Geno’s Pizza

We stopped by here on Tuesday night after visiting the Comedy Barn (recommended). It was around 10:30 pm, and almost everything is closed at that time in February, even if their sign says otherwise (Mellow Mushroom). The wife and I wanted pizza, so we found Geno’s. I was a bit concerned due to the less than stellar reviews, but I was, thankfully, surprised.
I suppose they recently moved, as my GPS sent me on the other end of Pigeon Forge. They are located just past Dixie Stampede if you are heading toward Gatlinburg. It was sort of hard to find at night… they lack a huge, flashing sign like some other places.
There was one lady working behind the counter, and she was extraordinarily nice. We had a large Meats Pizza for $ 22.95, tax included. I see that other reviews complained about the price, but this is similar to most other pizza, in my opinion, except perhaps Little Caesar’s. We had our pizza to go, and although it wasn’t still piping hot by the time we got it back to the cabin, it was still amazing. We had the pan pizza, but they also offer hand-​tossed and thin crust. The pizza was cooked perfectly. The crust was excellent, not greasy like most pan crusts. They have the yummy sausage, not the weird tasting sausage that some joints use. My only complaint is that the toppings weren’t very evenly spread across the pizza, which I only noticed when I looked at the picture I took of the pizza prior to writing this review.
It seems most of the negative reviews deal with the delivery aspect of the business. I can’t comment on that, but they have a seating area, as well as take-​out, if you’d prefer to avoid the seemingly spotty delivery.
The décor here is pretty outdated, but the kitchen area appeared to be clean. I will definitely be back!

Stopped in 2 days ago. Friendly guys working. They recommended some things. We got 3 pizzas, 2 cheese breads and 2 bread sticks for around $ 60. They gave us discounts and showed us their coupons. Definitely one of the best pizza places in the area.

Decided to try this place because it was honestly one of the only pizza places open that were not a national chain. I was a little worried based on previous reviews, so much to my surprise the pizza was excellent. We went with a take out all meat pan crust pizza. The pizza was cooked perfectly, wasn’t greasy like most pan pizzas. The pizza was very well balanced. I would have given it 5 stars but I do think that $ 23 for a large pizza is just a little high. Plus the restaurant is kind of hard to find due to it recently moving locations. Overall, I will likely return on my next visit.

Awful! Overpriced waste of time and money! Ordered a pizza last night they took over an hour to deliver and of course it was cold! AYOR!

Overpriced and underwhelming. Traveling through and thought I’d order from a local pizzeria. Two medium 2 topping pizzas cost $ 36! Seriously? I kept my order because I’m thinking, «this must be some darn good pizza» Upon delivery, pizza was not very hot, the crust was flavorless and my pineapple was hard and chewy. I do not recommend this place to anyone. Order from someone else!