also be able to come up with good chicken fingers and a decent salad.
.
Update: Someone from Mikes contacted me and told me that their chicken fingers are pre cooked. Please look at the picture and tell me that’s not raw?!?

Haven’t had the food yet because I haven’t gotten it! I ordered over two hours ago… Called an hour in, said they’d be here in 10 min. 50 min later… No food. I ordered from here because I’ve had their pizza and it was amazing. I DONT think I’ll be going here again just for this reason.
***officially never ordering again. Ever. An hour and 15 min later for delivery…***

Called in an order for a large pie for pick up. I was told 15 – 20 mins. Showed up at the twenty min mark. They told me it would be ready in a minute as I hear them call back to start making the pizza. Never again.

Got a slice at 1am and it was one of the best slices I’ve ever had. Highly recommended

The pizza was okay, but they’re not accommodating at all to customer requests– even when they’re paid for. I recently ordered a large pie with sausage and «Italian tomatoes», and a request for extra sauce. You would think these requests would be easy considering it’s a pizza place and I paid $ 2.50 for each topping! However, when I received the pie there was hardly any sauce or tomatoes– again I paid $ 2.50 for them. In grand total there was probably half of a tomato on the vine on my pie. I clearly wanted a lot of tomato and they did anything but deliver for that paid request.

Pulled up in a mini van full of 30 somethings. Half of us were still in the car when our slices were ready. Exactly what you want when you’re craving a NY slice: Quick, fat slices, with plastic tables and chairs outside. Let’s get down and dirty.

This is good enough pizza when you’re drunk or late night when nowhere else is open. I wouldn’t go here for dinner or order it otherwise, though.

It’s not often I rate anyone a 1 star. However, their employees don’t care at all about their customers. Their «management» may claim differently, but in all honesty, you’re better off driving elsewhere. I lived in Manayunk for over 3 years, and I’ve tried to be unbiased, but if you want great service and great food your best off calling Zestos on Ridge Avenue. Ll

Don’t see why the reviews are so low here but I personally really like the pizza here. It’s my favorite pizza place that is a not a chain. The serving sizes here are pretty big, the medium is like a large and the large is like an extra large. I guess because of their larger pizza size the prices are a tad higher. Every time I’ve came, I got the mushroom pizza. I think they put a pretty good amount of mushrooms on my pizza.
The thing about their pizza I really enjoy is that, it has this subtle sweet taste to it. It’s not like added sugar or anything but it really makes a difference to me and I enjoy the pizza so much more. I think the sweet taste comes from the tomato sauce they use? It’s this really small taste that I think most people wouldn’t notice. I will definitely be coming back to this place. I like how you get a free can of soda when you check in here!

I only order my plain pizzas from here! They have quick delivery service and the people who deliver are always friendly! Thanks for the bomb pizza :)

Mike’s pizza is hands down the best plain pie of Manayunk.
Truly a «Philadelphia Style» Pizza, and by gone they got it done. Their delivery comes in a decent amount of time, although I would recommend ordering online. Sometimes its difficult for the people working there to understand what you are saying due to a language barrier, when you order over the phone.
Other decent options from them is their buffalo chicken cheeesteaks, and their o-​la-​la french fry pizza.
Some tips, they don’t overload the pizza with toppings, so don’t expect that much. This is a hole in the wall, so don’t expect to bring a hot date, and finally I’d avoid ordering their wings, something they need to take a look at.

Mikes you did it again. Another great night ending with your crazy pizza concoctions. If you’re in the manayunk area and need some late night food mikes is where it’s at. Sooo much better than that bitch ass bitch place eddies that went out of business. You suck Eddie!

Mikes… What a disappointment, not just like oh my wings were boiled instead of fried disappointed, but like the kind of disappointed you get when your son doesn’t make it back from Iraq. For the record yes they boil their wings to insure the chewiest bite they can trick you into eating. The pizza was so soft and covered in flour it was almost inedible. I didn’t order this pizza rare so they should have cooked it for more than the time it took for them to microwave their hot pockets I’m sure they feed their kids for dinner. How can you look yourself in the mirror and call yourself an owner of a pizzeria. They didn’t even put the pepperoni on the pizza and when I called they offered to bring some pepperoni and 3 dollars cash back to my door step so I could put it on myself. It was at this point of the night that this was no longer about pizza this was personal. Mike (if that is your real name) your pizza is a joke, you probably have your 8 year old kid working the counter and turning the pizzas for you because if you run your business like you do your food I can only assume you’re doing something illegal and disgusting. Eating your pizza was the food equivalent of the trail of tears. The mozzarella sticks weren’t bad though.

Pizza itself was decent, but don’t call it «meat lover’s pizza» if there isn’t a generous helping of meat. There was a sprinkling of meat.
If you’re a meat lover, don’t bother with this place. If you are someone who likes a large piece of pizza with 1.5 pieces of pepperoni on it, then go for it.

Eh… decent pizza. $ 15 for a large pie. The slices were big and cheesy but the crust wasn’t crisp enough. It could have stayed in the over for a couple more minutes.
I can’t say that the pizza was bad, however I probably won’t recommend it to someone if they ask where they can grab a good slice of pizza. Simply put, Mike’s is a local Manayunk pizza shop serving up some OK pizza.
Also, don’t come with a huge party because they only have a few small tables in the back room.

There are few restaurants that have angered me enough to post a one star review, but this poor excuse for a pizza delivery service has warranted the following scathing retort.
Pizza delivery has one primary purpose: to deliver my goddamn pizza. How this place managed to completely fail is beyond reason…
We placed our order at 6:25 for delivery of three pizzas and were told they would arrive shortly. As we are located on Rector street within walking distance we assumed they would not only deliver at a reasonable time, but also that they would know the whereabouts of the largest church in the area which is visible from their pizza place.
With that being said, 45 minutes later 20 people were hungry and annoyed. The manager (?) assured us the delivery driver was 2 minutes away. 30 minutes later I called again. Not only did he seem mystified by my annoyance he also said they would «be right there» and claimed our location wasn’t close by.
In conclusion, 20 people are still hungry and not one person will be ordering from this negligent establishment in the future.

This place is such a rip off they use their location to lure people after the bars and charge and arm and a leg for a slice of pizza
Pizza is alright but definitely not worth the price.
2am this place is packed with drunk people.